Last updated: November 16, 2026

Why Medigap Premiums Differ: Rating Methods, Discounts and Underwriting Classes

Outside Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin, the same Medigap plan letter pays the same benefits whichever insurer sells it, so the price differences come from how each insurer builds the premium. The main drivers are the rating method (community-rated, issue-age-rated or attained-age-rated), where you live, discounts, tobacco status, and, outside protected windows, medical underwriting. Ohio’s Medicare supplement rule does not appear to require one rating method, but it requires rates to be filed and approved and the pricing basis to be disclosed.

Same Benefits, Different Prices

Medigap plans are standardized by letter. The CMS booklet *Choosing a Medigap Policy* says the benefits in each lettered plan are the same no matter which insurance company sells it, and that the premium is the only difference between policies with the same plan letter sold by different companies. The Ohio Department of Insurance’s OSHIIP program makes the same two points in its Welcome to Medicare materials: plans are standardized, and plan premiums vary between companies.

That standardization is the reason premium differences deserve an explanation. If a Plan N from one insurer covers what a Plan N from another covers, a price gap cannot come from richer benefits. It comes from some combination of the factors in the rest of this page. Medicare.gov says premiums vary widely depending on the insurance company, the plan and where you live, and the CMS booklet says there can be big differences in what insurers charge for the same coverage.

A few things look like price differences but are differences in what is being sold:

  • Older policies. CMS notes Plans D and G with coverage starting on or after June 1, 2010 have different benefits than earlier Plans D and G, and a policy bought before that date may offer coverage a newer one does not.
  • Plans closed to new buyers. Plans C and F cannot be bought by people new to Medicare on or after January 1, 2020, so a Plan F premium compares only for people who were eligible earlier.
  • Medicare SELECT. CMS says these policies require you to use certain hospitals and sometimes doctors to get full benefits, and the premium may be lower. It is a different arrangement, not only a different price.
  • High-deductible options. Plans F and G can come with a yearly deductible you pay first, in some states and when an insurer offers it. The amount is adjusted annually, so use the figure the insurer quotes. Ohio’s rule describes a Plan G With High Deductible.
  • Extra benefits. Ohio’s rule lets an insurer offer, with the superintendent’s approval, an additional form of the same plan for new or innovative benefits, and the outline of coverage must explain them. CMS suggests asking whether an insurer offers discounts or additional benefits.
  • Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin. These states standardize Medigap differently, so this page does not describe them.

Before comparing any two prices, confirm that you are comparing the same letter, the same form type and the same options. Our page on reviewing a Medigap premium gives a checklist for that.

The Three Rating Methods

CMS says each Medigap policy can be priced one of three ways, and that the way the insurer sets the price affects how much you pay now and in the future.

MethodHow the premium is setWhat happens as you ageCMS’s description of the tradeoff
Community-rated (also called no-age-rated)Generally the same premium for everyone, regardless of age or genderYour age is not a factor; premiums can still rise for inflation and other reasonsYour premium is not based on your age
Issue-age-rated (also called entry-age-rated)Based on your age when you buy the policyYour premium does not rise because you get older; it can still rise for other reasonsPremiums are lower for people who buy at a younger age
Attained-age-ratedBased on your current ageThe premium goes up as you get older, plus any general increasesLow for younger buyers; may be least expensive at first and can eventually become the most expensive

The table does not tell you which insurer will quote lower for you today. It tells you what shape each premium takes over time. For the long version of each method, see our Answer on attained-age, issue-age and community-rated pricing.

A Hypothetical Comparison Over Ten Years

Consider a hypothetical, with invented round numbers that are not real prices. Quote A is attained-age rated and starts at $100 a month at age 65, rising $7 a month each year because of age. Quote B is issue-age rated at $130 a month and stays level. To isolate the effect of the method, assume neither has any general rate increase, though in practice both would see some.

Year (age)Quote A monthlyQuote A running totalQuote B monthlyQuote B running total
1 (65)$100$1,200$130$1,560
5 (69)$128$6,840$130$7,800
6 (70)$135$8,460$130$9,360
9 (73)$156$13,824$130$14,040
10 (74)$163$15,780$130$15,600

Quote A costs less each month through year 5, costs more each month from year 6, and costs more in total from year 10. The arithmetic: A’s monthly premium in year n is $100 plus $7 times (n minus 1), and B’s is $130, so A passes B when $100 plus $7 times (n minus 1) exceeds $130, which first happens in year 6. Over ten years A totals $15,780 against B’s $15,600.

The point is not that one method wins. A person who expects to switch policies, or who values the lower early payments, may see Quote A differently from a person who wants a premium that does not climb with age. The point is that the same dollar figure on a quote sheet can describe very different futures, which is why CMS suggests asking how frequently an attained-age premium increases because of your age.

What Ohio’s Rule Says About Rating Methods

Ohio’s Medicare supplement rule, Ohio Administrative Code 3901-8-08, is the rule most readers ask about. After reading the full text, here is what it does and does not say.

