No annuity is protected the way a bank deposit is, so the useful question is what stands behind the promise. An annuity is a contract with an insurance company, and its guarantees depend on that company’s ability to pay. Several layers sit behind it: the contract’s own terms, the insurer’s reserves and capital, state regulation, independent rating opinions, and, as a limited backstop, the state guaranty association. This page walks through each layer, with the Ohio guaranty limits as they appear in the statute.
Why “safe” is the wrong first question
Our page on whether annuities are a safe investment covers the basics: different annuity types carry different risks, and the insurer standing behind the contract matters as much as the product. Here we go one level deeper into what that backing consists of. For a hub overview of how fixed indexed annuities and multi-year guaranteed annuities fit together, see the annuities guide.
The word “safe” hides several separate questions. Will the insurer be able to pay what the contract promises? If it cannot, what happens to the contract? How much of the balance would be covered? And apart from insurer failure, are there contract terms, such as surrender charges, that could cost you money if your plans change? This page addresses the first three. The fourth is covered in the fixed indexed annuity risks and myths page.
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities puts the starting point plainly: all product guarantees depend on the insurance company’s financial strength and claims-paying ability. Everything below is a way of looking at that one sentence.
The layers behind an annuity guarantee
Think of the protection as a series of layers, each with its own job and its own limits. None of them is a guarantee on its own.
| Layer | What it is | What it does not do |
|---|---|---|
| Contract terms | The written promises: crediting rules, minimum values, surrender schedule, riders | Does not make the insurer able to pay; a contract is only as sound as its issuer |
| Insurer capital and reserves | Assets the insurer must hold against its obligations, under statutory accounting rules | Does not prevent failure; regulators describe these requirements as early-warning tools |
| State regulation | The insurance department that licenses, examines and can take over an insurer | Does not guarantee that any particular insurer will stay solvent |
| Rating agency opinions | Independent, forward-looking views of an insurer’s ability to meet obligations | Not a guarantee, not a prediction of failure, not advice to buy |
| Guaranty association | State-created safety net funded by other insurers, paying up to statutory limits | Does not cover everything, and does not equal FDIC insurance |
| Claim on the insurer’s estate | The right to claim against what remains of a failed insurer for amounts above the limits | May be paid only in part |
Not FDIC-insured: what that means
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation insures deposits at member banks, and its standard coverage is $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category. The FDIC states that it does not insure annuities, including annuities bought through an insured bank. An annuity is not a deposit. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide describes an annuity as a contract with an insurance company and says its guarantees depend on that company’s financial strength and claims-paying ability.
That does not mean an annuity is unprotected. It means the protection comes from a different system, built around insurance regulation and state guaranty associations, with different limits, different mechanics and a different funding source. Comparing the two systems dollar for dollar can mislead, because the FDIC is a federal deposit insurance program while guaranty associations are state-level and funded by assessments on insurers. For how that difference affects a comparison with certificates of deposit, see MYGA vs. CD vs. Treasury.
How insurers are regulated
Insurance in the United States is regulated mainly by the states. Each insurer has a home (domiciliary) state whose insurance department leads its financial oversight, and it must be licensed in each state where it sells. In Ohio, the Superintendent of Insurance heads the Ohio Department of Insurance.
Statutory accounting and capital. Insurers file financial statements prepared under statutory accounting rules, which are designed with policyholder protection in mind. Layered on top is risk-based capital (RBC). The NAIC describes RBC as a statutory minimum amount of capital based on two factors: the size of the insurer and the riskiness of its assets and operations. Riskier companies must hold more. The NAIC is explicit that RBC is not a stand-alone measure of solvency and is not meant to rank companies. Its purpose is to flag weakly capitalized insurers so regulators can step in early.
