A surrender charge is a fee a fixed indexed annuity (FIA) can deduct if you take out more than the contract allows during the surrender period, and the percentage usually declines each year until it reaches zero. Many contracts let you withdraw a limited amount each year, often described as up to 10% of the account value, without the charge. A market value adjustment (MVA), found in some contracts, can raise or lower what you receive depending on interest rates when you withdraw. Terms vary by contract, so the contract itself controls.
Why FIAs have surrender charges at all
An FIA is an insurance contract. The insurer invests the premium you pay and uses part of the investment income to fund the index-linked credits described on our page about how fixed indexed annuity crediting works. The usual rationale for a surrender charge is that the insurer plans those investments around money staying in the contract for years, and that it has up-front costs of selling and issuing the contract. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says fees and charges help cover the insurer’s costs to sell and manage the annuity and pay benefits. The surrender charge is the contract’s way of passing some of that cost to the person who leaves early. Insurers describe it this way, and the exact reasoning varies by company.
That is the explanation, and it is also the tradeoff. A surrender charge is a price you may pay for access to the money. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities, written by the state insurance regulators, says the charge is a percentage of the amount you take out and that the percentage usually goes down each year until the surrender charge period ends. The SEC’s investor bulletin on indexed annuities says surrender charges will reduce the value and the return of your investment.
Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank deposits. They are not FDIC-insured, and every guarantee in the contract depends on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. This page explains contract mechanics in general terms. It does not describe any particular product, and nothing here is a rate, a quote or a recommendation.
How long the surrender period runs and how large the charge can be
Regulators describe the range, but they do not set one number. The SEC investor bulletin says a surrender period is a set period of time that typically lasts six to ten years, or even longer, after you purchase the annuity. FINRA gives a similar window, noting that withdrawing principal usually within the first six to 10 years may result in surrender charges and may also trigger tax penalties.
Older and longer examples exist. In a 2009 rulemaking release on indexed annuities, the SEC described maximum surrender charges that could be as high as 15 to 20 percent in the early contract years, declining gradually to zero over a surrender period that, for some indexed annuities, could run beyond 15 years. That release is old, and product designs have changed since, so we cite it only to show that the range of possible terms is wide. The same release noted in a footnote that the highest charges are often associated with annuities that credit a premium bonus at the start, because the charge may serve in part to recapture the bonus.
What this means in practice:
- A shorter surrender period is not automatically better or worse. It is one feature among several, and it may be paired with different caps, participation rates or spreads.
- A premium bonus is not an addition to what you own outright. If you leave early, the insurer may take some or all of it back through the surrender charge or other contract terms.
- The length of the period, the starting percentage and the schedule shape are all in the contract. Do not rely on a general range when deciding.
Reading a surrender schedule
Most contracts show the charge as a table in the contract or in the disclosure document. The schedule below is hypothetical, for illustration only; not a current rate or a quote.
| Contract year | Hypothetical surrender charge |
|---|---|
| 1 | 9% |
| 2 | 9% |
| 3 | 8% |
| 4 | 7% |
| 5 | 6% |
| 6 | 5% |
| 7 | 4% |
| 8 | 3% |
| 9 | 2% |
| 10 | 1% |
| 11 and later | 0% |
When you read the real schedule in a contract, check these points:
- What the percentage is applied to. The NAIC guide describes the charge as a percentage of the amount you take out. Confirm whether your contract applies it to the amount withdrawn above the free amount, to the whole withdrawal, or to some other base.
- When the clock starts. A schedule may count from the contract date or from the date of each premium. If the contract accepts more than one premium, a later premium may carry its own schedule.
- What “year” means. Some schedules count contract years from the issue date, so “year 4” begins on the third anniversary.
- Whether the charge is the same for partial and full surrender.
- What happens after the last year. After the final percentage the charge drops to zero, but some features, such as an MVA or the way mid-period index credits are handled, may follow separate rules.
Ohio’s annuity disclosure rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-6-14) requires the disclosure document for the annuities it covers to describe any value reductions caused by withdrawals from or surrender of the contract. The rule does not apply to every annuity, for example some employer-plan annuities, and other states have their own rules. The disclosure document is a good place to confirm the schedule, but if it ever conflicts with the contract, ask the insurer in writing which controls.
