A careful annuity purchase follows an order: decide what job the money has to do, match that job to a product type, read the disclosure documents before you apply, check the insurer, get the rates, surrender terms and rider rules in writing, and keep records. This page walks through those steps with the questions to ask at each one. It is educational, not a recommendation to buy any product. Annuities are insurance contracts, they are not FDIC-insured, and their guarantees depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability.
Start before any conversation: define the job and the timeline
Most regrets about annuities trace back to a mismatch between what the contract does and what the buyer assumed it did. So start with three written answers, before you look at a single product.
- What is this money for? Examples: growth that is predictable to a known date, growth linked to an index with limited downside, or a stream of income later in retirement. Each points to a different kind of contract.
- When might you need it? A contract with a surrender period only makes sense if you can leave the money alone for the whole period, or accept the cost of leaving early.
- What else covers your needs? Emergency savings, health-care costs, income you already have from Social Security or a pension, and other tax-deferred accounts all affect how much liquidity you want to give up.
The NAIC Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities puts several of these as questions you should be able to answer yourself: how the annuity helps meet your overall objectives and time horizons, what features other than tax deferral make it appropriate for you, and whether you are making use of other tax-deferred opportunities such as 401(k)s, 403(b)s and IRAs. If you cannot answer them yet, that is useful information. Our annuity guide overview maps the contract families to the problems each is built to solve.
Name the product type you are actually being shown
Annuity is a broad word. The paperwork will tell you which kind you have, but you should know before you read it.
| Type | How value changes | Who may sell it |
|---|---|---|
| Fixed (including MYGA) | The insurer declares a rate, which the insurer guarantees for a stated period | Licensed insurance producer |
| Fixed indexed | Interest is linked to an index through a formula, with a floor of zero for index credits | Licensed insurance producer |
| Immediate or income annuity | You pay a premium and income begins soon after | Licensed insurance producer |
| Variable annuity or RILA | Value follows investment subaccounts or index-linked investment options and can go down | Securities-licensed professional, with a prospectus |
Variable annuities and registered index-linked annuities are securities products. We mention them only so you can tell them apart from the fixed products on this site; they carry investment risk that the others do not, and they are outside what this page covers. If someone describes a product as “an annuity with market growth and no risk,” stop and ask which type it is and where the downside appears. Our guides to fixed indexed annuities and multi-year guaranteed annuities explain the two fixed types in depth, and the side-by-side comparison shows where they differ.
Read the Buyer’s Guide and disclosure before you apply
Regulators designed two documents to be in your hands early, and you should read them rather than wait for the contract.
The NAIC Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities explains how deferred annuities work in general terms and lists questions to put to the insurer or the person selling. It says plainly that it is about annuities in general, not any particular product, so your annuity may have features it does not describe.
The disclosure document is product-specific. The NAIC guide describes it as a document covering the key features of your annuity, including what is guaranteed and what is not, and the fees and charges. Ask for any illustration too, and ask what is guaranteed in it and what assumptions it uses. An illustration that shows index-linked values under assumed future conditions is a projection, not a promise.
Ohio’s annuity disclosure rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-6-14, built on the NAIC model) sets the timing. For a face-to-face application, the Buyer’s Guide and the disclosure document are to be provided at or before the time of application. For other applications, such as by mail or online, they are to be sent no later than five business days after the insurer receives the completed application. If they are not delivered on time, the rule gives the applicant a free look of at least 15 days to return the contract without penalty. The annuity glossary is a quick reference if the documents use a term you do not recognize.
Check the insurer as carefully as the product
A contract is a promise from a specific company, and the NAIC guide says it directly: all product guarantees depend on the insurance company’s financial strength and claims-paying ability. Three checks take little time.
- Ratings. The NAIC guide names four main rating firms: A.M. Best, Standard and Poor’s, Moody’s and Fitch. A rating is an opinion about an insurer’s ability to meet its obligations. A.M. Best’s own definitions describe its ratings as opinions of an insurer’s ability to meet its ongoing obligations, which is different from a prediction or a recommendation to buy. Each firm uses its own symbols, so read each firm’s published scale rather than assuming one letter means the same thing everywhere, and check that the rating you are looking at is current.
- Complaint and financial data. The NAIC Consumer Information Source is a database for researching an insurer’s financial information and complaint data. The NAIC notes that state insurance departments supply the information voluntarily, so not every state or company appears. Your state insurance department can also tell you about complaints.