Ohio adopted the framework in Chapter 3903 of the Revised Code. A domestic insurer must file an RBC report with the Superintendent each year, and for life insurers the formula takes asset risk, insurance risk, interest rate risk and other business risks into account. The statute sets escalating trigger points measured as multiples of an “authorized control level” figure: 2.0 times that figure is the company action level, 1.5 times the regulatory action level, and 0.70 times the mandatory control level. The Ohio General Assembly’s own findings in that chapter add a useful caution: capital above the required minimum is desirable, and the minimum does not fully measure every risk in the business.
Rehabilitation and liquidation. When an insurer gets into serious trouble, state law gives the home-state regulator a defined process. In Ohio, only the Superintendent can begin a delinquency proceeding against a domestic insurer, and the case is brought in the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas. The Superintendent may seek a rehabilitation order where continuing business would be financially hazardous to policyholders, creditors or the public. The Superintendent may seek liquidation on grounds that include insolvency or a hazardous financial condition. Other states have their own versions for the insurers they domicile.
Priority in a liquidation. Ohio’s order-of-payment statute puts administrative costs first, and then, in the second class, claims under policies for losses incurred. That second class expressly includes claims under life insurance, annuity policies and funding agreements, whether for death proceeds, annuity proceeds, investment values, principal or interest, which are treated as loss claims. Claims of a guaranty association also fall into that class. Policyholder claims therefore rank ahead of general creditors, though what remains to pay them depends on what the estate holds.
Reading insurer ratings
Rating agencies publish opinions on an insurer’s financial strength. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide names four main firms: A.M. Best Company, Standard and Poor’s, Moody’s Investors Service and Fitch Ratings. Each uses its own scale, so the same letter does not mean the same thing across agencies.
AM Best’s scale. AM Best publishes its Financial Strength Rating scale with these categories:
| Category | Symbols | AM Best wording |
|---|---|---|
| Superior | A++, A+ | Superior ability to meet ongoing insurance obligations |
| Excellent | A, A- | Excellent ability |
| Good | B++, B+ | Good ability |
| Fair | B, B- | Fair ability; financial strength vulnerable to adverse changes in underwriting and economic conditions |
| Marginal | C++, C+ | Marginal ability; vulnerable to adverse changes |
| Weak | C, C- | Weak ability; very vulnerable |
| Poor | D | Poor ability; extremely vulnerable |
AM Best also uses designations that are not ratings. “E” marks an insurer placed under court-ordered conservation or rehabilitation, or one where clear regulatory action has limited policyholder payments. “F” marks an insurer placed in liquidation after a finding of insolvency. “S” suspends a rating when sudden, significant events make the rating implications impossible to evaluate. “NR” means not rated.
Other agencies. S&P and Moody’s use their own letter scales, with a dividing line between investment grade and speculative grade: BBB- on S&P’s scale and Baa3 on Moody’s. Fitch publishes its own scale as well. We do not reproduce every notch here because the definitions are the agencies’ to state; the practical step is to read each agency’s published definition for the exact symbol you are looking at.
What a rating is, and is not. AM Best describes its Financial Strength Rating as an independent opinion of an insurer’s financial strength and ability to meet ongoing policy and contract obligations. The same document says a rating is not assigned to a specific policy, does not address an insurer’s claims-payment procedures, is not a recommendation to purchase, hold or terminate a contract, and can be changed, suspended or withdrawn at any time. It also says a rating is forward-looking and cannot be treated as a fact or guarantee of future credit quality. Treat a rating as one input among several, not a verdict.
Practical habits when you look at ratings:
- Confirm which legal entity is rated. The company named on the contract is the one that owes you the guarantee, and a parent or affiliate rating may not apply to it.
- Note the date. Ratings are updated, and a stale screenshot in a sales packet is not a current rating.
- Look at more than one agency where you can, and read the outlook or any status designation attached to the rating.
- Remember that two insurers with the same symbol are alike in category, not identical. AM Best says as much.
