Last updated: November 16, 2026

Fixed Indexed Annuity Risks and Common Myths

A fixed indexed annuity (FIA) is not invested directly in the market, and under the typical contract the index-linked interest credited for a period cannot be less than zero. That is a real feature, but it is not the same as having no risk. The main risks are the insurer’s ability to pay, terms the insurer may change, capped upside, limited access to your money, charges, taxes and complexity. This page lists each one and then tests nine common claims against what regulators say.

What regulators say, in brief

Three public sources frame most of what follows.

The NAIC Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities, written by the association of state insurance regulators, says an indexed annuity earns interest based on changes in a market index, that when the index goes down over a period zero interest is added, and that the annuity value will not go down from the index as long as you do not withdraw the money. It also says you are not investing directly in the market or the index, and that all product guarantees depend on the insurance company’s financial strength and claims-paying ability.

The SEC’s investor bulletin on indexed annuities is blunter about risk. It calls indexed annuities complex products, says to read the contract, and states that you can lose money buying an indexed annuity. It lists the ways: withdrawals during a time period, surrender charges, the 10 percent federal tax penalty before age 59½, market index drops in indexed annuities that are securities, and insurance company risk. The SEC regulates only indexed annuities that are securities. The FIAs sold through insurance-licensed agents are generally regulated by state insurance departments, and the SEC bulletin notes that indexed annuities not regulated by the SEC include minimum guarantees that limit, and in many cases eliminate, the potential for investment losses.

FINRA’s investor education page on indexed annuities calls the products complex, says the variety of crediting methods makes comparison difficult, and notes that returns could be significantly less than the index’s positive return.

Both statements can be true at once. An FIA can have a zero floor on index credits and still involve meaningful risks. The sections below separate them.

Annuities are insurance contracts. They are not FDIC-insured, and the guarantees in them depend on the insurer’s claims-paying ability. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is educational and is not tax, legal or investment advice.

The main risks at a glance

RiskWhat it meansWhere to look
Insurer credit riskGuarantees are only as strong as the insurer’s ability to pay; guaranty association protection is limitedInsurer ratings, guaranty association rules
Changeable termsCaps, participation rates and spreads may be reset by the insurerContract’s non-guaranteed elements and minimums
Capped upsideCredited interest is usually a fraction of index movementCrediting method, cap, participation, spread
InflationCredited interest may not keep pace with rising pricesYour time horizon and other assets
LiquidityEarly or large withdrawals can trigger surrender charges and forfeited creditsSurrender schedule, free withdrawal terms
ComplexityMany moving parts make comparison hardDisclosure document, illustration, Buyer’s Guide
Rider chargesOptional benefits cost extra and reduce valueRider terms and fee basis
TaxesGains are taxed as ordinary income on withdrawal; 10% additional tax before age 59½ in many casesA tax professional
ReplacementExchanging contracts may restart surrender periodsReplacement notice, existing contract terms
Sales-practice riskA product may not match your needsSuitability review, questions below

Insurer credit risk and guaranty association limits

Every promise in an FIA is a promise from the insurance company. The NAIC guide says product guarantees depend on the insurer’s financial strength and claims-paying ability. The SEC bulletin says that all amounts payable are subject to the ability of the insurance company to pay and that, if the insurer experiences financial distress, it may not be able to fully meet its obligations.

State guaranty associations are a back-stop, with limits. NOLHGA, the national organization of the associations, says the coverage level for a fixed annuity is $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits, that the limits are set by each state’s law, and that amounts above a state’s limit may be claimed against the failed insurer’s estate. Ohio’s statute (Ohio Revised Code 3956.04) sets the limit for annuities at $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits, including net cash surrender and withdrawal values, for any one life regardless of the number of contracts, and the Ohio Department of Insurance’s consumer guide describes it as the total you could collect no matter how many annuities you bought from that company. Other states set their own limits. Confirm current figures with your own state’s association before relying on them.

