Last updated: November 16, 2026

Medicare Supplement Premium Review: What to Check Before You Shop

A Medicare Supplement (Medigap) premium review compares what you pay now with what the same plan letter costs elsewhere, and checks why your premium moved. Because benefits are standardized by plan letter (with the exceptions noted below), the review is about price and how that price will behave over time. What it can change depends mostly on timing: inside a protected window an insurer cannot use your health, and outside one it can. Staying with the policy you have is a legitimate result of a review.

What a Premium Review Is, and What It Is Not

A premium review is a fact-gathering exercise. You collect the details that determine your premium, learn which of them can be questioned, and compare them with what is available. It is not a promise that you will pay less, and it is not a push toward a new policy.

Medicare.gov says each insurance company decides how it sets the price of its Medigap policies, and that premiums vary widely depending on the company, the plan and where you live. The CMS booklet *Choosing a Medigap Policy* adds that the premium is the only difference between policies with the same plan letter sold by different companies, and that there can be big differences in what companies charge for the same coverage. That is why a review is worth doing. The answer is still not automatic. A lower quote on paper may come with a different pricing method, a discount that depends on conditions, or a health-screening step that your current policy never required of you.

The standardization also has limits. Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin standardize Medigap in their own way, and Medicare SELECT and high-deductible versions of a letter work differently from the standard version.

Three questions organize everything below:

  1. What exactly do I own, and how is the premium built?
  2. Why did it change, and is the change one the policy anticipated?
  3. If I wanted to move, would the new insurer be allowed to use my health history?

The third question often decides the outcome, so it is covered in its own section and in more depth on our guide to changing your Medigap policy.

The Documents and Details to Gather

A reviewer, whether that is you, a family member, a counselor or an agent, can do very little with “I pay about this much for Plan G.” The details below turn that into something checkable. Most are on the policy schedule, the outline of coverage you received at application, and your most recent renewal or rate notice.

ItemWhere to find itWhy it matters
Plan letter and policy formPolicy schedule or ID cardConfirms what you own. CMS notes Plans D and G with coverage starting on or after June 1, 2010 have different benefits than earlier Plans D and G.
Effective date and your age on that datePolicy scheduleNeeded to tell whether your pricing method uses your age when you bought.
Pricing methodOutline of coverage, policy renewal provision, or a call to the insurerCommunity-rated, issue-age-rated or attained-age-rated policies behave differently over time.
Current premium and payment modeLatest bill or noticeMonthly, quarterly or yearly payment can carry different prices.
Premium history for several yearsOld bills, bank statements, past noticesCMS suggests asking whether the premium has increased in the last three years and by how much.
Discounts you receiveApplication, bill or insurerHousehold, electronic payment and yearly payment discounts can be lost or conditional.
Your address and the address on filePolicy scheduleMedicare.gov says where you live affects price.
Tobacco status on the applicationApplication copySome insurers use smoker and non-smoker rates.
Special featuresOutline of coverageMedicare SELECT network rules, a high-deductible option, or extra benefits added with approval.

If you cannot find the outline of coverage, the insurer can send another. Ohio’s Medicare supplement rule requires the outline to state the premium and payment mode for each plan offered to the applicant, to illustrate all possible premiums for that applicant, and to explain any smoker and non-smoker rates or household discounts. For a policy bought years ago, that document is often the clearest record of how the price was meant to work.

One more item belongs on the pile: your Medicare Part B premium. It is billed separately from the Medigap premium, and the standard amount, currently $202.90 per month, changes through Medicare rather than through your supplement insurer. People sometimes read a larger total outflow as a Medigap increase when part of it is Part B. Separate the two lines before drawing any conclusion.

How to Read a Renewal or Rate-Change Notice

A notice that your premium is going up is the usual trigger for a review. Reading it carefully answers half the questions above.

  • The effective date. Note when the new premium starts and whether it matches your policy anniversary or a billing date.
  • The reason given, if any. A notice may describe an age-related step, a general rate increase on your policy form, a change tied to Medicare benefit changes, or the end of a discount. These call for different responses.
  • The new amount, in dollars and percent. Calculate the percent yourself from the old and new figures. If your old premium was $150 and the new one is $162, the increase is $12, which is 8 percent of $150.
  • The plan letter and form. Confirm nothing has changed except the price. Plan benefits are standardized, so a notice should not reduce what a lettered plan covers.
  • Contact details for questions and for the state regulator. Insurers must file their rates, and the Ohio Department of Insurance can answer questions about how rate filings work.