- Guaranty association protection. If an insurer fails, state guaranty associations provide limited protection. NOLHGA describes the coverage level for a fixed annuity as $250,000 in present value in most states, and notes that coverage generally comes from the association of the state where the contract owner lives. Ohio Revised Code section 3956.04 sets the Ohio association’s limit for the present value of annuity benefits at $250,000 for any one life, regardless of the number of contracts, within an overall cap that also covers certain other benefit types, and NOLHGA notes that coverage of more than one policy is generally subject to an aggregate limit per person. Limits, exclusions and what is covered can change, and some amounts, such as index-linked interest not yet credited, are generally not covered, so confirm the current rules for your state.
Our page on insurer ratings and state guaranty associations goes further into how to read these sources.
Get rates, guarantees and changeable terms in writing
This is the section where products differ most, so ask for each item on paper and note where in the contract it appears.
| Item | Question to ask | What a clear answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum guarantee | Is there a guaranteed minimum interest rate or minimum guaranteed surrender value? | A number or formula stated in the contract and disclosure |
| Fixed-rate annuity renewals | What is the initial rate and how long does it last? How and when will the renewal rate be announced? Is there a minimum renewal rate? | Dates, a notice method and a stated floor |
| Indexed annuity formula | Which index, which crediting method, and what are the cap, participation rate or spread? Which of these can the insurer change, and how often? | Current values labeled as non-guaranteed, plus any guaranteed minimum or maximum |
| Early withdrawals | If I take money out before the index term ends, what happens to the interest for that term? | A plain statement. The NAIC guide notes that the annuity may not add all index-linked interest for that term |
| Bonuses | Is there a premium or interest bonus, and what do I give up to get it? | Conditions, vesting and any surrender or withdrawal limits tied to it |
| Fees and charges | Is there a contract fee, a charge on purchase payments, a transaction fee or a state premium tax? | A complete list with amounts |
Two cautions. First, a zero floor on index credits means index-linked interest is not negative; it does not mean charges, rider fees or surrender charges cannot reduce what you receive. Second, anything labeled current is not the same as guaranteed. The SEC’s investor bulletin on indexed annuities notes that contracts commonly let the insurer change terms such as participation rates and caps on a periodic basis, such as annually. When you compare two products, compare the guaranteed minimums as well as the current offers. Our fixed indexed annuity guide explains each term in detail.
Study the surrender schedule and how you can take money out
Surrender and withdrawal terms decide how flexible the contract really is. The NAIC guide says the surrender charge is a percentage of the amount you take out and usually declines each year until the surrender period ends. It also points to waivers for events such as death and to the right, in many contracts, to take out a small amount each year (usually up to 10%) without a surrender charge. Check the contract itself, because the percentage and rules vary.
Questions to ask, drawn from the NAIC guide and the SEC bulletin:
- Is there a limit on how much I can take out each year without a surrender charge, and a limit on the total during the surrender period?
- How long is the surrender period, and does the charge decline year by year or stay level?
- Is there a market value adjustment, and in which direction does it move? The NAIC guide explains that in general, if interest rates are higher at withdrawal than when you bought, the adjustment could reduce what you receive, and if lower, it could increase it, though every calculation is different.
- What do I actually receive, in dollars, if I surrender after year 1, year 3, year 5 and year 10?
- Are there waivers, such as nursing home confinement or terminal illness, and do they apply in my state?
Here is a hypothetical to show why dollar amounts matter. This is for illustration only; it is not a current rate, a quote or any actual product. Suppose a contract has a $100,000 account value, allows a withdrawal of 10% of the account value each year without a surrender charge, and has a hypothetical surrender charge of 7% in contract year 3. A $30,000 withdrawal in year 3 would be treated as $10,000 within the allowance and $20,000 above it. The charge would apply to the $20,000: $20,000 x 7% = $1,400. Before income tax, you would receive $28,600 ($30,000 less $1,400). Real contracts differ in how they treat the allowance and in how the account value changes, so use your own contract’s language.
Withdrawals also have tax consequences, including a possible additional 10% federal tax on the taxable portion before age 59½, subject to exceptions. Ask your tax professional before you commit; our page on how fixed annuities are taxed gives the general rules.
Understand every rider before you pay for it
The NAIC guide notes that you can add riders to many annuities, usually at extra cost, and that a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit is a common one with fixed indexed annuities. With any rider, ask:
- What does it cost, how often is it charged, and is the fee based on the account value or on a separate income base?
- Is the benefit a guaranteed income stream, a calculated figure used only to set income, or cash you can withdraw? The two are not the same.
- What actions can reduce or end the guarantee, such as withdrawals beyond the permitted amount?