Indexed annuities have a further wrinkle. NOLHGA says indexed annuities are generally covered but that most state laws carry special provisions, including excluding most index-linked interest that has not yet been credited. Ohio’s statute likewise excludes index-linked interest not credited as of the date the insurer becomes impaired or insolvent, and it excludes portions of a contract that the insurer does not guarantee. In plain terms, guaranty protection is a limited back-stop for the guaranteed portion, not a replacement for evaluating the insurer’s financial strength. Ohio law (Ohio Revised Code 3956.18) also bars using the existence of the guaranty association to sell or solicit coverage, so we present these limits as background for understanding risk, not as a reason to buy. Our page on insurer ratings and guaranty associations explains how ratings work and how to look up an insurer, and our existing article on the questions people ask about annuity risk covers the broader discussion.

Terms the insurer can change

A cap or participation rate shown at purchase may not apply for the whole contract. The SEC bulletin states that indexed annuity contracts commonly allow the insurance company to change some features periodically, such as the rate cap, and that changes can affect your return. Ohio’s annuity disclosure rule uses the term “non-guaranteed elements” for credited interest rates, benefits, values, charges and formula elements that are subject to company discretion and not guaranteed at issue. It also requires the disclosure document to explain that rates may change and are not guaranteed.

What to look for in the contract is the guaranteed minimum cap or participation rate, the lowest value the insurer has committed to, and how often the insurer may reset it. Our page on how crediting works shows what those terms do to a credit. A contract with a 0% floor and a very low guaranteed minimum cap is far less protective of upside than the first-year figure suggests.

Capped upside and opportunity cost

When an index rises sharply, a cap or participation rate limits what you are credited. FINRA notes that caps mean investors will not see returns go sky-high in big bull markets. The trade for that limit is that a down year does not reduce the credited interest below zero. Whether the trade is worthwhile depends on which index years arrive, and no one can know that in advance.

A hypothetical comparison shows both sides. It uses a made-up 6% cap on an annual point-to-point credit, a 0% floor, and the index’s price return only. It ignores dividends, fees, rider charges and taxes, and the index returns are invented. For illustration only; not a current rate or a quote.

YearScenario A index returnScenario A creditScenario B index returnScenario B credit
1+14%6%+12%6%
2minus 18%0%+10%6%
3+9%6%+9%6%
4+22%6%+15%6%
5minus 5%0%+8%6%
Ending value of $100,000$119,102$133,823
Index price return only, $100,000$118,094$166,786

In Scenario A, a volatile stretch, the capped contract with its zero floor ends slightly ahead of the index because it did not give back the losses. In Scenario B, a steady climb, the cap costs a large share of the gain. The same product produces both outcomes. Which pattern you experience is unknown, so the real question is whether a limited-upside, floored design matches what you want the money to do. Compounding check: 1.06 three times is about 1.1910, and 1.06 five times is about 1.3382.

Dividends are usually left out

Many indexes are measured on price only. The SEC bulletin states that dividends are usually excluded and that gains are generally calculated without including dividends paid on the securities in the index. Its example shows a total return reduced by the dividend portion before credit. A hypothetical version: if an index shows a 9% total return and 1.5% of it came from dividends, the contract might treat the index return as 7.5% before the cap, participation rate or spread is applied. The calculation is an index-design question that varies by contract, so ask whether the index is a price index or a total return index.

Inflation

FIAs credit interest in dollars. If credited interest is lower than inflation over a long period, the money buys less than before even though the account value did not fall. Inflation also affects guaranteed income from a rider, which may pay a level amount, so check whether the payment can adjust. This is a planning point, not a reason to avoid a product, since inflation affects most fixed-dollar assets. It is a reason to decide how much of your overall plan should be in fixed-dollar assets, and how much in assets that may have more growth potential and more volatility. A financial professional or tax adviser can help you weigh that mix.

Liquidity and surrender charges

The SEC bulletin says a surrender period typically lasts six to ten years, or even longer, and that surrender charges reduce the value and the return of your investment. FINRA adds that under some contracts, withdrawals can cause amounts already credited to be forfeited. Our surrender charges and withdrawals page covers free withdrawal provisions, market value adjustments and waivers. The main risk lesson is simple: do not put in money you may need during the surrender period, and keep an emergency reserve outside the annuity.

