Quick answer
Your plan must notify you in writing, and you get a Special Enrollment Period, December 8 through the end of February for a year-end non-renewal. If you do nothing, a Medicare Advantage plan ends and you default to Original Medicare without drug coverage. A stand-alone drug plan simply disenrolls you. Choose a new plan, ideally by December 7, to avoid gaps.
On this page
- Why Plans Leave
- The Letter, and When It Arrives
- Your Special Enrollment Period
- What Happens If You Do Nothing
- Your Three Basic Choices
- What About a Standalone Part D Plan?
- What If Your Medigap Insurer Leaves?
- A Practical Timeline
- A Step-by-Step Plan From Notice to New Coverage
- How It Plays Out for Each Coverage Type
- Scenarios
- Costly Mistakes
- What to Ask the Plan, the New Plan, and Your Providers
- If It Goes Wrong
- Frequently Asked Questions
Why Plans Leave
Private Medicare plans are renewed on a contract year that runs January through December. Insurers decide well ahead of the fall which plans and counties they will continue to offer. Under federal rules, a Medicare Advantage organization that is not renewing its contract has to tell CMS by the first Monday in June of the year the contract would end, and the reasons are business ones that can include finances, membership in an area, and expected costs. When an insurer decides to stop offering a plan, it can end the entire plan, or it can shrink the service area so that some counties are dropped.
Some years see more of this than others. When the changes are widespread, you might hear that a large insurer is “pulling out” of certain markets. What it means for you depends on which plan you are in and where you live, not on headlines, so the right move is to read your own mail.
It also helps to separate three things that sound alike:
- Non-renewal: the plan or its service area ends effective January 1.
- A mid-year termination, which is less common and can happen when an insurer ends a contract by agreement or when CMS ends a contract.
- A plan consolidation or benefit change, in which the plan continues but its name, benefits, or costs change. CMS guidance says consolidations are not terminations or non-renewals and do not trigger this SEP.
Everything below concerns the first two.
The Letter, and When It Arrives
Federal rules require plans to tell each affected enrollee the effective date of the termination, non-renewal, or service area reduction, and to describe the alternatives for getting benefits under Medicare. For Medicare Advantage non-renewals, federal regulations require the plan to notify each enrollee by mail at least 90 calendar days before the non-renewal takes effect. For a January 1 non-renewal, that means the notice should arrive by early October at the latest, shortly before open enrollment begins.
That timing is by design. The notice lands before the Annual Enrollment Period, which runs October 15 through December 7, so you have two chances to act: during the regular period and again during the special one that follows. Look for it among the mailings you receive in the fall, including the Annual Notice of Change, which we explain in our post on how to read your Annual Notice of Change. A plan ending notice is a different document. It is usually clearly labeled, but it can look like routine marketing, so open everything from your plan.
Your Special Enrollment Period
When a plan non-renews effective January 1, CMS says the special enrollment period begins December 8 and ends the last day of February. That gives you extra time beyond the regular fall period. The effective date depends on when you act:
The table below shows how timing works for the most common endings.
| Situation | Window or start date |
|---|---|
| Non-renewal: you choose December 8 to 31 | Coverage starts January 1 |
| Non-renewal: you choose in January | Coverage starts February 1 |
| Non-renewal: you choose in February | Coverage starts March 1 |
| Plan or sponsor terminates mid-year | Two months before through one month after |
| CMS terminates the contract | One month before through two months after |
- Requests made from December 8 through December 31 take effect January 1.
- Requests made in January take effect February 1.
- Requests made in February take effect March 1.
Choosing in the regular fall window is still the cleanest path, because your new coverage starts January 1 without any gap. The extra months after December 7 are a safety net, not a plan. Waiting until after January 1 can leave you in Original Medicare, without drug coverage, until your new plan starts.
Other kinds of endings have their own windows. For a termination by the plan or by mutual consent, the SEP begins two months before the termination date and ends a month after the month of termination. For a termination by CMS, it begins a month before and ends two months after. Our post on special enrollment periods lists others.
What Happens If You Do Nothing
The default rules are not friendly to inaction, and they differ by plan type.
