Last updated: November 16, 2026

Annuities: Fixed Indexed and Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuities

An annuity is a contract with an insurance company: you pay a premium, and the insurer promises to pay income on a regular basis for a period you choose, including, if you elect it, the rest of your life. This guide focuses on two kinds of fixed deferred annuity, the fixed indexed annuity (FIA) and the multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA), and it explains how each works, what is and is not guaranteed, and how to decide whether either belongs in a retirement plan. Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank deposits, and they are not FDIC-insured.

What an annuity is, and the two timing choices

The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) describes an annuity in its Buyer’s Guide as a contract with an insurance company in which the insurer promises to pay you income on a regular basis for a period you choose, including the rest of your life. That promise is what separates annuities from most other financial products. A savings account, a bond fund or a certificate of deposit does not make a lifetime income promise by itself.

Annuities differ first by when income starts:

  • Immediate annuities begin paying soon after you buy them. You hand the insurer a lump sum and receive payments on a schedule, often for life or for a set number of years. The money is generally committed once payments start.
  • Deferred annuities begin paying at a later date you choose. Until then the contract is in an accumulation period, and its value changes according to the type of annuity. Later there is a payout period, when the contract can make income payments, though you can also take money out other ways.

Both FIAs and MYGAs are deferred annuities. Most deferred annuities share a handful of traits, according to the NAIC: a basic death benefit that usually pays the greater of the account value or a minimum guaranteed surrender value; a surrender charge if you take money out too early; tax-deferred earnings; and optional riders, usually at extra cost. Tax-deferred means the tax is postponed, not eliminated. You generally owe ordinary income tax on the earnings when you take them out, and a 10 percent additional federal tax may apply to early withdrawals before age 59 and a half. Our guide to how fixed annuities are taxed explains the rules and the common exceptions.

The contract families, side by side

The word “annuity” covers several quite different products. The table below is a map, not a ranking, and no family is better in every situation.

FamilyHow the value changesWho bears the investment riskRegulatory category
Fixed annuityThe insurer declares an interest rate, with a contractual minimumThe insurerInsurance product, regulated by state insurance departments
Multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA)A declared fixed rate that is held for several years rather than reset annuallyThe insurerInsurance product
Fixed indexed annuity (FIA)Interest credits are linked to changes in a market index through a formula, typically with a floor of zero on index creditsThe insurer, within contract limitsInsurance product
Variable annuityValue rises and falls with investment subaccounts you chooseYouSecurity, sold under securities rules
Registered index-linked annuity (RILA)Linked to an index, with a buffer or floor that limits some, but not all, lossesYou bear losses beyond the buffer or floorSecurity, sold under securities rules
Immediate annuity (SPIA)Converts a lump sum into a payment stream starting soonSet by the contract and the payout option you chooseInsurance product

Variable annuities and RILAs are securities. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide notes that a person selling a variable annuity must be registered with FINRA through a broker-dealer, and the Securities and Exchange Commission has published an investor testing report on RILAs that explains buffers and floors. We mention them here only for contrast. We do not offer them, and the rest of this guide is about fixed products.

Where fixed indexed annuities and MYGAs sit

Both products are fixed annuities in the NAIC’s sense. The NAIC describes fixed annuities as guaranteeing at least a minimum interest rate, with the insurance company setting the rates, and describes fixed indexed annuities as a type of fixed annuity. Unlike a variable annuity, you do not choose the underlying investments. What differs is how growth is determined and what you trade away for it.

A multi-year guaranteed annuity is a fixed deferred annuity whose interest rate is declared up front and held for a stated number of years. Interest credits follow a rate you can read in the contract, which makes the result easy to forecast. Many people compare a MYGA to a bank certificate of deposit, but the two differ in who issues them, how they are protected, and how they are taxed; our MYGA vs. CD vs. Treasury comparison sets them side by side.

A fixed indexed annuity credits interest based on changes in a market index, such as the S&P 500, using a formula the contract spells out. You are not investing in the index itself. The NAIC explains that the formula often credits only part of an index change, through terms such as participation rates, cap rates and spread rates, and that if the index falls over the index term, zero interest is credited for that term. The SEC adds that the index gain is generally computed without dividends, that the insurer commonly can change participation rates, caps and spreads periodically, and that an investor can still lose money by cancelling early because of surrender charges.

In plain terms, a MYGA tends to be about predictability to a date, and an FIA tends to be about the possibility of larger index-linked credits and, in some contracts, optional lifetime income features, at the cost of more moving parts and less certainty about each year’s credit. Neither one is a guarantee of a particular outcome. Both involve limited access to your money during a surrender period, and both depend on the insurer’s ability to pay.

A decision map: what problem are you solving?

Annuity decisions go better when they start from a problem rather than from a product. The questions below are a way of finding which part of this guide to read first. They are prompts for conversation, not recommendations.

If your question is…Contract type to read about firstStart here
“I want to know what a fixed rate will do for me over a set number of years.”MYGAMYGA guide
“I am comparing a MYGA with a CD or Treasury.”MYGAMYGA vs. CD vs. Treasury
“I want growth linked to an index, with a floor on index credits.”FIAFixed indexed annuity guide
“I want to understand lifetime income riders.”FIAFIA income riders
“I cannot decide between the two.”BothFIA vs. MYGA comparison
“I want to know what happens if the insurer fails.”AnyRatings and guaranty associations
“I want to know how annuity income affects Medicare premiums.”AnyAnnuities and Medicare
“I am about to sign something.”AnyBuying checklist

Three further framing questions help before any product is chosen:

  1. When will you need this money? A surrender period is a promise you make to the insurer about time. If the answer is “possibly sooner than the surrender period ends,” that is important information.
  2. What would a bad outcome look like? For a MYGA, it might be a low renewal rate or the need for cash before the term ends. For an FIA, it might be index credits that are smaller than you expected, or rider fees that you did not plan for.
  3. What else do you already have? Social Security, a pension, retirement accounts and cash reserves all affect whether an annuity is solving a real gap or duplicating something you already have.

