About The Modern Insurance Store

The Modern Insurance Store was Founded on One Question...

Together, we have over 20 years of combined experience in the insurance industry.

We share an enthusiasm for insurance, we also recognize how customers can be served much, much better. 

Having an open mind eventually led us to think: Why not form a company of our own that isn’t bound by tradition but instead reinvents the customer experience?

 That’s how The Modern Insurance Store was created.

Anthony Selm

Co-Founder and Co-Owner

John Daniel Farlow

Co-Founder and Co-Owner

To date we’ve written, between us, more than 10,000 insurance policies that span a wide range of coverage. So we know the business extremely well.

We also use technology to modernize insurance practices to bring them into the 21st century and give clients vastly better service.

Among other things, we use social media, texting and the internet (including Skype) to make the whole process faster and easier for you, the client.

Tyler Mason - Licensed Agent

Tyler Mason

Licensed Agent

brad derflinger

Brad Derflinger

Licensed Agent

We’re always there when you need us.

We understand how frustrating it can be when you can’t get a hold of your insurance company right away. So we make it our policy to always be readily available.

Result: We’ve developed a strong, satisfied customer base in Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Missouri, Wisconsin, Tennessee and North Carolina. To these customers, even at a distance, we’re like true neighbors thanks to the internet and our responsive service.

 We have no incentive to promote one company over another.

The insurance plan you have now may be offered from an agent who only represents one company. This is a problem.

We knew there were much better options out there.

That’s why our agency offers products from dozens of major insurance companies, which give us the ability make recommendations that best suit your company or families needs.

And because our range is so broad, you can use us as your one-stop insurance provider for virtually everything.

 Let’s get acquainted!

Insurance Products We Offer

Let us help you plan, prepare, and protect what matters most.

Health Insurance Icon

Health Insurance

Overwhelmed by the cost and complexity of health insurance? We can help

Life Insurance Icon

Life Insurance

Life insurance is an inexpensive benefit that can have a large impact