Last updated: November 16, 2026

Index Options in Fixed Indexed Annuities: S&P 500, Volatility-Controlled and Proprietary Indexes

Fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) can link interest to a broad market index such as the S&P 500, to a volatility-controlled version of it, to a proprietary index designed by a bank or index sponsor, or to a fixed declared rate, and many contracts offer several of these at once. The index you choose does not decide your result alone. It works together with the cap, participation rate or spread attached to it, and the track record behind an index can be much shorter than it looks.

What the Index Does, and What It Does Not Do

In a fixed indexed annuity, the index is a measuring stick, not an investment you own. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) puts it this way in its Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities: when you buy an indexed annuity, you are not investing directly in the market or the index. The insurer uses the change in the index over a set period, runs it through a formula, and credits interest. We explain that formula in detail on our page about how fixed indexed annuity crediting works.

The NAIC guide notes that some indexes measure how the overall financial markets perform, giving the S&P 500 Index and the Dow Jones Industrial Average as examples, while others measure how a specific market performs, citing the Nasdaq. It also says that some contracts offer more than one index choice, and that many let you place part of your money in a fixed interest rate account. Beyond those widely published benchmarks, some contracts offer indexes designed for use in insurance products. This page, part of our complete guide to fixed indexed annuities, walks through the main families, what to ask about each, and how to read the documents that describe them.

A reminder that applies throughout: annuities are insurance contracts, not FDIC-insured, and every guarantee depends on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. State guaranty associations provide limited protection, which we discuss on our page about annuity safety and guaranty associations.

Broad Benchmark Indexes: The S&P 500 and Its Peers

The most familiar choice is a broad stock market benchmark. Its appeal is easy to understand: the index is published daily, widely reported, and has a long history that you can look up independently of the insurer.

Price return, not total return. The SEC’s investor bulletin on indexed annuities states that gains in the index are generally computed without including dividends paid on the securities that make up the index. S&P Dow Jones Indices, which publishes the S&P 500, explains that the headline S&P 500 is a price return index that reflects changes in the market capitalization of its constituents and does not account for dividends, while a separate total return version assumes dividends are reinvested. So an FIA linked to the S&P 500 price index may credit less than a quick look at an index’s total return would suggest. This is one reason that comparing an FIA’s credits with the performance reported by an index fund can mislead if the two are measured differently.

Where the broad index sits in the contract. Broad indexes are often offered with a cap, a participation rate, or both, which limit how much of the index gain is credited. The NAIC notes that companies often use a cap rate, especially if the participation rate is 100%, though specific contracts vary. The index does not set the cap; the insurer does, and the SEC notes that contracts commonly allow the insurer to change some of these features periodically, such as the rate cap.

What to weigh. The strengths of a broad benchmark are transparency and a long, independent history. The limits are the same ones that apply to any FIA formula: the cap or participation rate limits upside, dividends are left out, and a year of strong index gains can still produce a modest credit.

Price, Total Return and Excess Return: Read the Definition

Before comparing two indexes, find out which return measure each one uses. A fact sheet or contract disclosure should say which of these applies:

Return typeWhat it generally meansWhy it matters in an FIA
Price returnChange in index level; dividends are not countedTypical for headline benchmarks such as the S&P 500
Total returnPrice change plus dividends treated as reinvestedTypically produces higher index figures, but only if the contract uses it
Other constructions, such as excess return, or indexes with a built-in deductionDepends on the index rules; ask what is subtracted or addedThe index level you see already reflects those rules before any cap, participation rate or spread applies

Index names sometimes include abbreviations or terms such as “ER,” “TCA” or “decrement.” We do not assume any of these terms means the same thing from one index to the next, and neither should you. Ask the producer or the insurer for the index’s published methodology, and look for a plain statement of what is added to or subtracted from the underlying return.

Volatility-Controlled Indexes

A volatility-controlled index, sometimes called a risk-control or “hybrid” index, starts with an underlying index and adjusts how much of the portfolio is exposed to it depending on recent market volatility. S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes a family of “Daily Risk Control” indexes, for example, that apply a volatility overlay to the S&P 500: exposure is rebalanced based on historical volatility, aiming to hold volatility near a target such as 10%. Some versions describe allocating to cash to limit volatility to the target, and one version uses an interest-accruing cash component. Each version has its own rules, and a different sponsor’s design may work differently, so read the methodology for the specific index.

In plain terms, a volatility-controlled index generally holds less of the stock index when the underlying market has been volatile and more when markets have been calm. That has two consequences worth understanding.