The guaranty association system
Every state has a life and health insurance guaranty association, and the National Organization of Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Associations (NOLHGA), established in 1983, coordinates their response when a failure affects policyholders in many states. NOLHGA describes a task force that analyzes the failed insurer’s obligations, helps arrange for covered policies to move to a financially stable insurer where appropriate, and helps sell assets to raise funds for policyholder protection.
Ohio’s association. The Ohio Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Association is created by Chapter 3956 of the Revised Code as an unincorporated nonprofit association. Every insurer licensed to do life, annuity or health business in Ohio must be a member as a condition of its license. The association is supervised by the Superintendent of Insurance. Its stated purpose is to protect covered persons against losses when the insurer that issued a life, health or annuity contract becomes impaired or insolvent, by paying benefits and continuing coverages “as limited in this chapter.”
How it is funded. The statute funds the association through assessments on member insurers, calculated mainly on the premiums each member writes in Ohio. The statute separates administrative (class A) assessments from class B assessments tied to a particular impaired or insolvent insurer, and class B assessments are not called until necessary. Ohio caps what any one insurer can be assessed in a calendar year at 2 percent of its average annual Ohio premiums for the covered account, measured over the three calendar years before the year of the impairment or insolvency. The statute also allows an assessed insurer to consider the amount reasonably needed to meet its assessment obligations when it sets premium rates, and it provides for offsets against premium or franchise tax liability in some circumstances. We make no claim about how a particular assessment would ultimately be absorbed.
Which state’s association applies. Under NOLHGA’s description, the association in the state where the contract owner lives generally provides the coverage for an individual annuity, regardless of where the contract was bought. Ohio’s statute covers owners who are Ohio residents, with narrow exceptions for nonresidents, and it says it is to be read so that a person has coverage from only one association.
Ohio’s annuity coverage limits
The limits are in Ohio Revised Code section 3956.04. For annuities, the association’s liability is limited to the lesser of the insurer’s contractual obligations and the statutory cap. The cap that applies to an individual annuity owner is $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits, including net cash surrender and net cash withdrawal values, with respect to any one life, regardless of the number of policies or contracts.
Three points follow from the statute’s wording:
- Per person, across contracts. The limit is per life and applies “regardless of the number of policies or contracts.” Two contracts from the same failed insurer do not each receive their own $250,000.
- Separate for each failed insurer. NOLHGA states that coverage levels are applied separately for each insolvent insurance company, and that coverage in one company’s insolvency does not reduce coverage in another’s. If you own contracts with two different insurers, a failure at one is measured against that insurer’s contracts only.
- A combined ceiling. The statute also says the association is not liable to expend more than $300,000 in the aggregate with respect to any one individual across the categories in divisions (D)(2)(a), (b) and (d), which include life, health, disability, long-term care and annuity benefits, governmental-plan unallocated annuities and structured settlement annuities. Health benefit plan coverage has its own $500,000 figure. In practice, a person with several kinds of covered contracts may face that combined ceiling, not just the annuity figure.
Other categories have their own figures in the same section, including $250,000 per participant for unallocated annuity contracts funding certain governmental retirement plans and $250,000 per payee for structured settlement annuities. NOLHGA describes the $250,000 present-value level as the coverage level in most states, but limits are set by each state’s law and can differ. This page describes Ohio. If you live elsewhere, your own state’s statute governs.
What “present value” means here. The limit is stated in terms of the present value of the benefits the contract promises, not simply the account balance on a statement. The two figures can differ, and an annuity in payout status is measured by the value of its remaining payments rather than by an account balance.
A hypothetical, for illustration only. Suppose an owner holds a single deferred annuity with a present value of $400,000 at an insurer that later fails. NOLHGA describes partial coverage as a ratio of the coverage level to the benefits: $250,000 divided by $400,000 is 62.5 percent. The owner’s remaining claim of $150,000 would be a claim against the failed insurer’s estate. Now suppose the same $400,000 had instead been split evenly into two contracts at two different insurers, $200,000 each. Each is below the $250,000 level, so if one insurer failed, that contract would sit within the limit. This is a simple arithmetic example of how the limit is measured. It is not a recommendation to buy or to split any contract, not a prediction that any insurer will fail, and not a statement about how any actual insolvency would be handled. Holding several contracts also means more paperwork, more contracts to manage and, for some products, minimum premium requirements.