Complexity and comparison

The NAIC guide notes that insurers use different formulas, and that participation rates, caps and spreads all describe ways the interest added may not reflect the full change in an index. Layer on multiple strategies, annual reallocation, bonus features and riders, and two products can be very difficult to compare. The SEC’s advice is to read the contract and ask questions until you understand how each feature works and how the features interact.

Rider charges

Optional living benefit riders usually cost extra. The NAIC guide says fixed annuities, especially indexed ones, may offer a guaranteed living benefits rider, usually at an extra cost. For example, a hypothetical 1% annual rider charge on a $100,000 base would be $1,000 a year. Depending on the contract, the charge may be deducted from the account value even in a year when no interest is credited, so it can reduce the account value in a flat market. Our page on income riders explains the income base, the fee basis and withdrawal limits.

Taxes and the 10% additional tax

An annuity defers tax. It does not eliminate it. The NAIC guide says you will pay ordinary income tax on earnings when you take a withdrawal, receive an income stream, or receive each annuity payment, and that you may have to pay a 10% tax penalty if you withdraw money before age 59½. In the Internal Revenue Code, Section 72(q) imposes the 10% additional tax on the taxable part of early distributions, with exceptions such as death, disability, substantially equal periodic payments and immediate annuities. Section 72(e) generally treats withdrawals from a non-qualified contract as gain first. Our tax page explains these rules in more detail. Please consult a CPA or tax attorney about your own situation.

Replacement risk

Moving from one annuity to another can be reasonable in some circumstances, but it can be costly. FINRA warns that exchanging one contract for another may involve additional costs and fees, including surrender charges, and usually means the clock restarts for early-withdrawal purposes. The NAIC’s replacement model calls for a written notice when a purchase involves replacing existing coverage. Ohio’s replacement rule (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-6-05) requires a notice to the owner and a 30-day right to return the new contract. The notice is a prompt to stop and compare the old and new contracts in detail.

Sales-practice risk

An FIA can be well designed and still be a poor fit for a particular person. The NAIC’s annuity suitability model (Model 275) and Ohio’s version (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-6-13) have the recommending agent meet obligations of care, disclosure, conflict of interest and documentation, and require the agent to act in the consumer’s best interest. Those rules reduce the risk of a mismatch, but they do not replace your own review. Our page on who might consider a fixed indexed annuity includes questions for a recommendation.

Common myths and what is accurate

The claimWhat is accurate
“I get market returns with no downside.”You are not invested in the market. Credits come from a formula and are limited by caps, participation rates or spreads, so returns can be much lower than the index.
“I can never lose money.”Index credits cannot be negative, but charges, surrender fees, rider fees and early withdrawals can reduce what you receive.
“I get the full index return.”Usually only part is credited, and dividends are usually excluded.
“There are no fees.”A product called no fee can still reduce your return through caps, participation rates and spreads, and riders add explicit charges.
“Guaranteed income equals my account value.”Income rider guarantees are calculated from a separate figure and paid under rider terms, not cashed out as account value.
“It is FDIC-insured or government-backed.”It is neither. Guarantees depend on the insurer; guaranty associations give limited protection.
“The gains are tax-exempt.”They are tax-deferred and taxed as ordinary income when withdrawn.
“My money is locked up.”Contracts usually allow limited withdrawals each year; larger ones may carry a charge.
“Annuities are always bad, or always good.”Neither. Fit depends on purpose, time horizon, other assets and the specific contract.

Myth: “I get market returns without any downside”

The NAIC guide says plainly that you are not investing directly in the market or the index when you buy an indexed annuity. The floor protects against negative index credits for a period, but the price of that design is the cap, participation rate or spread. The tradeoff shows up in the Scenario B table above. A person who wants full market participation, and is willing to accept market declines, may be looking at a different kind of product altogether. Variable annuities and registered index-linked annuities are securities products sold under securities rules, and we mention them here only for contrast.