  • It can mute downside, and it can mute upside. In a sharp, sustained decline, less exposure means smaller index losses. Since an FIA already has a 0% floor on credits, the reduced downside is less relevant to the contract owner than it would be in a market-linked investment. In a sharp rebound, an index holding more cash may lag the underlying market, because it adjusts after volatility has already risen.
  • The cap or participation rate attached may differ. Contracts that offer volatility-controlled indexes sometimes pair them with higher cap or participation rates, or with no cap. The explanation that product materials usually offer is that a steadier index may cost the insurer less to support. Treat it as the seller’s rationale to test, not as an established fact. A higher cap on an index that rarely produces large gains does not necessarily produce a higher credit.

Here is a hypothetical comparison, for illustration only. Every number below is made up; none is a current cap, rate or index result, and none predicts how any real index will behave. Assume two strategies in the same hypothetical contract: a broad price index with a 7% cap, and a volatility-controlled index with 100% participation and a 9% cap.

Hypothetical yearBroad index changeCredit: broad index, 7% capVolatility-controlled index changeCredit: volatility-controlled, 9% cap
Strong rise+18%7.0%+9.5%9.0%
Rebound after a drop+22%7.0%+8.0%8.0%
Moderate rise+6%6.0%+3.5%3.5%
Steady, calm gain+10%7.0%+9.0%9.0%
Decline-15%0.0%-3%0.0%

In these invented years, the volatility-controlled strategy produces the higher credit in three of five, the broad index in one, and they tie at zero in a decline. Change the invented numbers and the pattern changes. The point is that a higher cap by itself tells you little; you need to know how the index it is attached to tends to behave.

Proprietary and Bank-Designed Indexes

Many FIAs also offer indexes created by a financial institution or index sponsor. These typically follow a rules-based formula: a set of assets or sub-indexes, a method for allocating among them, a volatility target, and sometimes built-in costs. Some blend stocks, bonds and other assets. Some are tied to a single sponsor’s strategy and are not available outside insurance products.

Because the rules are specific to the index, the useful questions are factual ones. Who designed and calculates it? When did it launch? What does it hold, how often does it rebalance, and what does it subtract? How has it performed since launch, as opposed to in simulations?

Track record is the central issue. An index’s fact sheet commonly shows two kinds of numbers: live results since the index launched, and back-tested results calculated afterward by applying the index rules to past data. Back-tested numbers are hypothetical by construction. The rules were chosen with knowledge of the past, and past results do not predict the future. When a performance chart shows a long line, ask which part is live and which part is simulated, and what the index’s launch date is.

The NAIC has recognized this issue in its illustration rules. Under the Annuity Disclosure Model Regulation, as adopted in states such as Arizona, if an index used to determine account value has not been in existence for at least ten calendar years, indexed returns for that index are not to be illustrated, and an allocation to that index is assumed to be zero. NAIC working group materials note that some companies interpret the rule to allow hypothetical returns when an index’s components have a longer history, and that regulators have been reviewing the issue. States adopt versions of the model at different times, so the document in front of you and your state’s rules govern. As a reader, the practical takeaway is that a newer index may appear in the contract without appearing in the illustration, and you should ask how it is being evaluated.

Other limits to understand. A rules-based index can behave differently than its description suggests in market conditions it has not been through. Complexity can also make comparisons harder: two indexes with different construction and different caps are difficult to compare fairly without scenarios.

The Fixed-Rate (Declared-Rate) Allocation

Most FIAs that offer several index strategies also offer a fixed-rate account. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide notes that many indexed annuities offer the choice to put part of your money in a fixed interest rate account with a rate that will not change for a set period. This account behaves like a conventional fixed annuity: the insurer declares a rate, and it applies for the stated period. Afterward the insurer declares a new rate.

The NAIC’s illustration rules treat this allocation as its own category. If a product lets you allocate to a declared-rate segment, the narrative must describe the options for new premiums and transfers, and how the guarantees on the declared-rate segment differ from those of the indexed segments. When you compare strategies in a contract, treat the declared rate as the one with a known rate for the period, and the indexed strategies as the ones whose credits depend on the index path and on elements the insurer may reset.

Our page on fixed indexed annuities versus MYGAs compares this idea with a product that pays a declared rate throughout.

Allocating and Reallocating Among Strategies

When a contract offers several choices, you decide how to divide your money. The NAIC illustration rules require that the allocation used in an illustration be the same across the three historical scenarios, which is a reminder that the split you choose is itself a variable. A few practical points:

  • Check when changes are allowed. Contracts commonly specify when you can move money between strategies. Many tie changes to a contract anniversary or the end of an index term, but the schedule varies, and we cannot say what a particular contract allows. Ask where this is stated.
  • Ask what happens to a partly finished term. The NAIC and the SEC both note that interest for a term may not be fully credited if you take money out before the term ends. Ask whether a transfer between strategies before the term ends is treated the same way.
  • Know what resets. If the insurer changes the cap or participation rate on a strategy, you may have the option to move to another strategy at that time. The contract should say how and when you are notified.
  • Avoid reading an allocation as a market view. Choosing an index only because of its recent performance can repeat a familiar mistake from other products, since past results do not predict future credits.