What the guaranty association does not cover
The statute lists exclusions, and some matter specifically for annuity owners:
- Amounts above the limits. These are not covered by the association, though they may be claimed against the estate.
- Portions not guaranteed by the insurer. The association does not cover any portion of a contract that the insurer does not guarantee or under which the contract holder bears the risk. This is why money in variable annuity investment sub-accounts is outside the protection, since the holder carries that market risk.
- Interest or crediting rates above a formula. The statute excludes a portion of a contract to the extent that its interest or index-based crediting rate exceeds a rate derived from Moody’s monthly average corporate bond yield, less two percentage points averaged over the four years before the association became obligated, and less three percentage points from that date forward. A contract with an unusually high credited rate or bonus may therefore be only partly covered.
- Index credits not yet credited. For indexed contracts, the statute excludes interest or value changes determined by an index that have not been credited, or that are subject to forfeiture, as of the date the insurer becomes impaired or insolvent, with a special rule for contracts that credit less often than annually. This is one reason it helps to know where in a crediting period a contract stands; our annuity glossary defines the crediting terms.
- Claims outside the written contract. The association’s liability is limited to the express terms of the policy and the statute, and is not affected by brochures, illustrations, advertisements or other sales material.
- Other listed exclusions, including policies issued in Ohio by an insurer that was not licensed or authorized to issue them, self-funded or uninsured employer plans, and policies providing Medicare Parts C and D or Medicaid benefits.
How a failure could be handled. When an insurer becomes insolvent, the Ohio association may, at its discretion, guarantee, assume, reissue or reinsure the covered contracts, assure payment of the insolvent insurer’s contractual obligations, or provide benefits and coverages under the statute. For an indexed contract, the statute allows the association to issue a substitute contract that replaces the index with a fixed interest rate, a different calculation method or minimum-guaranteed dividends, so long as other material terms stay substantially similar. With court approval, it may also impose temporary moratoriums or liens on payments of cash values and policy loans, and permanent contract liens in defined circumstances. In other words, a covered owner may see continuity of the covered benefits, but not necessarily immediate access to cash or the same crediting method.
What past insolvencies show
One of the most cited cases is Executive Life Insurance Company of California, placed in conservation by the California Insurance Commissioner in April 1991. According to the California State Auditor, Aurora National Life Assurance Company assumed and reinsured nearly all of its policies under a rehabilitation plan the California Supreme Court upheld in September 1993, and those policies were revalued at approximately 78 percent of their original value. In 2005 the California Department of Insurance estimated policyholders recovered 90 percent of their original policy rights, while the Auditor estimated 86 percent of expected account values, a difference the Auditor attributes partly to factors such as the time value of money. NOLHGA’s materials report that the estate closed in August 2022.
We include these figures with care. They describe one insurer from more than three decades ago, before the current guaranty association statutes took their present form, and they are not a forecast of what would happen in any future failure. They do show two things worth knowing: insolvency outcomes can take many years to finish, and recovery in a real case can be less than one hundred percent of what a contract once promised.
A more recent example from a different line of business is Penn Treaty, a long-term care insurer. NOLHGA’s materials say that after a 2022 Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruling, payments above guaranty association limits were not permissible under Pennsylvania law. That case involved long-term care policies, not annuities, but it shows the limits are applied as written.
How to check an insurer before you sign
- Ask which company issues the contract and confirm its legal name on the application and disclosure documents.
- Look up current ratings from at least one agency and read the agency’s own definition of the symbol.