Myth: “I can never lose money”

The statement is accurate in one narrow sense: index credits are not negative, so the index alone does not lower the account value. The SEC lists several other ways to lose money in an indexed annuity, including withdrawals during a period, surrender charges and insurer financial distress. An early surrender after a modest credit history can return less than the premium. Rider charges can also lower the account value in a flat year. A better statement is that index credits cannot go below zero, while the total outcome depends on charges, timing and the insurer.

Myth: “Guaranteed income means I can take out my account value”

Lifetime income riders commonly calculate guaranteed income from an income base, which is a figure used for calculation and is not cash you can withdraw. The NAIC guide notes that a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit can keep paying for life even if payments reduce the annuity’s value to zero, and that if you die while receiving payments, your survivors may get some or all of the money left in your annuity. Both points matter. Guaranteed does not mean the same as accessible. See our income riders page for the mechanics.

Myth: “They are always a bad idea” and “They are always a good idea”

Both statements overreach. The sources cited on this page do not tell the public to avoid or to buy indexed annuities. They tell the public to read the contract, understand the features and ask about costs, including commissions. The SEC suggests asking how much of the money invested goes to work for you and how much goes to fees and expenses. Some people value a floor on index credits and tax deferral and accept limited liquidity and capped upside. Others will find the tradeoffs poor for their situation. The costs and fees page explains how insurers and agents are compensated.

A short checklist for weighing the risks

  1. Write down what you want this money to do and when you may need it.
  2. Confirm you have a reserve outside the annuity for emergencies and planned expenses.
  3. Read the Buyer’s Guide and the disclosure document, and ask what is guaranteed and what is not.
  4. Find the guaranteed minimum cap, participation rate or spread, not only the first-year figure.
  5. Ask how much you can withdraw without a charge, and what happens to credits if you withdraw mid-period.
  6. Look up the insurer’s financial strength ratings and your state’s guaranty association limits.
  7. Ask what any rider costs, on what base, and what voids its guarantees.
  8. Ask a tax professional how withdrawals, any exchange, and beneficiaries would be taxed.
  9. If you are replacing an annuity, compare surrender periods and costs of both contracts.
  10. Keep the signed documents and a record of what you were told.

If you would like to review a contract with us, you can reach us on our contact page. The complete guide to fixed indexed annuities shows where each of these risks fits in the overall picture.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a fixed indexed annuity lose value?

The index-linked interest credited for a period cannot be less than zero in the typical contract, so the index alone should not reduce the account value. The account value can still fall because of withdrawals, surrender charges, and rider or other charges, and the SEC says you can lose money buying an indexed annuity. Read how your contract treats each of these.

What happens to my FIA if the insurance company fails?

A state insurance regulator oversees the process, which can include rehabilitation or liquidation. State guaranty associations provide limited protection. In Ohio the limit is $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits for any one life, and other states set their own limits, with special rules for indexed annuities. Amounts above the limits, and index interest not yet credited, may not be covered. Check your state’s rules.

Do the cap and participation rate stay the same for the whole contract?

Not necessarily. The SEC bulletin notes that contracts commonly let the insurer change features such as the cap periodically. The contract should state a guaranteed minimum or maximum, and that is the figure to check.

Is an FIA the same as a variable annuity?

No. A variable annuity is a securities product whose value depends on the performance of investment subaccounts and can fall. An FIA sold as an insurance product is regulated by state insurance departments, with index credits that are floored at zero. We discuss variable annuities only for contrast and do not offer them.

Are the gains in an FIA taxed?

Yes, when withdrawn. The tax is deferred, not eliminated, and withdrawals before age 59½ may also face a 10% additional federal tax unless an exception applies. Ask a tax professional how it applies to you.

Does a 0% floor protect me from surrender charges?

No. The floor applies to the index credit, not to the fees you may pay for leaving early. A surrender charge, a market value adjustment or forfeited credits can reduce what you receive even when the index credit was zero or positive.

Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.

Ready to talk through your options?

It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.