How to Read an Index Fact Sheet

A fact sheet, disclosure document or product guide for an index should let you answer these questions. If it does not, that is itself useful information.

  1. Who calculates and publishes the index, and where is the full methodology available?
  2. Which return measure is used? Price, total, excess or another construction.
  3. What is the launch date? And what is the start date of the performance history shown?
  4. Which results are live and which are back-tested? Look for labels, shading or footnotes.
  5. What does the index hold, and how does it rebalance?
  6. Is there a volatility target, and what happens to the part of the portfolio not in the underlying index?
  7. Does the index deduct anything, such as a fixed percentage, a cost assumption or a financing charge?
  8. How would the index have behaved in different environments? Look at falling, flat and rising periods, not only the headline average.
  9. Which cap, participation rate or spread applies to this index in my contract, and what is the guaranteed limit?

What Regulators Say You Should Ask

The regulators’ guidance on this is consistent. The SEC’s investor bulletin calls indexed annuities complex products, says you should understand how each feature works and what effect it may have on potential return, and says to read the contract before deciding. It also notes that an insurance company may credit you with a lower return than the actual index’s gain. The NAIC Buyer’s Guide says to review the contract and disclosure carefully, to ask the salesperson to explain anything you do not understand, and not to buy an annuity you do not understand. A 2005 notice from the NASD (now part of FINRA) on equity-indexed annuities describes them as complex and notes that many let an investor participate in only a stated percentage of an index’s increase.

On hypothetical performance specifically, the NAIC illustration rules aim to keep the presentation honest. Under the NAIC Annuity Disclosure Model Regulation (Model 245), as adopted by states that have enacted it, a fixed indexed annuity illustration must show values under three index-history scenarios: the most recent ten calendar years, and the lowest-growth and highest-growth continuous ten-year periods within the last twenty years. It must state that benefits and values are not guaranteed, that the insurer can change the assumptions, and that actual results may be higher or lower, and the elements used, such as caps and participation rates, can be no more favorable than the current ones. Illustrations are a useful way to see mechanics. They are not a forecast, and the NAIC has had these illustration requirements under review, so they may change.

Our annuity buying checklist collects the questions to ask before you sign, and the annuity glossary defines the terms used on this page. If you want to see how an index choice fits into overall costs, read our page on what fixed indexed annuities cost, for the wider set of tradeoffs, see fixed indexed annuity risks and common myths, and for questions of fit, see who might consider a fixed indexed annuity. To talk through a specific contract, contact our agency.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there one index that works for everyone?

No. A broad benchmark is simple and has a long public history, but it is usually attached to a cap or participation rate. A volatility-controlled or proprietary index may come with a higher cap or participation rate, but with a shorter live track record and a different pattern of returns. The right question is which index, with which formula, fits your time horizon and tolerance for uncertainty in the credit.

Do fixed indexed annuities include dividends from the S&P 500?

Generally not. The SEC’s investor bulletin says gains in the index are generally computed without dividends, and S&P Dow Jones Indices notes that the headline S&P 500 is a price return index. Check your contract to see which version of an index it uses.

What is a volatility-controlled index?

It is an index that adjusts its exposure to an underlying index based on recent volatility, aiming to keep volatility near a target, with the remainder typically held in cash or a cash-like component. Because it holds less of the stock index when markets are volatile, it can lag in some rebounds. Each sponsor’s version has its own rules, so read the methodology.

Are back-tested index results reliable?

They are hypothetical. Back-tested results apply an index’s rules to historical data after the fact, so they reflect choices made with knowledge of the past. Look for the index’s launch date and for live results shown separately from simulated ones, and do not treat the simulated portion as a prediction.

Can I change which index my money is linked to?

Many contracts allow it at specified times, such as an anniversary or the end of an index term, but the rules vary by contract. Ask when changes are allowed, whether the change affects interest for a term in progress, and what happens if the insurer resets the cap or participation rate on your current strategy.

Does the fixed-rate account in an indexed annuity work like a MYGA?

It is similar in that the insurer declares a rate for a set period. It differs in that the declared rate in an FIA typically applies to a portion of the contract and for a stated period, after which the insurer sets a new rate. A multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) is built around a rate guaranteed for a longer set term. Compare the specific guarantee periods in each contract.

Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.

Ready to talk through your options?

It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.