- What happens to the rider if I die, if my spouse is the joint annuitant, or if the account value falls to zero?
- Can the insurer change the rider fee or terms after purchase?
Our explanation of fixed indexed annuity income riders walks through the account value versus income base distinction in detail.
Ask how the person selling it is paid
You are entitled to ask, and Ohio’s rule backs that up. Under Ohio Administrative Code 3901-6-13, an agent recommending an annuity must give a prominent disclosure that covers the scope of the relationship and the agent’s role, the products the agent is licensed to sell, the insurers the agent can sell for, the types and sources of cash and non-cash compensation, and the consumer’s right to ask about cash compensation. On request, the agent must also estimate cash compensation and say whether it is one-time or recurring.
The NAIC guide adds context. It says insurance companies usually pay the salesperson after the sale, and that the payment does not reduce the amount you pay into the annuity. It also says fees and charges help cover the insurer’s costs to sell and manage the annuity. The guide does not detail how the insurer funds that payment, so a commission that does not come out of your premium does not by itself tell you how the product is priced. Ask any producer, including us, to explain how compensation works and whether it varies by product or term.
The same Ohio rule requires the agent to act in the consumer’s best interest, without placing the agent’s or the insurer’s financial interest ahead of the consumer’s, and to identify and avoid or reasonably manage and disclose material conflicts of interest. Ohio’s rule treats this as a regulatory duty, not a fiduciary one.
Treat replacements and 1035 exchanges with extra care
If you already own an annuity or life insurance policy, replacing it deserves its own review. Ohio’s replacement rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-6-05) defines a replacement as a transaction where the person proposing the new contract knows or should know that an existing contract will be terminated, reduced or otherwise altered, which includes a surrender or partial surrender.
What the rules require, in plain terms:
- When an applicant reports existing coverage, the agent must present and read the replacement notice, and both the applicant and the agent sign it. The notice lists each annuity being replaced.
- The existing insurer must provide information on current contract values, such as an in-force illustration or summary, within five business days of a request.
- Under the best-interest standard, the agent must weigh the whole transaction, including surrender charges, lost benefits, higher fees and any other exchange within the prior sixty months.
- The NAIC replacement model’s notice urges you to compare the costs and benefits of the existing and proposed contracts.
For taxes, federal law (IRC section 1035) allows no gain or loss to be recognized on the exchange of an annuity contract for another annuity contract. That is a tax rule, not a reason to exchange. Before any exchange, ask: Will a new surrender period start? Will I lose a bonus, a rider or a guaranteed benefit I already have? What happens to my cost basis? Use a direct transfer between companies rather than taking a check, and have your tax professional confirm the details.
Answer the suitability questions accurately, then keep your copies
The producer must collect a consumer profile before recommending an annuity. Under Ohio’s rule, at a minimum it covers age, annual income, financial situation and needs including debts, financial experience, insurance needs, financial objectives, the intended use of the annuity, time horizon, existing assets and products, liquidity needs, liquid net worth, risk tolerance (including willingness to accept non-guaranteed elements), the resources used to fund the annuity and tax status. A recommendation is only as sound as those answers. If you round liquidity needs up or understate other assets, the paperwork will describe someone who is not you.
Ohio’s rule also provides that if a consumer refuses to provide profile information, the agent must obtain a signed statement acknowledging the consequences, and if a consumer proceeds with a transaction the agent did not recommend, a signed statement is required for that too. The NAIC guide adds a practical test: if you are not comfortable with the annuity, ask the salesperson to explain why they recommended it, and do not buy an annuity you do not understand.
Keep a folder with the application, the Buyer’s Guide receipt, the disclosure, any illustration, the replacement notice if there was one, and your own notes of who told you what and when. If something important was said verbally, ask for it in writing or ask where it appears in the contract. Our overview of annuity rules and protections for Ohio retirees covers what is specific to the state.
After you apply: free look, contract review and the first-year routine
When the contract arrives, compare it with what you were told. The NAIC guide says many states give you a set number of days, usually 10 to 30, to change your mind after you receive the contract, and that the contract and disclosure should state the free look period prominently. Depending on the state, you get back either all of your money or your current account value. Another NAIC consumer sheet describes longer windows in some states, which is a reason to rely on the number printed in your contract rather than a general figure.
For Ohio, the state Department of Insurance’s consumer guide uses 10 days as an example of a contract-specified free look and says the period is 30 days when you buy an annuity to replace one you already have. The disclosure rule described earlier sets a floor of 15 days when the Buyer’s Guide and disclosure are late. Treat the free look as a time to verify, not as a substitute for research.