  • It does not name a required method. We found no paragraph requiring community, issue-age or attained-age rating, and none prohibiting any of them. The rule instead presupposes that age-based pricing exists: the policy’s renewal provision must disclose any reservation of the right to change premiums and any automatic renewal premium increases based on the age of the policyholder, and a paragraph about exchanged policies refers to a policy priced on an issue-age rate schedule.
  • Rates must be filed and approved. An insurer may not use or change premium rates unless the rates, rating schedule and supporting documentation have been filed with and approved by the superintendent of insurance. Rates are filed annually, and the rule says benefits are not unreasonable in relation to the premium when the rates were calculated in accordance with sound actuarial principles.
  • There is a minimum loss ratio. The policy form is expected to return at least 65 percent of earned premiums as benefits for individual policies, and 75 percent for group policies, estimated over the period for which rates are computed. The rule does not set premium levels, so insurers can still price differently within it.
  • Premiums must be disclosed. The outline of coverage must state the premium and mode for each plan offered, illustrate all possible premiums for the applicant, and explain any smoker and non-smoker rates or household discounts.
  • Changing the rating structure is regulated. The rule treats a change in rating structure or methodology as a discontinuance of the form, unless the insurer supplies an actuarial memorandum and later keeps the described percentage differential. This concerns forms and filings. It is not a promise about what your own premium will do.
  • Health-based pricing is limited in protected situations. In the open enrollment period an insurer may not discriminate in pricing because of health status, including tobacco or nicotine use, and may not use premium rating practices that make premiums higher for people eligible for open enrollment than for people who are not. For guaranteed-issue situations, the rule says the insurer may not discriminate in pricing because of health status.
  • Genetic information cannot be used. An insurer may not discriminate in pricing on the basis of genetic information.

What the rule does not tell you is which method any particular insurer uses or what its rates are. That comes from the insurer’s outline of coverage and quote, and OSHIIP can help you read them. The rule is also specific to Ohio. Rules in Kentucky, Indiana and other states may differ, so ask that state’s insurance department if you live in or move to another state. For the wider set of state rules, see our guide to Ohio Medicare Supplement rules.

Where You Live

Medicare.gov names where you live as one of the factors that vary Medigap premiums. How an insurer divides Ohio into pricing territories, if it does, is part of the rating schedule it files with the superintendent. We did not find a public rule that defines territory boundaries, so we cannot describe how any insurer draws them.

A practical consequence follows. Quotes should be run on your actual ZIP code, not a nearby one or a state average. CMS also says you can generally keep your current Medigap policy wherever you live as long as you still have Original Medicare, and that buying a different policy after a move may cost more and involve medical questions outside protected windows. Whether your existing premium changes after a move is a question for your insurer, so ask before you relocate across a county or state line. Our Answer on moving to a new address covers the Medicare side of a move.

Discounts and Payment Mode

CMS lists the discounts an insurer may offer: discounts for women, non-smokers or married people, for paying yearly, for paying by electronic funds transfer, and for multiple policies. Which of these exist, how large they are, and what conditions apply vary by insurer. Ohio’s rule only requires that smoker and non-smoker rates and household discounts be explained in the outline of coverage.

Two cautions make discounts worth asking about rather than assuming.

  • Conditions can end a discount. A household discount, for example, is defined by the insurer. Ask what qualifies a household and what happens if a member leaves the policy or the household.
  • A discount is part of the comparison, not a separate line. A quote that includes a household discount and a quote that does not are different inputs. When comparing, either apply the same discounts to both or compare only the undiscounted amounts.

Payment mode matters for the same reason. CMS names paying yearly and paying by electronic funds transfer as discount types, so a monthly-pay quote and an annual-pay quote are not directly comparable. Convert both to a yearly total before judging them.

Tobacco, Gender and Other Personal Factors

Three personal factors can show up in a quote, and each is limited by rule in some situations.

Tobacco. CMS lists discounts for non-smokers, and Ohio’s rule refers to smoker and non-smoker rates. Inside the open enrollment period, the rule bars discrimination in pricing based on health status, including tobacco or nicotine use. Outside it, a tobacco question on an application can affect pricing, so answer it accurately because the insurer may rely on the answer.

Gender. CMS describes community-rated policies as charging generally the same premium regardless of age or gender, and lists discounts for women among the discounts some insurers offer. That is the extent of what we verified on gender pricing, so ask each insurer whether its rates differ.

Health. Health history is not a rating factor during your six-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period. CMS says an insurer cannot charge you more for a Medigap policy because of health problems during that period or when a guaranteed-issue right applies. Outside those situations the next section applies.

Underwriting and Rate Classes

When no protected window applies, CMS says an insurer may use medical underwriting or charge a different premium. That is the largest source of price difference for people who are no longer in their first six months. Two applicants of the same age, in the same ZIP code, requesting the same letter can receive different quotes, or one can be declined, because of the answers on their applications.

