Last updated: November 16, 2026

Medigap or Medicare Advantage at 65? A Decision Guide

At 65, the choice is between Original Medicare with a Medigap (Medicare Supplement) policy and a Medicare Advantage plan. You cannot have both. Neither is better for everyone: Medigap generally moves more of your cost into a monthly premium and works with any provider that accepts Medicare, while Medicare Advantage generally pairs a lower (sometimes $0) plan premium and extra benefits with network rules and plan-set cost sharing. This guide lays out the tradeoffs so you can weigh them against your own doctors, budget, health, and travel habits.

The Two Paths in Plain Terms

Everyone who signs up for Part A and Part B starts in Original Medicare, the federal program. From there you either stay in Original Medicare or move your Part A and Part B coverage into a private Medicare Advantage plan.

Path 1: Original Medicare plus Medigap, usually plus a Part D drug plan. Medicare pays its share of an approved service first. A Medigap policy, sold by a private insurer, then pays part or all of what Medicare leaves behind, depending on which standardized plan letter you hold. Medigap policies sold after 2005 do not include prescription drug coverage, so a stand-alone Part D plan is a separate decision. You pay the Part B premium, the Medigap premium, and the Part D premium (if you join a drug plan).

Path 2: Medicare Advantage (Part C). A private company contracts with Medicare to deliver your Part A and Part B benefits, and most plans also include Part D drug coverage. Medicare pays the plan a fixed monthly amount for you, and the plan sets its own copayments, coinsurance, deductibles, and rules for how you get care. You keep paying the Part B premium, and you may pay a plan premium too, though some plans charge none and some may help pay all or part of the Part B premium.

One rule shapes everything that follows: Medicare’s own materials state that you can either buy Medigap or enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan, but you can’t have both. If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, it is illegal for anyone to sell you a Medigap policy unless the plan’s coverage will end before the Medigap policy starts. A Medigap policy also cannot pay a Medicare Advantage plan’s copayments, coinsurance, deductibles, or premiums.

For the underlying building blocks, see our pages on Medicare Supplement plans and Medicare Advantage plans.

Why This Decision Has a Time Dimension

Most decisions in Medicare can be revisited each fall. This one is different, because the two paths are not equally easy to leave. Medicare Advantage can generally be changed during the annual Open Enrollment window (October 15 to December 7) and during a January 1 to March 31 window for people already in a plan. Medigap, by contrast, can be medically underwritten once your open enrollment window closes unless a specific right applies. That asymmetry is why the first choice at 65 gets so much attention. It is covered in detail in the sections on underwriting and trial rights below.

Your first window to choose is your Initial Enrollment Period. If you are still working or your timing is unclear, start with our explanation of the 7-month Initial Enrollment Period.

How the Cost Structures Differ

The two paths are built differently, so comparing monthly premiums alone can mislead. Three layers matter: the premium you pay every month, the cost sharing you pay when you use care, and the ceiling on what you could owe in a bad year.

Cost elementOriginal Medicare + MedigapMedicare Advantage
Part B premiumYou pay itYou pay it, though some plans may help pay all or part of it
Additional monthly premiumMedigap premium, set by the insurerPlan premium, which can be $0 on some plans
Cost sharing at the point of careDepends on the plan letter; some letters cover most or all Part A and Part B coinsurance, others leave some cost sharingSet by each plan: copayments or coinsurance that can vary by service
Yearly cap on out-of-pocket costsNo cap in Original Medicare itself; a Medigap policy reduces exposure by covering cost sharingYearly limit on Part A and Part B services, which may differ for in-network and out-of-network care
Drug coverageSeparate Part D planMost plans include Part D
Part B deductibleMedigap plans sold to people new to Medicare after January 1, 2020 are not allowed to cover itPlan-specific

For reference, the standard Part B premium is currently $202.90 per month and the Part B deductible is $283; see our Part B page for what Part B covers.

Premium versus cost sharing

A useful way to see the difference is to ask when you pay. With a comprehensive Medigap plan, more of your cost is paid up front through the premium and less when you use care. With many Medicare Advantage plans, a lower premium is offset by cost sharing that arrives when you need a service. Neither pattern is a mistake. The right question is which pattern matches how much care you expect to use and how much variability you can absorb.