Free withdrawals: what they are and what they are not
Many FIAs let you take a portion of the contract value each year without a surrender charge. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says most annuities with surrender charges let you take out a certain amount, usually up to 10%, each year without paying surrender charges on that amount. The SEC’s 2009 release on indexed annuities likewise noted that many indexed annuities permit purchasers to withdraw a portion of contract value each year, typically 10%, without surrender charges. The Ohio Department of Insurance’s consumer guide describes the same feature, generally available after the first year. These are general descriptions, and your contract may allow more, less or none.
Details that change what the provision is worth:
- The base. The percentage may apply to the account value at the most recent anniversary, to the current account value, or to the premium paid. These produce different dollar amounts.
- Use it or lose it versus carry-forward. In some contracts an unused allowance expires each year. In others it may accumulate. Ask which.
- First-year rules. Some contracts restrict free withdrawals in the first contract year.
- Frequency. Some contracts allow one withdrawal per year, others allow several, and some allow systematic monthly or annual withdrawals.
- Full surrender. In many contracts the free amount does not reduce the charge on a full surrender. Confirm this, because it affects how a late-in-the-period surrender is priced.
- Required minimum distributions. For an annuity held inside an IRA, many contracts let the owner take the required minimum distribution without a surrender charge even if it exceeds the usual free amount. This is contract-specific, so confirm it if the annuity will be held in a retirement account. The tax section below and our tax page explain how retirement-account rules apply.
- Rider withdrawals. If you add a lifetime income rider, ask whether withdrawals taken within the rider’s allowed amount are exempt from surrender charges, and whether the rider’s withdrawal limits and the free withdrawal limit are separate. The income riders page explains how those provisions work.
One point of vocabulary prevents a common misunderstanding. “Free” in this context means free of the insurer’s surrender charge. It does not mean free of income tax, and it does not avoid the IRS 10% additional tax if you are under age 59½ and no exception applies. See the tax section below.
A hypothetical withdrawal and surrender example
The numbers below use the hypothetical schedule above. They are for illustration only; not a current rate or a quote, and your contract may calculate each step differently.
Assume a $100,000 premium and a $118,000 account value on the third anniversary, after credits. The owner is in contract year 4, when the hypothetical charge is 7%. The free withdrawal amount is 10% of the account value at the most recent anniversary.
Partial withdrawal of $30,000
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Free withdrawal amount (10% of $118,000) | $11,800 |
| Portion of the withdrawal above the free amount ($30,000 minus $11,800) | $18,200 |
| Surrender charge (7% of $18,200) | $1,274 |
| Amount the owner receives, charge taken from the withdrawal ($30,000 minus $1,274) | $28,726 |
| Account value remaining ($118,000 minus $30,000) | $88,000 |
If the owner had withdrawn only $11,800 or less, the surrender charge in this example would have been zero.
Full surrender at different times
To compare timing, the table holds the account value at $118,000. In a real contract the value would change over time. It also assumes the charge applies to the whole amount and that no MVA applies.
| When the contract is surrendered | Hypothetical charge | Charge in dollars | Cash received |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contract year 2 | 9% | $10,620 | $107,380 |
| Contract year 4 | 7% | $8,260 | $109,740 |
| Contract year 8 | 3% | $3,540 | $114,460 |
| Contract year 11 | 0% | $0 | $118,000 |
The pattern is the point. The same contract is worth more in cash the longer it is held, even if its underlying account value does not change. Also notice that in an early year with modest credits, the cash value can be below the premium. Suppose the account value in year 2 were only $102,000. A 9% charge is $9,180, so the owner would receive $92,820, which is less than the $100,000 paid in. FINRA makes the same point, warning that after surrender charges, depending on the returns and amounts forfeited, an investor may lose some of the principal by surrendering an indexed annuity too soon.