Then set up a short routine:
- Confirm the contract matches the application: owner, annuitant, beneficiaries, premium, product type and riders.
- Mark the dates that matter: the end of the free look, any crediting or anniversary dates, the end of each surrender period and any renewal-rate notice date.
- Review each annual statement: account value, credited interest, charges and any rider values.
- Revisit beneficiaries after life events. The NAIC guide asks how you will make sure your chosen survivors receive any payment if you die.
Red flags that call for slowing down
None of these proves bad intent, but each is a reason to pause and ask for the answer in writing.
- Pressure to decide today, or to sign before you have the Buyer’s Guide and disclosure.
- Descriptions such as “market returns with no risk,” or any promise of a return or of income that is not tied to a contract provision.
- Vague answers about surrender charges, caps, participation rates or compensation.
- A suggestion to surrender or replace an existing annuity without a written comparison.
- Illustrations that rely on past or back-tested index performance without clear labeling as hypothetical.
- Requests to sign blank forms, to shade the profile answers or to move money in a way that bypasses the insurer’s paperwork.
- Credentials offered in place of answers. The NAIC cautions that senior-sounding designations do not always show specialized knowledge, and suggests asking what the designation means and what was required to earn it.
If you believe you were misled, you can contact your state insurance department; the NAIC notes that complaints can be filed there.
Printable checklist
Use this list as a one-page summary. It is general; your situation may call for more.
- I wrote down what the money is for and when I might need it.
- I know my emergency reserves and other income sources.
- I know which type of annuity I am looking at: fixed, fixed indexed, MYGA, immediate, or a securities product.
- I read the NAIC Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities and the product disclosure.
- I asked for any illustration and for what is guaranteed in it.
- I checked the insurer’s current ratings with the rating firms themselves.
- I looked at complaint information through the state insurance department or the NAIC Consumer Information Source.
- I know the guaranty association limit that applies to me and that it is limited protection.
- I have the guaranteed minimums in writing, and I know which terms can change and how often.
- I know the surrender period, the schedule, the withdrawal allowance and any market value adjustment.
- I asked what I would receive in dollars if I left in years 1, 3, 5 and 10.
- I understand every rider fee and what could reduce or end each guarantee.
- I asked how the person selling it is paid and whether it varies by product.
- If this replaces something, I received and read the replacement notice, and I compared the existing contract in writing.
- I answered the suitability questions accurately, and my answers on liquidity and other assets are correct.
- I spoke with a tax professional about taxes and, if relevant, an attorney about legal questions.
- I noted the free look period in my contract and its end date.
- After delivery I checked the contract against the application and my notes.
- I named beneficiaries and know how the death benefit works.
- I set reminders for statements, anniversaries and the end of surrender periods.
Questions about a specific contract you are considering are easier to answer in a conversation. Contact our team to talk it through, and bring the documents with you.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to cancel an annuity after I buy it?
It depends on the state and the contract. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says many states give a set number of days, usually 10 to 30, and that the contract and disclosure should state the period prominently. In Ohio, the Department of Insurance’s consumer guide gives 30 days for a replacement annuity, and the disclosure rule sets a minimum of 15 days if the Buyer’s Guide and disclosure were not delivered on time. Read the figure printed in your contract.
Do I get all of my money back during the free look?
Not necessarily. The NAIC guide says that depending on the state, you will get back either all of your money or your current account value. Ohio’s replacement rule describes a full refund of premiums for a replacement contract returned in its free look, with different treatment for some contract types. Check the exact refund language in your contract.
Is an annuity FDIC-insured?
No. Annuities are insurance contracts, and their guarantees depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. If an insurer fails, state guaranty associations provide limited protection, subject to the limits and exclusions of the state that applies to you.
Does the commission come out of my premium?
The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says insurers usually pay the salesperson after the sale and that the payment does not reduce the amount you pay into the annuity. It also says fees and charges help cover the insurer’s costs to sell and manage the annuity, so ask how compensation relates to the product’s pricing and terms. Ohio’s rule lets you ask about cash compensation and requires an estimate on request.
Should I read the contract if I already read the disclosure?
Yes. The disclosure summarizes key features, but the contract is the legal document that binds you and the insurer. Check that the owner, annuitant, beneficiaries, premium, riders and surrender terms match your application, and use the free look period if something does not.
Who should I ask about the tax side?
A tax professional or attorney who knows your full situation. The NAIC guide states that its information is general and not tax advice. Our annuity guide and tax page explain the general rules, but they cannot replace advice on your own return.
Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.
Ready to talk through your options?
It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.