Consider a hypothetical comparison, with no dollar figures because plans differ widely. One retiree has a quiet year: a few primary care visits and routine prescriptions. Another has a year with several specialist visits, imaging, and a hospital stay. In the quiet year, a plan with a low premium and modest copays may cost less overall. In the heavier year, cost sharing on a Medicare Advantage plan accumulates until it reaches the plan’s yearly limit, while a Medigap plan with broad coverage would have paid most of the cost sharing throughout. Nobody knows in advance which kind of year is coming, which is why the ceiling matters as much as the average.

Understanding the Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximum

Every Medicare Advantage plan has a yearly limit on what you pay for covered Part A and Part B services. After you reach it, you pay nothing more for those covered services for the rest of the year. Two cautions apply. The limit does not include the monthly premium, and it applies to Part A and Part B services rather than to every cost you might face. The amount is set by each plan within federal rules, and it can change from year to year. For a closer look, see Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximums explained and the costs that can still reach you.

Premium changes over time

Both options can change in price. Medicare Advantage plans reset their premiums, cost sharing, networks, and benefits each year and must send an Annual Notice of Change before Open Enrollment. Medigap premiums are priced by the insurer and may rise over time depending on how the policy is rated. The three pricing methods are explained in our guide to attained-age, issue-age, and community-rated pricing. It is worth asking how a specific policy is rated before comparing a first-year premium.

Provider Choice Versus Networks

This is often the deciding factor, and it is simple to test.

With Original Medicare and Medigap, you can generally use any doctor or hospital in the United States that accepts Medicare. You do not need referrals to see specialists in most cases. Medigap works with any provider that accepts Medicare, and the policy renews automatically each year even if your health changes, for standardized policies.

With Medicare Advantage, you may need to use doctors and hospitals in the plan’s network and service area for non-emergency care. Some plan types, such as PPOs, cover out-of-network care at a higher cost, while HMOs typically require the network. Some plans require a referral to see a specialist. A network can also change during the year if a doctor or hospital leaves it, and the plan must notify you.

Questions to ask yourself:

  • Are there doctors or a hospital system you would not want to give up?
  • Do you see specialists at more than one health system?
  • Do you spend long stretches away from your home area?
  • Would you be comfortable checking a network each fall?

If you do prefer a network, learn what the plan type means. See Medicare HMO plans, Medicare PPO plans, and how to check whether your doctors are in a plan’s network.

Prior Authorization and Care Approval

In Original Medicare, most services and items do not require prior authorization. In a Medicare Advantage plan, you may need approval from the plan before it covers certain services or items. If the plan does not approve a request, you may have to pay for the service yourself unless you appeal and win. Plans must cover all medically necessary services that Original Medicare covers and have appeal rights, but the process differs from Original Medicare’s.

This does not make one path wrong. It is a difference in how you receive care. People who value fewer administrative steps tend to weigh this heavily. Others accept it in exchange for a lower premium or extra benefits. The full process is described in how Medicare Advantage prior authorization works.

Drug Coverage

Drug coverage works differently depending on the path.

  • Original Medicare with Medigap: You join a separate Part D drug plan if you want drug coverage. Choosing one is its own decision with its own late-enrollment rules; see our Medicare Part D page.
  • Medicare Advantage: Most plans include Part D drug coverage, so you do not join a separate drug plan. Not every plan includes it, so confirm for the specific plan.

Whichever path you choose, check each plan’s formulary and pharmacy network against your prescriptions every year. A Part D late enrollment penalty can apply if you go without creditable drug coverage; Medicare describes it as 1 percent of the national base beneficiary premium for each month without coverage, added for as long as you have Part D. The mechanics are covered in our Initial Enrollment Period guide.

Extra Benefits

Original Medicare does not cover some services, including routine physical exams, eye exams, and most dental care. Medigap does not add them. Medicare Advantage plans may offer extra benefits such as fitness programs and some vision, hearing, and dental services, though what is included varies by plan and can change each year. Check what an extra benefit covers, including limits and networks, before counting it as a reason to choose a plan. See what a $0-premium plan includes for an example of reading the details.

Travel and Time Away From Home

Travel is a practical test that is easy to overlook.

  • Within the United States: Original Medicare with Medigap works with any provider that accepts Medicare, across the country. Medicare Advantage plans cover emergency and urgently needed care when you are away from home, but routine, non-emergency care generally needs the network, so how a plan handles it depends on its type and service area.
  • Outside the United States: Original Medicare generally does not cover medical care outside the U.S. Medicare’s materials say you may be able to buy a Medigap policy that covers emergency care outside the U.S. Medicare Advantage plans generally do not cover care outside the U.S., though some offer an extra benefit for emergency and urgently needed services when traveling abroad.

If you split the year between two states, or travel often, read the plan’s travel rules before relying on it. Ask specifically what happens with scheduled care when you are away.

Underwriting and Timing

Medicare Advantage does not use medical underwriting. Medigap often does, and the timing of when you buy matters a great deal.

During your Medigap Open Enrollment Period, an insurer must sell you any Medigap policy it offers and cannot refuse or charge more because of health conditions. Ohio’s Medicare supplement rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-8-08) defines this as a six-month period starting with the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. It happens once. When it ends, and you do not qualify for another protection, an insurer can generally review your health history before issuing a policy, and may decline, charge more, or limit coverage. You can read more in the 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period explained and what insurers ask during underwriting.

Two practical points follow:

  • Choosing Medicare Advantage first and Medigap later is possible, but later may mean underwriting unless a guaranteed-issue right applies.
  • A pre-existing condition exclusion can apply in some situations. Medicare notes that if you have held your current Medigap policy for less than six months and switch, the new policy may have a waiting period before it covers a pre-existing condition. Ohio’s rule limits such exclusions and credits prior coverage in certain cases.

Trial Rights: A Backstop if Medicare Advantage Is Not a Fit

Federal law provides two “trial rights” for people who try Medicare Advantage, and Ohio’s Medicare supplement rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-8-08) includes both. Medicare’s Medigap booklet describes them this way:

  • Joined Medicare Advantage when first eligible at 65. If you joined a Medicare Advantage plan (or a PACE program) when you were first eligible for Medicare Part A at 65, and within the first year you decide to switch to Original Medicare, you have the right to buy any Medigap policy sold by an insurance company in your state. Ohio’s rule describes it the same way: it covers people who enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan upon first becoming eligible for Part A at 65 or older and who disenroll within 12 months of the effective date.
  • Dropped a Medigap policy to try Medicare Advantage. If you dropped a Medigap policy to join Medicare Advantage for the first time, have been in the plan less than a year, and want to buy Medigap again, you may be able to get the same policy back if the company still sells it. If it is not available, you can buy one of a limited set of plan letters sold in your state. Medicare’s booklet lists Plans A, B, C, D, F, and G for this purpose, and Ohio’s rule lists A, B, C, F (including high-deductible F), K, and L, with D and G (including high-deductible G) substituted for people newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020.

Some details to keep straight:

  • The right applies when you return to Original Medicare. It is not a right to move to another Medicare Advantage plan with Medigap.
  • If you leave voluntarily, you can apply as early as 60 days before your Medicare Advantage coverage ends and no later than 63 days after it ends. If the plan is ending your coverage, the window can start from the date of the termination notice. Medigap cannot start until the Medicare Advantage coverage ends.
  • Medicare notes that these rights may last an extra 12 months in certain circumstances, so check with the Ohio Department of Insurance if you are close to the one-year mark.
  • If you dropped a Medigap policy to join Medicare Advantage and the trial period passes, you might not be able to get the same policy back, and in some cases you might not be able to get any Medigap policy.

The trial right reduces the risk of trying Medicare Advantage first, but it has an end date. After the trial period, returning to Original Medicare may mean that Medigap is available only with underwriting. Read the full explanation in Medicare Advantage trial rights.

Switching Later: What to Expect in Ohio

If you choose one path now and want the other later, here is how the options compare.

Medigap to Medicare Advantage. You can generally join a Medicare Advantage plan during Open Enrollment (October 15 to December 7), and coverage starts January 1. You would then drop your Medigap policy, because it cannot pay Medicare Advantage costs. Because Medigap can be underwritten later, this step can be hard to reverse unless a trial right or another guaranteed-issue right applies.

Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare. During Open Enrollment you can drop the plan and return to Original Medicare. During the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1 to March 31, for people already in a plan) you can switch plans or return to Original Medicare, but only one change is allowed. Returning does not by itself give you a right to buy Medigap. You need either a trial right, another guaranteed-issue situation, or to pass underwriting.

Medigap to a different Medigap policy. Under federal rules, you generally have no right to switch Medigap policies unless you are within your six-month open enrollment period or a guaranteed-issue situation applies. Medicare also notes that states can add rights, so it recommends checking with your state insurance department.

Ohio specifics. Ohio Administrative Code 3901-8-08 provides a six-month open enrollment period that begins with the first month you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During that window an insurer cannot deny or condition a policy, or price it, based on health status (the rule lists tobacco and nicotine use), claims experience, receipt of health care, or medical condition. Outside it, the rule’s guaranteed-issue section (paragraph O) lists specific events, such as losing employer or retiree coverage that supplemented Medicare, a Medicare Advantage plan ending or leaving your area, a Medigap insurer’s insolvency or other involuntary termination of your policy, and the two trial rights described above. Most windows run until 63 days after the coverage ends.

Two limits are easy to miss. First, the rule’s guaranteed-issue rights for most of those events apply only to certain plan letters: A, B, C, F (including high-deductible F), K, and L, with D and G substituted for people newly eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. Plans such as N and M are not named, and an insurer only has to sell the policies it currently offers to new enrollees. The trial right for people who joined Medicare Advantage at 65 is the exception, because it covers any Medigap policy an insurer offers. Second, guaranteed-issue situations require a triggering event. Switching because you found a lower premium is not one.

We read the rule for any annual, birthday-based, or continuous window that would let an existing Medigap holder move to a different policy without underwriting, and did not find one. The Ohio Department of Insurance’s Ohio Senior Health Insurance Information Program (OSHIIP) agrees: its 2026 Welcome to Medicare guide lists no annual enrollment for Medicare supplement insurance, and no guaranteed issue and no annual open enrollment period when moving from one supplement to another. Some other states do add enrollment periods or switching rights. Rules can change, so confirm current Ohio rules with the Ohio Department of Insurance or OSHIIP before you rely on switching later, because that is the assumption that most often matters. More is in our Ohio Medigap rules explainer and changing your Medigap policy, and Medigap’s rate pressure is covered in why Medigap premiums differ.

Questions to Ask Yourself

A decision framework works better when it surfaces your own priorities. Consider these questions, and notice which ones produce a strong reaction.

  1. Doctors. If your current doctors and hospital are not in a plan’s network, how much does that matter to you?
  2. Variability. Would an unpredictable year, with cost sharing up to a yearly limit, be manageable? Or is a steadier cost pattern more valuable?
  3. Monthly cash flow. What premium fits your budget today, and what would you do if premiums rose?
  4. Health. How is your health now? Medigap protections are strongest during your open enrollment period, so your health history can affect how flexible later choices are. Medicare Advantage costs also depend on how much care you use.
  5. Prescriptions. Do you take medications that vary widely in price across drug plan formularies?
  6. Approvals. Does the idea of prior authorization bother you, or is it acceptable?
  7. Travel. How much of the year will you spend outside your home service area, or outside the country?
  8. Extra benefits. Would you use fitness, dental, vision, or hearing benefits if offered, and are the limits acceptable?
  9. Paperwork. Do you want to review a plan’s changes every fall, or would you prefer a more stable setup?
  10. Spouse. Each person chooses separately. Do you and your spouse have different needs?

A framework for turning the answers into a comparison is in our guide to comparing Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage costs.