The minimum guaranteed surrender value
FIAs sit under a state standard nonforfeiture law, based on an NAIC model, which sets a floor on what a deferred annuity must pay if it is surrendered. In the NAIC Standard Nonforfeiture Law for Individual Deferred Annuities (as amended in 2020), the minimum nonforfeiture amount is built from 87.5% of the premiums paid, accumulated at a minimum interest rate and then reduced by any prior withdrawals, a small annual contract charge, any premium tax the company paid and any loan owed to the company. The model sets the rate as the lesser of 3% a year and a formula tied to the five-year Treasury constant maturity rate less 1.25 percentage points, with a lower bound of 0.15%. The model also says no cash surrender benefit may be less than the minimum nonforfeiture amount. States adopt their own versions, so the exact percentage and rate in your contract may differ, and the contract states its own figures. The SEC’s 2009 release described the guaranteed minimum value in indexed annuities as typically a percentage of purchase payments accumulated at a specified interest rate, serving as a floor on the amount paid on withdrawal and as a death benefit.
Here is a hypothetical, simplified example that ignores withdrawals and annual charges. For illustration only; not a current rate or a quote. Suppose the floor is 87.5% of a $100,000 premium, accumulated at 1% a year. After two years that would be $87,500 multiplied by 1.01 twice, or about $89,259. After four years it would be about $91,053 ($87,500 multiplied by 1.01 four times).
What this tells you:
- The floor limits how far a surrender charge can reduce the payout when little interest has been credited. It does not promise that you will receive your premium back.
- It is a minimum, not an expected result. Typically the account value, less any surrender charge and adjustment, is higher.
- It depends on the insurer paying its obligations. Annuity guarantees depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability, and state guaranty associations provide limited protection.
What happens to index credits if you withdraw mid-period
An FIA usually credits index-linked interest at the end of a crediting period, such as one year. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says that once interest is credited for an index term, those earnings usually are locked in, but that if you take money from an indexed annuity before an index term ends, the annuity may not add all of the index-linked interest for that term. The SEC bulletin says the same, noting that if you take your money out before the end of a time period, not all of the return from that period may be applied. FINRA adds that under some contracts, amounts already credited from returns will be forfeited if withdrawals are taken.
Contracts differ, so ask the insurer which rule applies. Possibilities include:
- No index credit at all for the period in which the withdrawal occurs.
- A partial credit, calculated according to a formula in the contract.
- A credit based on index performance up to the withdrawal date, subject to the cap or participation rate.
- Forfeiture of previously credited interest in certain circumstances, which FINRA says occurs under some contracts.
A hypothetical illustration, not a current rate or a quote: assume a one-year crediting period, a 5% cap, and a $100,000 account value at the start. If the index finished the period above the cap, the credit would have been $5,000 ($100,000 multiplied by 5%). If the owner withdrew two weeks before the anniversary and the contract credits nothing for a partial period, the $5,000 would not be credited. A withdrawal timed just after an anniversary avoids this particular issue, because the credit has already been added. This is one reason the timing of a planned withdrawal can matter.
Market value adjustments
Some FIAs include a market value adjustment. Ohio’s annuity disclosure rule describes an MVA as a positive or negative adjustment that may be applied to the account value or cash value on withdrawal, surrender, annuitization or death. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says an MVA could increase or decrease an annuity’s account value, cash surrender value, or death benefit value if you withdraw money.
The direction generally follows interest rates, as the NAIC guide explains. If rates are higher than when you bought the annuity, the MVA could reduce the amount you can take. If rates are lower, the MVA could increase it. The guide adds that every MVA calculation is different. The index or rate the adjustment is based on, the formula, any limits on how large the adjustment can be, and which withdrawals it applies to are all contract terms.
The table below is hypothetical, for illustration only; not a current rate or a quote. It assumes $50,000 is withdrawn above the free amount, a hypothetical 6% surrender charge applies, and the contract applies the MVA factor to the amount withdrawn. Real contracts may apply the pieces in a different order or to different bases.
| Scenario | MVA factor | MVA in dollars | Surrender charge (6%) | Amount received |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rates higher than at purchase | minus 3% | minus $1,500 | minus $3,000 | $45,500 |
| Rates lower than at purchase | plus 2% | plus $1,000 | minus $3,000 | $48,000 |
Check: $50,000 minus $1,500 minus $3,000 is $45,500. $50,000 plus $1,000 minus $3,000 is $48,000.
Two cautions. First, an MVA that can add value can also subtract it, so it is a source of uncertainty rather than a feature that only helps. Second, many FIAs have no MVA, and some contracts apply one only to certain withdrawals or only during the surrender period. Our MYGA surrender charges and MVA page covers how MVAs work in fixed-rate contracts, where they appear more often.
Waivers: nursing home, terminal illness and death
Some contracts waive the surrender charge in defined circumstances. The NAIC guide tells buyers to look for waivers for events such as a death and for the right to take out a small amount each year. The Ohio Department of Insurance’s consumer guide describes a medical waiver, sometimes called a medical bailout, under which the charge is waived if the owner is confined to a nursing home or other long-term care facility, and may also apply with a terminal illness diagnosis. The NAIC’s long-term care shopper’s guide likewise notes that some companies will waive the charge if the withdrawal is used to pay for long-term care.
Waivers are not universal, and they are subject to conditions. Ask these questions:
- Which events qualify: nursing home confinement, home care, terminal illness, disability, unemployment?
- What documentation or waiting period is required? Some require a stay of a stated length, a physician’s certification, or that the condition began after the contract was issued.
- Does the waiver apply to the owner, the annuitant, or a spouse?
- Does the waiver cover the whole account value or only part of it?
- Is the waiver available in your state? Insurance law varies by state, and not every waiver is approved in every state.
A waiver can end the surrender charge, but it does not erase income tax on the gain or the 10% additional tax where it applies. Long-term care planning is a separate topic with its own cost and coverage questions.
Bailout provisions
The Ohio Department of Insurance’s consumer guide also describes a “bailout” provision, found in some fixed annuities, that waives the surrender charge if the declared renewal rate falls below a stated bailout rate. The guide presents it as a feature of some fixed annuities, so whether a particular FIA has one varies. If the contract has one, ask which values trigger it, how long the waiver lasts, and whether an MVA still applies. The guide notes the details depend on the contract.
Partial surrender, full surrender and annuitization
A partial withdrawal leaves the contract in force with a lower account value. The surrender charge, if any, applies to the amount above the free amount, and the lower balance means future index credits are calculated on less money. If you have an income rider, an excess withdrawal can also reduce the rider’s guaranteed values, as the income riders page explains.
A full surrender ends the contract. The NAIC guide says that if you take all of your money out of an annuity, you have surrendered it and no longer have any right to future income payments.
Annuitization, converting the contract to a stream of payments, is a separate choice. Some contracts treat annuitization after a stated number of years as exempt from surrender charges, while others apply a charge if you annuitize early. This is a contract term to confirm if lifetime income is your plan.
Taxes on early withdrawals
The surrender charge is an insurance cost. Taxes are separate and can be larger or smaller than the charge.
For a non-qualified annuity, meaning one bought with after-tax money, federal law treats partial withdrawals as coming from gain first. Section 72(e) of the Internal Revenue Code treats a withdrawal as income to the extent the contract’s cash value, determined without regard to any surrender charge, exceeds the investment in the contract. That ordering is sometimes called last-in, first-out.
A hypothetical example, using the earlier figures: the premium of $100,000 is the investment in the contract and the account value is $118,000, so the gain is $18,000. A $30,000 withdrawal would be treated first as $18,000 of ordinary income, with the remaining $12,000 treated as a return of the investment in the contract.
If the owner is younger than 59½, Section 72(q) adds a 10% additional tax on the part of the distribution included in income, unless an exception applies. IRS Publication 575 and the statute list exceptions, including distributions made after the holder’s death, because of disability, as part of a series of substantially equal periodic payments, or under an immediate annuity. On the hypothetical $18,000 of income, the additional tax would be $1,800 ($18,000 multiplied by 10%). The NAIC Buyer’s Guide describes the same age 59½ rule. How a surrender charge is treated on a return is a question for a tax professional.
Annuities offer tax deferral, not tax exemption. Our page on how fixed annuities are taxed covers deferral, 1035 exchanges and retirement-account rules in more detail. Please talk to a CPA or tax attorney about your own situation. We do not give tax or legal advice.