What annuities do not do

A fair guide has to be clear about limits. A few points apply across the whole family:

  • Annuities are not FDIC-insured. The FDIC lists annuities among the financial products that fall outside deposit insurance, even when they are sold through a bank.
  • Guarantees depend on the insurer. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide states that all product guarantees depend on the insurance company’s financial strength and claims-paying ability. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails, subject to per-person limits that vary by state. In Ohio, for example, the statute caps the association’s limit for the present value of annuity benefits at a stated dollar amount per life; see our Ohio retirees page for the figures and the source.
  • Surrender charges can reduce what you receive. The SEC cautions that a surrender charge can mean receiving less than the purchase payments if you cancel early. Our pages on FIA surrender charges and MYGA surrender charges and market value adjustments show how those provisions work.
  • Rates and terms are not promised until the contract is issued. We do not publish current rates or caps, because they change and because the contract you are issued controls.
  • They are not right for everyone. Some people are better served by simpler alternatives, and some by a different type of annuity entirely. Our FIA suitability page and MYGA suitability page discuss who might and might not consider each.

For a broader, shorter overview of the risk side, see our existing article on annuity risks and protections, which this guide expands and does not contradict.

How this guide is organized

The guide has two main branches, plus shared pages that apply to both. Each page is written to stand on its own, so you can read in any order.

Fixed indexed annuities (FIAs)

Start with the complete guide to fixed indexed annuities, then go deeper where your questions are:

Multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs)

Start with the complete guide to MYGAs, then continue with:

Shared pages

A short reading path for first-time readers

If you are new to annuities, this order tends to work:

  1. Read the glossary quickly so the vocabulary is familiar.
  2. Read the guide to whichever product you are curious about, MYGAs or FIAs.
  3. Read the comparison page, even if you have already decided; it shows what the other path would look like.
  4. Read about safety and guaranty associations and taxes, because those two topics change the result for almost everyone.
  5. Use the buying checklist before you meet with anyone, including us.

How we approach annuities

The Modern Insurance Store is an independent insurance agency based in Bethel and serving the Cincinnati area, and we are licensed in 25 states. Our work centers on Medicare, life insurance, long-term care and annuities, and you can read more about who we are and how we describe working as independent agents. We write these pages to explain how the products work, including the downsides, so that you can ask better questions of any agent, including us.

A few standards guide how we write and talk about annuities:

  • We do not promise returns, income or savings, and we do not publish current rates, caps or participation rates.
  • We describe annuities as insurance contracts with guarantees that depend on the issuer, not as deposits.
  • We encourage you to read the NAIC Buyer’s Guide, which the insurer or agent is expected to provide, and the contract’s disclosure before you decide.
  • We encourage you to talk with a tax professional or attorney about tax and legal questions. Nothing here is tax, legal or investment advice.

In many states, a free look or right-to-return period lets you review a contract after you receive it. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says the length is usually between 10 and 30 days and is stated in the contract. Because the exact period depends on your state and your purchase, check your own contract, and see the Ohio page if you live in Ohio.

If you have questions after reading, you can contact us. We would rather answer a question before you buy than after.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between a fixed indexed annuity and a MYGA?

A MYGA credits a declared fixed interest rate for a stated number of years, so the growth is a number you can read in the contract. A fixed indexed annuity credits interest through a formula tied to a market index, with a floor, commonly zero, that keeps index credits from going below that level. The FIA has more moving parts, including caps, participation rates and spreads that the insurer may be able to change, and the MYGA is generally simpler to forecast.

Are annuities FDIC-insured?

No. The FDIC does not insure annuities, even when they are sold through a bank. Guarantees depend on the issuing insurer’s financial strength and claims-paying ability, and state life and health guaranty associations provide limited protection with per-person limits that vary by state.

Can I lose money in a fixed indexed annuity or MYGA?

The index-linked credit in a fixed indexed annuity does not go below zero for a period, but you can still receive less than you put in if you cancel early and a surrender charge applies, as the SEC cautions. Rider fees can also reduce value. In a MYGA, early withdrawal can trigger a surrender charge and, in some contracts, a market value adjustment that may raise or lower what you receive.

Are variable annuities and RILAs covered in this guide?

Only for contrast. They are securities products sold by securities-licensed professionals, and they carry investment risk that you bear. This guide is about fixed deferred annuities, which are insurance products.

How long do I have to change my mind after buying an annuity?

Many states provide a free look period, and the NAIC Buyer’s Guide says it is usually 10 to 30 days after you receive the contract. The exact length depends on your state, the type of purchase and the contract, so read the contract’s right-to-return language and note the date you received it.

Do you quote current rates on this site?

No. Rates, caps and participation rates change often and are not promised until a contract is issued, so we explain how they work instead of quoting them. To talk about your situation, you are welcome to reach out through the contact page.

Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.

Retirement Planning With Annuities

Start here if you are thinking about lifetime income, protecting assets, or paying for care:

Ready to talk through your options?

It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.