- Check complaint history. The NAIC’s Consumer Insurance Search provides closed, confirmed complaint information reported by state insurance departments, which can be searched by state, company and insurance type, generally covering the past few years. The NAIC cautions against relying on a single factor and notes that a company’s complaint index can shift with overall market trends. Complaints themselves are filed with your state department of insurance. The Ohio Department of Insurance accepts complaints about insurance companies through an online consumer complaint form.
- Ask for the guaranty association summary. Ohio law requires member insurers to deliver a summary document with a new contract, and to provide it on request. The Ohio association’s own site, olhiga.org, also describes its role. The same chapter bars using the existence of the guaranty association for sales, solicitation or inducement to purchase insurance, and this page is education about the system, not a reason to buy any contract.
- Read the buyer’s guide the insurer or agent is required to provide, and compare what is guaranteed with what is not.
- Know what the limits mean for the amount involved. If the amount is above $250,000 at one insurer, the portion above the limit would not be covered by the association. The limit is a fact about the system, not a reason to buy; a licensed professional can help you weigh it with everything else in your plan.
Our annuity buying checklist turns these steps into a full pre-purchase list, and the comparison of fixed indexed annuities and MYGAs shows how the product type changes which guarantees you are relying on. If you hold several multi-year contracts, the laddering page explains how spreading maturities and carriers interact. Readers in Ohio can find state-specific rules gathered on our Ohio annuity page.
Limits of this page
The numbers above come from Ohio statute and from NOLHGA, NAIC, FDIC and rating-agency materials as we read them, and laws, limits and ratings change. They apply to Ohio residents; the rules in Kentucky, Indiana and every other state are set by those states. A guaranty association’s actual obligations in a given insolvency depend on the facts of the failure, the court orders and the contract. None of this is legal, tax or investment advice, and it does not predict that any insurer will fail. If you would like to talk through an insurer’s ratings or how a particular contract is structured, you can reach us through our contact page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are annuities insured by the FDIC?
No. The FDIC states that it does not insure annuities, even those purchased through an insured bank. An annuity’s guarantees are obligations of the issuing insurance company. Limited protection comes from the state guaranty association system, which works differently from deposit insurance.
What is the Ohio guaranty association limit for annuities?
Under Ohio Revised Code section 3956.04, the limit is $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits, including net cash surrender and net cash withdrawal values, per person regardless of the number of contracts. The statute also contains a $300,000 aggregate ceiling per individual across several categories of coverage. Limits can change, so confirm the current statute or ask the association.
Does the limit apply per contract or per insurer?
Under Ohio’s wording, the limit applies per life, regardless of the number of contracts, and NOLHGA says coverage levels are applied separately for each insolvent insurer. So two contracts at the same failed insurer share one limit, while contracts at different insurers are measured separately.
Are index credits covered if my insurer fails?
Only partly, and only as the statute allows. Ohio excludes index-based interest that has not yet been credited, or is subject to forfeiture, at the date the insurer becomes impaired or insolvent. It also excludes credited rates that exceed a formula tied to a corporate bond average. Ask what your specific contract would likely be treated as.
Is a high insurer rating a guarantee?
No. AM Best describes its rating as a forward-looking opinion that is not a recommendation to buy, hold or terminate a contract and can be changed, suspended or withdrawn at any time. A rating is useful context, but it does not guarantee that an insurer will meet its obligations.
Do guaranty associations use taxpayer money?
The association is funded by assessments on member insurers rather than by a direct appropriation, and each insurer’s yearly assessment is capped at 2 percent of its average annual Ohio premiums for the covered account. The statute also lets assessed insurers consider assessments when setting rates and provides tax offsets in some circumstances, so we do not claim that no cost reaches the public. Ohio law also exempts the association itself from state and local fees and taxes. For how a particular assessment would be handled, ask the association or the Ohio Department of Insurance.
Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.
Ready to talk through your options?
It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.