Insurers may also hold more than one policy form of the same plan letter. Ohio’s rule lets an insurer offer, with approval, up to four additional forms of the same type for the same standard plan, including separate forms for guaranteed-issue or underwritten coverage and for people eligible for Medicare because of disability. The premium you are quoted may therefore belong to a particular form, so ask which form it is. The rule also mentions the “rating class” of an insured when a 1990-standardized policy is exchanged for a 2010-standardized one. We did not find a public definition of insurer-specific classes such as preferred or standard, so if a quote mentions classes, ask the insurer to explain what places an applicant in each one.

For what insurers ask and how they decide, see our Answer on Medigap medical underwriting. For the situations that remove underwriting, see our page on changing your Medigap policy. Our Answer on why Medigap is not part of open enrollment explains why no yearly window exists. OSHIIP lists no annual enrollment for Medicare supplement insurance, and Ohio’s rule shows none.

Rate-Increase History: Why Two Insurers Diverge Over Time

Even with the same method, discounts and location, two insurers’ premiums can drift apart. Medicare.gov says Medigap premium amounts typically increase each year, and the amount depends on each insurer’s filed rates. Under Ohio’s rule an insurer cannot change rates without approval, and the loss ratio standard looks at claims in relation to premiums over time. That framework means rate changes go through regulatory review, but it does not make two insurers’ increases equal. Their pools of policyholders, claims experience and pricing history differ.

This is why CMS suggests asking whether a policy’s premium has increased in the last three years and by how much. A low quote paired with a history of large increases can be less informative than a higher quote paired with a steadier record, though neither predicts the future. For the causes of increases, see our Answer on Medicare Supplement rate increases.

Comparing Two Quotes Fairly

Use this table to decide what to hold constant when you compare.

InputHold constantWhy
Plan letter and formSame letter, same type (standard, Medicare SELECT, high-deductible)Benefits are the same only within a letter and form type.
Age and ZIP codeToday’s age, your actual ZIPAge and location both affect price.
Pricing methodRecord it for each quoteDetermines how the price moves later.
DiscountsSame set applied to bothOtherwise you compare different inputs.
Payment modeSame mode, or convert to a yearly totalModes can carry different prices.
Tobacco statusSame, and accurateMay change the price.
Increase historyAsk each insurerShows how rates have moved.

Then compare the first-year price and the likely shape of later years. The hypothetical earlier shows why both matter.

How We Help

We are an independent insurance agency in Bethel, Ohio, serving the Cincinnati area. For a pricing question, we can go through your outline of coverage with you, explain what each pricing method means for the quote in front of you, and make sure you are comparing the same letter with the same inputs. We can also explain how underwriting would apply to you before you apply anywhere. A decision to keep your current policy is a fine outcome. To talk it through, contact our office, or see our Medicare Supplement plans hub for the plan letters.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the same Medigap plan letter priced differently by different insurers?

Because insurers set their own prices. CMS says each insurance company decides how it will set the premium, while the benefits of each lettered plan are the same. Differences come from the rating method, where you live, discounts, tobacco status, any underwriting, and the insurer’s own claims and rate history.

Does Ohio require attained-age, issue-age or community rating?

We found no paragraph in Ohio’s Medicare supplement rule, OAC 3901-8-08, that requires or prohibits any of the three. The rule requires that rates be filed with and approved by the superintendent, that premiums be disclosed in the outline of coverage, and that the policy’s renewal provision disclose age-based renewal increases. Which method applies to a policy is shown in that insurer’s documents.

Is an attained-age policy always cheaper at first?

Not necessarily. CMS says attained-age-rated premiums are low for younger buyers and may be the least expensive at first, but how the quotes compare depends on the insurers you are looking at. Ask for quotes under each method, and ask how often the age-based step occurs.

Do discounts change the benefits?

No. Discounts affect the premium, not what the plan pays. Because benefits are standardized by letter, a discount only changes price. Ask what conditions apply, since a discount can end if your circumstances change.

Can an insurer charge me more because of my health?

Outside protected situations, it may. CMS says an insurer can use medical underwriting or charge a different premium when you are not in your Medigap Open Enrollment Period and do not have a guaranteed-issue right. Inside those situations, it cannot use health to deny you or set your price.

Should I pick the lowest quote?

The lowest quote is one input. Compare the same letter and inputs, check the pricing method and rate history, and consider how the premium may behave in later years. A lower starting price can cost more over time, and a higher one can cost less, so the choice depends on your plans and budget.

Want a second look at your Medicare Supplement premium?

Bring your renewal notice and we’ll go through it with you, including what a change would involve.

This page is general education about Medicare Supplement (Medigap) insurance, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules, costs and plan availability vary by state, county and insurer, and we do not offer every plan available in your area. We’re an independent agency, not affiliated with or endorsed by the Medicare program, the Social Security Administration or any government agency. For official information, visit Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE.