A MYGA ladder divides a sum of money among several multi-year guaranteed annuities with different guarantee periods, so that one contract reaches the end of its term every so often rather than all of the money maturing at once. The aim is to reduce dependence on a single reinvestment date and to create regular points at which money becomes available. A ladder does not raise the rate on any contract, and it does not promise a better result than a single contract. It trades simplicity for staggered timing.
The idea in plain terms
Suppose you have a sum you intend to hold in fixed annuities for several years. One approach is to place all of it in a single MYGA with one guarantee period. Another is to split it into pieces, called rungs, and give each rung a different guarantee length. When the shortest rung ends, you decide what to do with that piece. Often the choice is to place it into a new long-term rung, so that over time the ladder is rebuilt with maturities arriving at regular intervals.
If you have read our complete guide to MYGAs, you know the building block: a fixed deferred annuity that credits a declared rate for a stated number of years. A ladder is simply several of those with deliberately different end dates. Each rung is a separate contract, with its own rate, its own surrender schedule, its own cost basis, and its own date.
Why people consider a ladder
Three problems come up repeatedly, and a ladder responds to each of them in a limited way.
- Reinvestment risk. When a single large contract ends, the whole balance has to be reinvested at whatever rates and renewal terms exist that day. If those terms are less favorable than expected, the entire sum is affected. With a ladder, only the maturing rung faces that day. This does not remove the risk. It spreads it across dates, so that no single date decides the outcome for all of the money.
- Access at intervals. Surrender charges can make early withdrawals from a MYGA costly (see the page on MYGA surrender charges, withdrawals and market value adjustments). A ladder is a way to plan for money to become available on dates you know in advance, without relying on penalty-based exits.
- Uncertainty about rates. Nobody knows what rates will do. A ladder lets you commit to terms at different times and lengths rather than in one decision. You give up the chance of having committed everything at the single most favorable moment, and you also avoid having committed everything at the least favorable one.
That last point is worth stating plainly. A ladder lowers the odds of an unlucky timing outcome and also lowers the odds of a lucky one. It is a way to manage uncertainty, not to beat it.
A hypothetical five-rung ladder
The example below is for illustration only. It uses made-up dollar amounts and terms, it shows no interest rates, and it is not a current rate or a quote. Interest is left out on purpose so that the structure is easy to see.
Imagine a saver divides $200,000 equally into five rungs of $40,000 each, and chooses guarantee periods of one, two, three, four and five years. Which term lengths are offered, and by which insurers, varies, so a real ladder may have to use different lengths.
| Rung | Amount placed | Starting term | First maturity | Rebuilt as | Next maturity |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | $40,000 | 1 year | End of year 1 | New 5-year term | End of year 6 |
| B | $40,000 | 2 years | End of year 2 | New 5-year term | End of year 7 |
| C | $40,000 | 3 years | End of year 3 | New 5-year term | End of year 8 |
| D | $40,000 | 4 years | End of year 4 | New 5-year term | End of year 9 |
| E | $40,000 | 5 years | End of year 5 | New 5-year term | End of year 10 |
The five rungs add up to $200,000 (5 x $40,000). In years one through five, one rung matures each year. If each maturing rung is reinvested into a new five-year term, then from year six on every rung is a five-year contract and one of them matures every year. Along the way the owner could do something different at any maturity: take the money as spending, shorten or lengthen the next term, or move it to another insurer. The dollar amounts above exclude any interest earned, so each real rung would be larger at maturity by whatever its declared rate credited.
A few features of that structure are worth noticing:
- Only one-fifth of the money, in this example, is ever tied to the decision at a given maturity.
- The first few years carry shorter terms, which tend to have different rates than longer terms, and rate differences between terms change over time. Which length pays more varies by insurer and by period, so nothing about the shape of the ladder predicts the rates.
- The money is divided across several contracts, so there is more paperwork, more notices to track, and more dates to remember.
Other ladder shapes
The five-by-one-year pattern is only one version. Others people consider include:
- A short ladder. Three rungs, for example, with terms of three, four and five years. This uses fewer contracts and has fewer dates to manage, with less frequent access.
- A longer ladder. Rungs stretching toward seven or ten years, where the availability of longer terms permits it. This extends the planning horizon and also lengthens the period over which money is locked up.
- A ladder with a spending purpose. Each rung is matched to a known need, such as a year of expected spending later in retirement. Our guide to using a MYGA in a retirement income plan discusses that type of planning, including the idea of time segmentation.
- A ladder across insurers. Each rung is purchased from a different insurer, which interacts with guaranty association limits, covered below.
Which shape suits a person depends on what the money is for, when it may be needed, and how much movement they are comfortable managing.
Ladder, single contract, CD ladder or Treasury ladder
A ladder of MYGAs can be compared with a single contract, and with ladders built from other instruments. The table is a framework for the comparison, and it does not rank them.
| Question | MYGA ladder | One large MYGA | CD ladder | Treasury ladder |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dates to manage | Several | One | Several | Several |
| Access before maturity | Surrender charges and possibly a market value adjustment | Same, on the whole amount | Early withdrawal penalties set by the bank | Securities can generally be sold before maturity at the market price |
| Protection behind it | The insurer’s claims-paying ability, with limited state guaranty association backing | Same, concentrated in one insurer | FDIC deposit insurance up to its limit | Backed by the U.S. government |
| Tax timing on interest | Generally deferred until withdrawn, for non-qualified money | Same | Interest is generally reported each year | Interest is generally reported each year; federal tax applies |
| Reinvestment timing | Staggered | One date | Staggered | Staggered |
Our side-by-side comparison of MYGAs, CDs and Treasuries describes those differences in more detail, including state tax treatment, liquidity and how reportable interest can affect other parts of a financial picture.
Guaranty association limits and spreading money across insurers
This is the part of laddering where details matter most. A MYGA is an insurance contract, not a bank deposit, and it is not FDIC-insured. The guarantee depends on the claims-paying ability of the insurer that issued it. If an insurer is unable to pay, state life and health insurance guaranty associations provide limited protection. For Ohio residents, Ohio’s statute (Revised Code 3956.04) sets the guaranty association’s limit for annuities at $250,000 in the present value of annuity benefits, including net cash surrender and net cash withdrawal values, “with respect to any one life, regardless of the number of policies or contracts.” The statute also sets an overall aggregate cap per individual across certain categories of benefits, so the limit that applies to you may depend on what else you have with the same insurer. Other states have their own laws, and the limits can change, so check the current law for the state where you live. Ohio law (Revised Code 3956.18) also bars using the existence of the guaranty association to sell or solicit coverage, and the association’s summary document warns buyers not to rely on association coverage when selecting an insurer. We describe the limits here only so you can understand how they are counted, not as a reason to buy any contract.
Three points follow.
- Contracts with the same insurer share a limit. The Ohio language says the cap is applied to one life regardless of how many contracts there are. Three rungs bought from one insurer are not three separate $250,000 limits. They are counted together for that insurer.
- Contracts with different insurers are treated separately. The National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations (NOLHGA) states in its FAQ material that coverage levels apply separately for each insolvent insurer. That describes how the limits are counted. It is not a reason to choose one insurer over another.
- Anything above the limit is not covered by the association. NOLHGA notes that amounts above the limit may be claimed against the failed insurer’s estate, which is a different and less certain path than association coverage. Some benefits are also excluded entirely: Ohio’s statute excludes any portion of a contract whose crediting rate exceeds a formula tied to a corporate bond yield average, so a very high rate is not necessarily covered in full.
A hypothetical, for illustration only, showing how the counting works: a saver holds $400,000 in MYGAs, all with one insurer. For that insurer, the Ohio annuity limit would be $250,000, leaving $150,000 above the limit ($400,000 minus $250,000). If the saver instead held $200,000 with each of two insurers, each balance would be below the $250,000 limit on its own. Real balances grow with interest, so present value is what is measured, and a balance that starts below a limit can drift above it. Using more than one insurer also means two sets of financial strength to assess, two sets of notices, and two sets of terms.
Dividing money among insurers changes how the limit is counted, but it does not remove credit exposure to any insurer. Guaranty associations are a backstop with caps, exclusions and processes of their own, and the first line of protection is the insurer’s own financial strength. Our page on insurer ratings and state guaranty associations explains how rating agencies describe insurers and how the guaranty system works.
Rebuilding rungs when they mature
The test of a ladder comes when a rung ends. The decisions are the same ones described in our guide to what happens when a MYGA guarantee period ends: renew, withdraw, move by a 1035 exchange, or convert to income. A ladder adds a few considerations.
- Which term to buy next. If the goal is to keep a stable ladder, the maturing rung often goes into the longest rung of the ladder. If the goal has changed, the ladder can be allowed to shorten or end.
- Whether the rung stays with the same insurer. A renewal keeps the money in place and leaves one insurer’s balance where it was. A move to a new insurer changes how balances are divided, and it brings the paperwork and surrender-period tradeoffs of any new contract.
- Minimum premiums. Insurers set minimum amounts for new contracts, and those minimums differ. A small rung may not meet them. A ladder made of many small pieces can run into this.
- The window. Each rung has its own decision window, with a length set by the contract. With several rungs, calendar discipline matters. A missed window on one rung can mean renewal on terms you did not compare.
Taxes and reporting for a ladder
Each rung is its own contract, so each has its own cost basis and its own gain. The tax rules are the same ones that apply to any fixed annuity, and a tax professional can apply them to your situation. Here are the main ones.
For non-qualified money, gains generally are not taxed until withdrawn. A rung that matures and is withdrawn produces ordinary income on the gain. Under section 72(e) of the tax code, withdrawals before the annuity starting date are treated as coming from earnings first. If the owner is under age 59½, section 72(q) adds a 10 percent additional tax on the part of the withdrawal that is includible in gross income, subject to listed exceptions (the IRS describes the additional tax and the exceptions on its early-distribution topic page).