If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan that ends and you do not choose a new plan, CMS guidance says you default to Original Medicare on the termination date. You would have Part A and Part B, with the standard 20% coinsurance and no yearly out-of-pocket maximum. If your old plan included drug coverage, as most do, that coverage ends too. Unless you enroll in a stand-alone Part D plan, you would have no Medicare drug coverage.
If you are in a stand-alone Part D plan that ends and you do not enroll in another, you are simply disenrolled on that date.
The drug coverage gap has a lasting cost. A stretch of 63 days or more without creditable drug coverage can lead to a Part D late-enrollment penalty, which is added to your premium for as long as you have Part D. Our post on how Medicare Part D works explains the penalty. Since a plan ending is not your fault, it is worth acting early.
CMS guidance also says that in some cases the SEP continues for a short time after the plan ends, so a person who defaults to Original Medicare may still be able to select a plan after the fact. The coverage would start prospectively rather than going back to January 1, though, so any gap in between could mean bills you would owe.
Your Three Basic Choices
When your plan is ending, you generally have three directions to go.
Join another Medicare Advantage plan. If you want to stay in the Advantage world, you can compare the plans available at your address. The comparison should go beyond the premium. Look at whether your doctors and hospitals are in the network, how the plan prices the drugs you take, whether it requires referrals, and what the yearly out-of-pocket limit is. Our plan comparison checklist and our guide to checking networks can help structure this. If you have a Medicare Advantage HMO today, our post on how HMO and PPO networks work in real life is useful for deciding whether a different plan type would suit you better.
Switching to another Advantage plan does not give you any Medigap guaranteed-issue right, a point worth keeping in mind.
Return to Original Medicare, with a drug plan and possibly a Medigap policy. If you leave Advantage for Original Medicare, you should arrange a stand-alone Part D plan to replace the drug coverage that the old plan included. You may also consider a Medigap policy to help pay Original Medicare’s cost-sharing.
Here the termination can work in your favor. Medicare.gov says that if your Medicare Advantage plan is leaving Medicare or stops giving care in your area, you have guaranteed issue rights to buy certain Medigap policies. A guaranteed issue right is the protection that, within its window, keeps insurers from turning you down or charging more because of your health history. You can apply starting 60 days before your coverage ends and up to 63 days after it ends. Medicare.gov lists Plans A, B, C, D, F, G, K and L as available under this right, though which letters you can actually buy depends on when you first became eligible for Medicare and which plans are sold in your state. Medigap coverage can’t start until the Advantage plan ends.
Our explanation of Medigap medical underwriting shows why the guaranteed-issue window matters. Outside it, many states allow insurers to ask health questions. Our overview of switching from Medicare Advantage to Original Medicare covers trade-offs such as higher premiums for the supplement versus the lack of a network.
Keep the same insurer, if it offers another plan. Sometimes the insurer stops one plan but continues others in your county. CMS guidance also mentions that in certain circumstances a plan reducing its service area may offer enrollees a continuation option within the same organization when no other Advantage plan is available, in which case you may be required to use designated facilities in the service area. If a similar plan from the same company is offered, do not assume it is a duplicate. Compare it as carefully as you would an unfamiliar one, because networks, copays, and drug lists can differ.
What About a Standalone Part D Plan?
The same general logic applies, with one difference: a Part D plan ending leaves you without drug coverage on the termination date unless you choose a new one. Because pharmacies and formularies vary, check that your pharmacy is in the new plan’s network and that your medications are on its drug list. Our post on checking your drugs against the formulary shows how.
If you get Extra Help or have Medicaid, there are additional flexibilities, such as a monthly SEP into stand-alone drug plans, but they come with limits. Call 1-800-MEDICARE or a State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor to confirm how they apply to you.
What If Your Medigap Insurer Leaves?
This is different from a plan ending, and the news is generally better. Medicare.gov says standardized Medigap policies are automatically renewed every year, even if you have health problems, and that the insurer can end your coverage only in a few situations: you stop paying premiums, you were not truthful on your application, or the insurer goes bankrupt or out of business. An insurer that simply stops selling new Medigap policies in your state does not, by that fact alone, appear on that list, but the details can vary, so ask the insurer or your state insurance department if you receive a notice.