What Ohio’s rule says about rate changes is limited but useful. An insurer may not use or change premium rates for a Medicare supplement policy unless the rates, rating schedule and supporting documentation have been filed with and approved by the superintendent of insurance, and the rule requires annual rate filings. The rule’s loss ratio standard expects an individual policy form to return at least 65 percent of earned premiums as benefits, estimated over the entire period for which rates are computed. The rule also requires the policy’s renewal provision to disclose any automatic renewal premium increases based on the policyholder’s age.

We did not find a rule-specified advance-notice period for an ordinary rate increase in that rule, and the Revised Code section on approval of sickness and accident premium rates (R.C. 3923.021) deals with filings and approval by the superintendent rather than notice to policyholders. The rule does require a notice at least 30 days before the annual effective date of Medicare benefit changes, including when any premium adjustment tied to those changes will be made. For a general rate increase, your policy and the notice itself are the places to find the timing, and the insurer can confirm it by phone.

For the forces that push Medigap rates up, such as claims costs and pool shifts, see our Answer on Medicare Supplement rate increases. For how pricing methods work, see attained-age, issue-age and community-rated pricing, and our fuller page on why Medigap premiums differ.

A Hypothetical Review of a Rate Notice

Consider a hypothetical retiree, using round numbers that are not real prices. Her Plan G premium was $150 a month and the notice raises it to $162. The yearly cost moves from $1,800 to $1,944, a difference of $144.

She gathers the items above and finds three things. First, her policy is attained-age rated, so part of the increase may be her birthday and part may be a general rate change. Second, a household discount she received has ended because her spouse left the policy, which accounts for some of the change. Third, her bank statement shows the Part B premium also rose this year, which is a separate line.

With that picture she can make three calls: one to the insurer about the discount and pricing method, one for current Plan G quotes at her age and ZIP code, and one to learn whether a new insurer would use her health history. If a new insurer would, and she has a condition that makes an approval uncertain, the review may conclude that the $144 difference is smaller than the risk of a decline or a higher rate. If no health screening would apply, the comparison is simply arithmetic. Either result is a finished review.

What a Review Can Change, and What It Cannot

Some things a review can change quickly and without any new application. Others depend on underwriting.

LeverNeeds a new application?Main limit
Add or restore a discount (payment mode, electronic payment, household)NoDepends on the insurer’s conditions.
Correct tobacco status or address errorsNoMust be accurate and may change the price in either direction.
Move to the same plan letter with another insurerYesThe new insurer may use health questions unless a window or right applies.
Move to a different plan letterYesAlso a coverage decision, not only a price decision.
Move to a high-deductible Plan GYesYou take on a yearly deductible in exchange for a different premium.
Move between Medicare Advantage and MedigapYesHas its own timing rules and Medigap consequences.

The central fact is underwriting. Your six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period begins when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, and during it an insurer cannot use your health to deny you or set your price. Outside it, an insurer can do both unless a guaranteed-issue right applies. OSHIIP, the Ohio Department of Insurance’s Medicare counseling program, lists no annual enrollment for Medicare supplement insurance, and our reading of Ohio’s rule found no yearly switching window either. That means there is no October-to-December equivalent for Medigap. You can apply at any time, and the insurer’s right to use health answers follows the same rules as always.

The practical effect is that two people with the same policy and the same premium can have very different review outcomes. A healthy person may find an approved, lower-priced alternative. A person with a recent diagnosis may find that no alternative is available at any price, while their current policy keeps renewing because standardized Medigap policies bought after 1992 are automatically renewed every year, even if you have health problems. The CMS booklet says the insurer can drop you only if you stop paying the premium, you were not truthful on the application, or the insurer goes bankrupt or out of business. Our page on changing your Medigap policy lays out the guaranteed-issue situations and the sequence that keeps you covered, and our Answer on Medigap medical underwriting describes what insurers ask.