A ladder that is meant to supply spending money will therefore create reportable income when rungs are withdrawn, and the timing of that income can affect other things. Reportable income can change how much of a Social Security benefit is taxed, and it can count toward the income-related adjustments to Medicare premiums. That is one reason some people stagger terms with taxes in mind. The annuity tax guide explains the rules, and our IRMAA explainer explains how Medicare looks at income.
A rung that is moved into a new annuity under section 1035 is not taxed at the time of the exchange if the rules are met. Treasury Regulation 1.1035-1 requires the same person or persons to be the obligee under the new contract, which in practice means the owner and annuitant generally must match. A reportable exchange appears on Form 1099-R with code 6. If a rung is split, the IRS’s Revenue Procedure 2011-38 treats a partial direct transfer as an exchange when no amounts are received from either contract during the 180 days after the transfer, apart from certain annuity payments. That 180-day rule is a reason to plan a ladder rebuild carefully, especially when money is also being withdrawn for spending.
Compare this with ladders built from CDs or Treasury securities, where interest is generally reportable each year. The deferral in an annuity ladder postpones the tax, and it does not eliminate it.
Required minimum distributions on a qualified ladder
When MYGAs are held inside an IRA, required minimum distributions apply, with the starting age set by federal law and depending on the year you were born. The IRS explains that an IRA owner calculates the required distribution separately for each IRA but may take the total from one or more of them. That flexibility can be useful, because it may let you satisfy the requirement from an IRA holding an account that is not locked up in a contract with surrender charges. For a ladder, it means planning for the required amount to be available each year without having to break a rung early.
Ask both the insurer and the IRA custodian how the contract’s value is counted for the calculation and how the distribution would be paid. Rules about waivers of surrender charges for required distributions vary by contract, so check the wording. Moving qualified money between insurers is normally done by a transfer between custodians rather than by a 1035 exchange, and the IRS instructions for Form 1099-R say a transfer between trustees or issuers with no payment to the participant is generally not reported.
Drawbacks to weigh
A ladder is not the right fit for every situation. The honest list of drawbacks is long enough to take seriously.
- Complexity. Several contracts means several statements, several notices, several windows and several sets of terms.
- Minimum premium rules. Splitting a sum into small rungs may not meet each insurer’s minimum.
- Dependence on the rate environment. A ladder buys at different times and for different lengths, and the rate offered on each rung is what it is. Some rungs may turn out to look less attractive in hindsight.
- Surrender charges still exist. Spreading terms does not remove them. If an unplanned need arises, breaking a rung early can cost money, and a market value adjustment can raise or lower the amount.
- Insurer concentration or spread. Using one insurer concentrates credit exposure. Using several means evaluating several insurers.
- Shorter terms may not suit everyone’s goals. A short rung may reach maturity at a time when renewal terms are unfavorable, with no ability to predict this ahead of time.
Who might look at a ladder, and who might not
A ladder tends to appeal to people who have a sum they do not expect to need for several years, who value knowing when money becomes available, and who are comfortable managing multiple dates or working with someone who tracks them. It may not suit someone who needs ready access to most of the money, who would find multiple contracts hard to keep track of, or whose sum is too small to divide into contracts that meet insurers’ minimums. Our page on who might consider a MYGA covers the broader suitability questions, and it applies to every rung of a ladder as much as to a single contract. If you would like to talk through whether a ladder fits your situation, you are welcome to contact us.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many rungs should a MYGA ladder have?
There is no standard number. Some people use three to five rungs to get regular maturities without too many contracts, but the right number depends on the amount of money, insurers’ minimum premiums, how many dates you are willing to manage and what each rung is for. More rungs mean more flexibility and more administration.
Does a ladder earn more than a single MYGA?
Not by design. A ladder changes when money matures, and it does not change the rate on any contract. Depending on what rates do, a ladder can turn out better or worse than a single contract. Its purpose is to spread timing, not to raise returns.
Do I need a different insurer for each rung?
No. Rungs can be with the same insurer, and if they are, they count together toward the same guaranty association limit for that insurer. Using several insurers means evaluating each one and managing more paperwork, and Ohio’s guaranty association materials say not to rely on association coverage when selecting an insurer. Annuities are not FDIC-insured, and their guarantees depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability.
What happens to taxes when a rung matures?
For non-qualified money, nothing is taxed just because the term ends. Tax arises when you withdraw the gain. If you move the rung to another annuity through a 1035 exchange that meets the rules, the exchange is not taxed at the time. Withdrawals before age 59½ can bring a 10 percent additional tax on the taxable part, with exceptions. Check your situation with a tax professional.
Can I add rungs to a ladder later?
Yes, a ladder can be extended or restructured when you have new money or when a rung matures. Each new rung is a new contract with its own rate, surrender schedule, free-look period and terms. If the new money comes from an existing annuity, replacement rules and paperwork may apply.
Is a MYGA ladder the same as a CD ladder?
The shape is the same, but the contracts are different. A MYGA is an insurance contract backed by an insurer, with state guaranty association limits, deferred tax treatment for non-qualified money and surrender charges. A CD is a bank deposit with FDIC insurance up to its limit and annually reportable interest. The tradeoffs in each should be weighed in addition to the rates.
Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.
Ready to talk through your options?
It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.