That said, if you ever received a notice about your Medigap company, read it and call the insurer or your state insurance department with questions. Rate changes, ownership changes, and market exits are separate things. If you are shopping for a new policy because of one, our post on Medigap pricing methods explains what to compare.
A Practical Timeline
Putting the pieces together, a reasonable sequence looks like this:
- By early October: expect the non-renewal notice, and read it for the end date and your options.
- October 15 through December 7: use the regular enrollment window to pick a new plan, so coverage starts January 1.
- If you are heading back to Original Medicare: line up a drug plan and consider the Medigap application window, which begins 60 days before coverage ends.
- December 8 through the end of February: the special window is your backup if you missed the first one.
- Throughout: confirm your doctors, pharmacy and drug list for any new plan before you enroll.
A Step-by-Step Plan From Notice to New Coverage
If a notice arrives, work through it in order rather than all at once.
- Read the letter for three things: the type of change (non-renewal, service area reduction, or termination), the date coverage ends, and the alternatives it describes. Keep the envelope and the letter.
- Confirm what ends. Ask whether it is your medical plan, your drug coverage, or both. In a Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage, both end together.
- Gather your information: your Medicare number, a list of your doctors and hospital, a list of your medications with doses, and your pharmacy.
- Compare options for next year. You can look at other Advantage plans, a path back to Original Medicare with a stand-alone drug plan, and whether a Medigap policy is available to you. Our comparison checklist works step by step.
- Check each option’s network and drug list before you choose, not after.
- Enroll before December 7 if you can, so coverage begins January 1. Use the December 8 through February window only as a backup.
- If you are heading to Original Medicare, mark the Medigap guaranteed-issue window on your calendar. It starts 60 days before coverage ends and lasts until 63 days after it ends.
- After enrolling, keep your confirmation, wait for your new card and welcome materials, and test the new coverage with a prescription fill or a scheduled visit early in the year.
How It Plays Out for Each Coverage Type
If you have a Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage. This is the most exposed situation. If the plan ends and you choose nothing, CMS guidance says you default to Original Medicare on the termination date and your plan’s drug coverage ends. Original Medicare brings the standard 20% coinsurance and no yearly out-of-pocket cap, so most people who go this route also consider a Medigap policy and a stand-alone drug plan.
If you have a stand-alone Part D plan. If the plan ends and you enroll in nothing, you are disenrolled on the termination date. You keep your medical coverage, but your drug coverage stops, and a gap of 63 days or more without creditable coverage can mean a late-enrollment penalty.
If you have Original Medicare with a Medigap policy. A Medicare Advantage or Part D plan ending does not directly touch your Medigap policy. If your Medigap company withdraws from selling new policies, Medicare.gov’s description of automatic renewal means the existing policy generally continues as long as you pay your premium, with the narrow exceptions described above.
If you get Extra Help or are dual eligible. CMS guidance describes a fall process in which it reassigns affected low-income subsidy enrollees from a non-renewing plan to a stand-alone drug plan, within the same organization where possible, unless you already have Part D coverage for the following year, so you may receive a notice that you have been placed in a new plan. If your ending plan was a Medicare Advantage plan, you keep the option to choose another Advantage plan instead. Read it carefully, because an automatic assignment may not match your pharmacy or your drug list, and you keep the right to choose a different plan. Our posts on Extra Help and dual-eligible special needs plans explain those programs.
If you are in a special needs plan. CMS guidance also describes passive enrollment in certain limited situations, such as an integrated dual-eligible plan non-renewing, in which CMS, after consulting the state Medicaid agency, may move full-benefit dual eligible enrollees automatically into another plan, with notices that explain how to decline or choose a different plan. If you get such a notice, don’t assume it is the best fit for you, and ask what your options are.
Scenarios
None of these describes a real person, and each is simplified.
Picture a retiree in an Advantage HMO whose plan is leaving her county. She reads the letter in October, uses her doctors’ and hospital’s names to check two other plans’ networks, confirms that her medications are covered, and enrolls in early December, so the new plan starts January 1. Nothing lapses.