Checking a Quote Against Your Current Policy

If you decide to gather quotes, hold the inputs constant so the numbers mean something.

  • Same plan letter. Compare Plan G with Plan G. CMS says to compare the same lettered plan across companies.
  • Same age and ZIP code. Ask for the premium at your age today, not at 65.
  • Same payment mode. A monthly quote and an annual-payment quote are not comparable.
  • Same discounts. Ask which discounts are already included, and what ends them.
  • Same tobacco status. Smoker and non-smoker rates can differ.
  • Shape over time. Ask whether the policy is community-rated, issue-age-rated or attained-age-rated. If it is attained-age rated, CMS suggests asking how frequently the premium increases due to your age.
  • History. Ask whether the premium has increased in the last three years and by how much.

Note the issue-age trap in particular. If your current policy is issue-age rated, its price reflects your age when you bought it. A new policy is priced from your age when you apply for it, so a lower-looking new quote can start from a different footing. This is one reason the same dollar figure can mean different things for two policies.

Then compare total expected cost over a horizon you care about, not just the first-year number. A quote that is lower today and rises faster can cost more by the time you reach your late seventies, and a quote that is higher today and rises slowly can cost less. Nobody can know in advance how any policy will be repriced, but the pricing method tells you which direction the built-in pressure runs.

High-Deductible Plan G: A Different Kind of Premium Review

A high-deductible Plan G is the option people most often ask about when the premium feels heavy. Ohio’s rule describes a Plan G With High Deductible, and the CMS booklet says that if you choose a high-deductible option you must pay the first portion of deductibles, copayments and coinsurance for covered services that Medicare does not pay before the policy pays anything. The deductible amount is adjusted every year, so use the figure the insurer quotes for the current year, and there is a separate, smaller deductible for foreign travel emergency care. After the deductible is met, the plan covers the same benefits as standard Plan G. Not every insurer sells it, and the premium you pay each month does not count toward the deductible. Ohio’s rule says the Part B deductible you pay does count toward the high deductible. Our page on high-deductible Plan G covers the mechanics.

The question for a premium review is whether the premium saving outweighs the added exposure in a bad year. Consider a hypothetical with made-up round premiums. Suppose standard Plan G costs $160 a month and a high-deductible Plan G costs $60 a month. The premium difference is $100 a month, or $1,200 a year. The deductible changes every year, so this example calls it the stated deductible; in a real comparison, substitute the amount the insurer quotes.

  • In a year with little care, the person with the high-deductible plan keeps the $1,200 and pays only the Medicare cost-sharing they incur.
  • In a year with large Medicare cost-sharing, such as a hospital stay plus follow-up care, the person pays up to the full stated deductible before the plan pays. Under standard Plan G they would have paid only the Part B deductible, currently $283. Because that Part B deductible counts toward the high deductible, the added exposure is the stated deductible minus the Part B deductible, set against the $1,200 saved on premiums. In such a year the high-deductible plan comes out ahead only if that difference is smaller than the premium saved.
  • The premiums also behave over time. If the premium gap widens or narrows in later years, so does the comparison.

The high-deductible plan works as a bet on your own year-to-year use of care, and some people have cash set aside to absorb a bad year while others do not. This page cannot say which describes you. Ask for both quotes, note the stated deductible, and decide with your own savings and health history in view.

When Staying With Your Current Policy Is the Right Outcome

A review that ends with no change is not a wasted review. Staying may make sense when:

  • the quoted savings are small compared with the chance of being declined or priced higher;
  • you hold a plan you could not buy today, such as Plan F if you were first eligible for Medicare before 2020 (CMS says people new to Medicare on or after January 1, 2020 cannot buy Plans C and F);
  • your policy is older and CMS notes a policy bought before June 1, 2010 may offer coverage a newer policy does not;
  • a health condition would likely lead to a decline or an unaffordable rate and no protected window applies;
  • the insurer’s rate history has been modest and its service has met your needs;
  • your pricing method is issue-age or community-rated and a switch would reset your starting age.