Side-by-Side Comparison

TopicOriginal Medicare + MedigapMedicare Advantage
Who delivers Part A and BFederal Original MedicareA private plan under contract with Medicare
Doctors and hospitalsAny provider that accepts MedicarePlan network and service area for non-emergency care; varies by plan type
ReferralsGenerally not neededMay be required, depending on plan type
Prior authorizationNot required for most services in Original MedicareMay be required by the plan for some services
PremiumsPart B + Medigap + Part D (if joined)Part B + plan premium (can be $0)
Yearly out-of-pocket limitNone in Original Medicare; Medigap covers much or all cost sharingRequired limit on Part A and B services
Drug coverageSeparate Part D planIncluded in most plans
Extra benefitsNot part of MedigapOffered by many plans; varies
Travel outside the U.S.Some Medigap plans may offer emergency coverageGenerally not covered; some plans offer an extra benefit
Medical underwritingOften applies outside open enrollment and guaranteed-issue rightsNot used
Annual plan changesMedigap policy stays standardized and renews automaticallyPlan costs, networks, and benefits can change each year
Leaving laterUnderwriting may apply when returning to Medigap without a rightCan switch during the fall or January-March windows

Where People Go Wrong

Four patterns come up often in conversations about this choice, and each is avoidable.

  • Choosing on premium alone. A low premium does not capture cost sharing or the yearly limit.
  • Skipping the network check. A plan is only as useful as its network for your own doctors and hospital. Check by name, not by plan type.
  • Assuming Medigap will always be available. Outside open enrollment and guaranteed-issue rights, underwriting can apply.
  • Skipping drug coverage. Whichever path you choose, decide how you will cover prescriptions.

Making the Decision

There is no formula that selects a winner. The decision is a weighing of provider access, cost pattern, administrative rules, travel, and how much flexibility you want later. Many people find that writing down their doctors, medications, and travel plans first makes the comparison concrete. If you want a second set of eyes, we can walk through your situation with you, compare actual plans available where you live, and explain how each fits the questions above. Related reading: the Turning 65 Medicare checklist and the Turning 65 hub.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I have Medigap and Medicare Advantage at the same time?

No. Medicare’s materials state that you can either buy Medigap or enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan, but you can’t have both. A Medigap policy cannot pay a Medicare Advantage plan’s costs, and it is illegal for anyone to sell you a Medigap policy while you are in a Medicare Advantage plan unless the plan’s coverage will end before the Medigap policy starts.

Can I try Medicare Advantage and switch to Medigap if I do not like it?

Possibly. If you join Medicare Advantage for the first time when first eligible for Part A at 65, you generally have a 12-month trial right to return to Original Medicare and buy a Medigap policy. After that period, Medigap may be subject to medical underwriting unless another guaranteed-issue situation applies. Details are in the trial rights section above.

Does Ohio give me a yearly window to change Medigap policies?

Not that we found. Ohio’s Medicare supplement rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-8-08) has no annual or birthday-based window for existing Medigap holders, and the Ohio Department of Insurance’s OSHIIP guide lists no annual enrollment for Medicare supplement insurance. Ohio provides an open enrollment period at 65 and guaranteed-issue rights tied to specific events. Because state rules can change, confirm with the Ohio Department of Insurance or OSHIIP before relying on a later switch.

Is a Medicare Advantage plan with a $0 premium $0 in total cost?

The plan premium may be $0, but you still pay the Part B premium, and you pay whatever copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles the plan sets, up to its yearly out-of-pocket limit. Drug costs and extra-benefit limits also vary by plan. Compare the whole cost structure, not only the premium line.

Does Medicare Advantage cover everything Original Medicare covers?

Plans must cover all medically necessary services that Original Medicare covers, and many add extra benefits. How you receive those services differs: networks, referrals, and prior authorization may apply, and the costs you pay are set by the plan. Original Medicare still helps cover some items, such as hospice care, for plan members.

Does Medigap cover prescription drugs?

No. Medigap policies sold after 2005 do not include prescription drug coverage. People with Original Medicare who want drug coverage join a separate Part D plan, while most Medicare Advantage plans include it.

Which one should I choose at 65?

We do not recommend one path for everyone, because it depends on your doctors, health, budget, travel, and tolerance for variability in costs. The questions above are meant to help you decide, and we can talk through your situation with you if that would be useful.

Turning 65 soon? Let’s check your dates and options.

Tell us your birth month and we’ll walk through your enrollment window, your options and your questions.

This page is general education about Medicare, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules, costs and plan availability vary by state, county and insurer, and we do not offer every plan available in your area. We’re an independent agency, not affiliated with or endorsed by the Medicare program, the Social Security Administration or any government agency. For official information, visit Medicare.gov or call 1-800-MEDICARE.