Death benefits and surrender charges
The NAIC guide says that if you die during the accumulation period, a deferred annuity with a basic death benefit generally pays some or all of the annuity’s value to your beneficiaries, usually the greater of the account value or the minimum guaranteed surrender value. The guide lists a death as an example of an event for which a waiver may apply, so ask whether your contract pays the death benefit without a surrender charge. The guide also warns that an MVA could affect the death benefit value, so confirm whether your contract applies one at death. The death benefits and beneficiaries page covers beneficiary choices and spousal continuation.
Exchanging one annuity for another
A 1035 exchange moves money from one annuity to another without immediate tax if the rules are followed. It can also reset the clock. FINRA notes that exchanging one contract for another may involve additional costs, including surrender charges, and usually means the clock restarts for purposes of early withdrawal penalties. The old contract may charge a surrender charge on the transfer, and the new one may start a new schedule. Many states have replacement rules based on the NAIC’s replacement model, which calls for a notice when existing coverage is involved. Ohio’s replacement rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-6-05) requires the replacing insurer to give notice of a 30-day right to return the new contract; for a market value adjusted contract, the refund is the cash surrender value plus the fees and charges deducted. The annuity buying checklist includes a replacement section.
Questions to ask before you sign
- What is the full surrender schedule by contract year, and what is the percentage applied to?
- How much can I withdraw each year without a surrender charge, and on what base is it calculated?
- Does the free amount carry forward if I do not use it?
- Does the free amount apply to a full surrender?
- What happens to the index credit if I withdraw before the end of a crediting period?
- Does the contract have an MVA? If so, what drives it, what are its limits, and when does it apply?
- Which waivers are included and available in my state, and what proof is required?
- How do rider withdrawals interact with the surrender schedule?
- What is the minimum guaranteed surrender value, and how is it calculated?
- Can I see the surrender value, after all charges and adjustments, for each of the first several years?
The costs and fees page and the risks and myths page cover how surrender terms fit with other costs and drawbacks. The complete guide to fixed indexed annuities shows how the pieces fit together. If you would like to talk through a specific contract’s schedule, our contact page shows how to reach us.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I lose money if I surrender an FIA early?
Yes. The SEC investor bulletin lists surrender charges among the ways you can lose money with an indexed annuity, and FINRA warns that an investor may lose some of the principal by surrendering too soon. The loss is most likely in early contract years when the surrender percentage is high and little interest has been credited. Index credits cannot go below zero in a typical FIA, but charges and withdrawals can still reduce what you receive.
How much can I withdraw each year without a surrender charge?
It depends on the contract. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says most annuities with surrender charges let you take out a certain amount, usually up to 10%, each year without paying surrender charges on that amount. Check how the percentage is calculated, whether it carries forward and whether it applies to full surrenders.
Does a free withdrawal avoid income tax?
No. A free withdrawal only avoids the insurer’s surrender charge. Gains withdrawn from a non-qualified annuity are generally taxed as ordinary income, and a 10% additional federal tax may apply if you are younger than 59½ and no exception applies. A tax professional can explain how this applies to you.
What happens if I need nursing home care?
Some contracts waive the surrender charge for nursing home confinement, and some also waive it for terminal illness. Conditions, waiting periods and state availability vary, and the waiver does not eliminate taxes on any gain. Ask for the waiver language before you buy.
Does an MVA always reduce my money?
No. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says an MVA could increase or decrease the amount you can take. In general, it may reduce the amount if interest rates are higher than when you bought the annuity and increase it if rates are lower, but every MVA calculation is different. Many FIAs do not have one.
Can I cancel an FIA after I buy it?
Many states give you a free look period after you receive the contract. The NAIC guide says it is usually 10 to 30 days, and that depending on the state you will get back either all of your money or your current account value. In Ohio, the Department of Insurance’s consumer guide says the free look is 30 days when you buy an annuity to replace one you already own, and Ohio’s annuity disclosure rule requires at least 15 days if the buyer’s guide and disclosure document were not provided by the time of application. Your contract should state the period prominently, and other states differ. After the period ends, the surrender schedule applies.
Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.
Ready to talk through your options?
It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.