Picture a man who sets the letter aside and forgets it. On January 1 he is in Original Medicare with no drug plan. He remembers in February when a pharmacy asks for his plan card. He can still use the December 8 to February window, but a plan chosen in February starts March 1, and he has paid full price for prescriptions in the meantime. He also needs to think about the penalty clock, which counts days without creditable drug coverage.
Picture a woman who prefers Original Medicare plus a Medigap policy and has a health history that might make underwriting difficult. Because her plan is leaving the area, she has guaranteed issue rights, so the insurer can’t turn her down for health reasons, and she applies in November, within the window that opened 60 days before her coverage ends. Medigap coverage can’t start until the Advantage plan ends, so the new policy starts January 1.
Picture someone who joins another Advantage plan. He does not get a Medigap guaranteed-issue right, because he did not return to Original Medicare. He should be aware that his options to switch later will be governed by normal rules.
Costly Mistakes
- Treating the letter as junk mail. The notice is the start of a deadline.
- Choosing by premium alone. The cheapest plan may not include your doctors or your drugs. Check both.
- Assuming a same-company replacement is identical. Networks, copays and drug lists can differ between plans from one insurer.
- Forgetting drug coverage when leaving Advantage. Original Medicare does not include it.
- Waiting for the Medigap window to close. Outside it, many states allow insurers to ask health questions and decline applicants.
- Joining a new plan without checking the network. A plan that looks inexpensive may not include your hospital.
- Letting a pharmacy surprise be the first test. Confirm coverage of your key medications before the new year.
What to Ask the Plan, the New Plan, and Your Providers
Questions for the plan that is ending: what exactly ends, what is the end date, whether any continuation option exists in your area, and whether there are services in progress, such as a course of treatment or a pending authorization, that need to be handled before the end date.
Questions for a new plan: whether your doctors, hospital and pharmacy are in the network, whether each of your drugs is on the formulary and at what cost tier, whether prior authorization applies to services you use, and what the yearly out-of-pocket limit is.
Questions for your doctors’ offices: which plans they will participate in next year, since contracts can change. Our guide on checking networks shows how to confirm.
If It Goes Wrong
If you missed the window and are now in Original Medicare without drug coverage, enroll in a drug plan as soon as you are eligible and ask whether any other enrollment period applies to you. CMS guidance describes a short extension for some mid-year terminations and describes an exceptional-circumstances process, case by case, for situations where something outside your control kept you from acting in time. Call 1-800-MEDICARE and explain what happened.
If you cannot get a Medigap policy after missing the guaranteed-issue window, you may still be able to apply, but the insurer may ask health questions, and the answer depends on the company and state. Our post on Medigap medical underwriting explains how those decisions are made.
If you believe you were wrongly disenrolled, or never got a notice you were due, ask the plan for its records, and contact 1-800-MEDICARE. A State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) counselor can also help at no charge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my Medicare Advantage plan just end?
Yes. Insurers can choose not to renew a plan or to reduce its service area at the end of the contract year, but they must notify you and describe your alternatives, and you receive a Special Enrollment Period.
How long do I have to choose a new plan if mine is non-renewed?
The SEP for a year-end non-renewal runs from December 8 through the last day of February. Choosing during the regular Annual Enrollment Period, October 15 through December 7, keeps your coverage starting January 1 without a gap.
What happens if I don’t choose a new plan?
If you are in a Medicare Advantage plan, you default to Original Medicare when the plan ends, and your drug coverage from that plan ends. If you are in a stand-alone drug plan, you are disenrolled. Either way, a long gap in drug coverage can trigger a late-enrollment penalty.
Can I buy a Medigap policy if my Advantage plan leaves my area?
You have a guaranteed-issue right to buy certain Medigap policies, with an application window from 60 days before your coverage ends to 63 days after. That right applies only if you switch to Original Medicare.
Will my Medigap policy be canceled if my insurer leaves the state?
Medicare.gov says standardized Medigap policies renew automatically every year, and an insurer can end yours only in narrow cases, such as nonpayment, a false application, or the insurer going out of business. Ask your insurer or state insurance department if you get a notice.
Got a plan-ending notice and not sure what it means? Talk with our independent team, by phone or video wherever you live, with no cost and no obligation.
Ready to talk through your options?
It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.