It can also make sense to stay while keeping an eye on the policy, repeating the review when a notice arrives or your circumstances change. Moving to Medicare Advantage is a different decision with its own tradeoffs, and CMS warns that leaving Medigap for Advantage may mean you cannot get your old policy back. Our Medigap or Medicare Advantage guide frames that choice.

Questions to Ask Any Agent or Insurer

Whoever helps you, the same questions apply. Several come from the CMS booklet.

  • Do you use medical underwriting for this policy, and do I qualify for protected enrollment?
  • Do you price it as community-rated, issue-age-rated or attained-age-rated?
  • If attained-age rated, how often does the premium increase because of my age?
  • Has the premium increased in the last three years, and by how much?
  • What discounts are included, and what ends them?
  • Is there a waiting period for pre-existing conditions?
  • Is this a Medicare SELECT policy, and would I be limited to certain hospitals or doctors?
  • Which insurers can you quote me on, and which can you not?
  • How are you paid, and does that differ by insurer? Our Answer on how insurance agents get paid for Medicare plans explains why the question is reasonable.

CMS also lists practices that are illegal for agents and insurers, including pressuring or lying to get you to switch, selling you a second policy unless you state in writing that you plan to cancel the first, and asking family-history questions. If something feels wrong, the State Insurance Department and OSHIIP can help. OSHIIP’s hotline is 800-686-1578.

How We Help With a Premium Review

We are an independent insurance agency in Bethel, Ohio, serving the Cincinnati area and licensed in 25 states. A review conversation usually starts with your policy schedule and latest notice, whether any protected window or guaranteed-issue right applies, and how the pricing method on your policy is likely to behave. We can explain what a new application would involve and how to keep your current coverage in place until a new policy is approved. We will say so if the right result looks like no change. For a walk-through of your own policy, contact our office. For the wider set of choices, see our Medicare Supplement plans hub.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is my Medigap premium too high?

It depends on what you compare it with. Start by comparing the same plan letter, at your current age and ZIP code, from other insurers, and check how your pricing method moves over time. Medicare.gov says premiums vary widely by company, plan and location, so a gap between quotes is common. Whether you can act on a gap depends on whether a new insurer may use your health history.

Can a premium review lower my premium without switching?

Sometimes. A review can find a missing discount, an outdated tobacco or address entry, or a payment-mode difference. These depend on the insurer’s own conditions, so ask what applies to your policy. A pricing method or age-based step built into your policy generally does not change on request.

Does Ohio have a time of year when I can switch Medigap without health questions?

Not that we found. OSHIIP lists no annual enrollment for Medicare supplement insurance, and Ohio’s rule shows no yearly window. Protection from health-based pricing applies in your six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period and in specific guaranteed-issue situations, as covered on our page about changing your policy.

Will my premium go up every year?

Medicare.gov says Medigap premium amounts typically increase each year. How much depends on your pricing method, your insurer’s claims experience and the rates approved by the Ohio superintendent of insurance. An attained-age policy has an age-based step on top of general increases.

Should I keep my plan if the premium keeps rising?

That is a personal decision, and keeping it is a reasonable outcome. A policy bought after 1992 is automatically renewed each year even if you have health problems, so the insurer cannot drop it because of your health. The tradeoff is price, which you can weigh against the chance that a new insurer would decline you or charge more.

Is a high-deductible Plan G worth reviewing?

It is worth a quote if you want a lower monthly premium and can absorb a yearly deductible. The deductible amount is adjusted every year, and the plan pays the same benefits as standard Plan G after you meet it. The comparison depends on your use of care and savings, so look at both the premium saved and the amount you could owe in a bad year.

What documents do I need for a review?

Your policy schedule or ID card, your most recent renewal or rate notice, the outline of coverage, and a few years of premium history. Also note any discounts, your tobacco status on the application, and your payment mode. If anything is missing, the insurer can send a copy.

Want a second look at your Medicare Supplement premium?

Bring your renewal notice and we’ll go through it with you, including what a change would involve.

This page is general education about Medicare Supplement (Medigap) insurance, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules, costs and plan availability vary by state, county and insurer, and we do not offer every plan available in your area. We’re an independent agency, not affiliated with or endorsed by the Medicare program, the Social Security Administration or any government agency. For official information, visit Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE.