Last updated: November 16, 2026

What Happens When a MYGA Guarantee Period Ends

When a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) reaches the end of its guarantee period, the fixed rate you were promised stops, and the contract usually gives you a limited window to choose what happens next. The common paths are to renew at whatever rate the insurer is then offering, withdraw the money, move it to another annuity through a 1035 exchange, or convert it to an income stream. What happens if you do nothing depends on the contract, and some renew automatically. The exact rules are in your contract and differ from insurer to insurer.

What actually ends, and what does not

A MYGA is a fixed deferred annuity that credits a declared interest rate for a stated number of years. Our complete guide to MYGAs covers the basics. This page is about the moment the stated number of years runs out, because a missed deadline or an unexamined default can be costly.

Three different dates can be involved, and they are not always the same:

  • The end of the guarantee period. The date the declared rate stops applying. This is the date most people mean by “maturity.”
  • The end of the surrender period. The date surrender charges stop applying. In many MYGAs the surrender period lines up with the guarantee period, but a contract can be written otherwise, and the two terms are worth checking against each other. The surrender charge and market value adjustment page explains how those schedules work.
  • The latest date income must begin. Deferred annuities generally name a date by which the contract must be annuitized, paid out, or otherwise dealt with. Where that date falls, and what the contract does when it is reached, is a contract term.

What does not end is the contract itself. The money is still inside an insurance contract, still tax-deferred if it is non-qualified money, and still subject to the terms you agreed to at purchase, including the contract’s minimum guaranteed interest rate. The NAIC’s consumer material on fixed deferred annuities describes that minimum rate as stated in the contract and unable to change while you own it, and it describes the insurer setting a new rate after each rate period that could be higher or lower than the one before. A renewal rate cannot be lower than that stated minimum.

The notice and the decision window

Insurers generally send a renewal or maturity notice ahead of the end of the guarantee period. Some contracts spell out when it must be sent, and the timing varies by insurer. We have not found a single regulatory standard that applies to every state and every contract, so the contract is what controls.

What follows the end of the guarantee period is often a short window. Some contracts use a window of about 30 days, but we could not find a common standard, and the length varies by contract. During that window, some contracts allow you to withdraw or transfer without a surrender charge. Several details are carrier-specific, and they are worth confirming in writing:

  • Does the window start on the maturity date, or can it open earlier?
  • Do you have to complete a transfer inside the window, or only start it?
  • Does the notice state the renewal rate, and is that rate locked for the whole window?
  • What address, email or portal does the insurer use for the notice? A move or an outdated mailing address is a common reason people miss notices.

The practical point is that the date matters more than most people expect. A window that closes while a transfer request is still waiting for a signature can change what happens to the contract.

How the renewal rate gets set

If you stay, the insurer applies a renewal rate for the next term. It is set by the insurer under the terms of your contract, usually based on its own investment results and business needs at that time. A few points follow from that:

  • It is not a promise made at purchase. Only the minimum guaranteed rate was promised for the life of the contract. The renewal rate is whatever is declared at renewal.
  • It can be higher or lower than your original rate. Which direction depends on the interest-rate environment and the insurer’s choices. There is no way to know in advance, and this page does not predict it.
  • It can differ from what the same insurer, or others, offer on new contracts. Insurers price new business and renewals separately, so the renewal rate and a new-contract rate may not match. That is a reason to compare, not a reason to assume either direction. The page on how MYGA rates work explains what drives these rates.
  • The renewal term may be your choice or the insurer’s. Some contracts let you select a new guarantee length, and some renew for a set length. Find out which applies to yours.

Another question worth asking is whether a new surrender period begins when the contract renews. In some contracts it may, and in others surrender charges do not apply after the first term. Because this affects your liquidity for years to come, it is worth reading the renewal provision rather than relying on memory or a sales conversation.

Your options at a glance

The table below uses non-qualified money (money that is not in an IRA or other retirement account) as its example. Qualified money has different mechanics, covered further down.

OptionWhat happensTax effect in general termsWatch for
RenewMoney stays in the same contract for a new term at the renewal rateNo tax event; deferral continuesRenewal rate vs alternatives; new surrender period
Withdraw allContract is surrendered and money paid to youGain is ordinary income; 10% additional tax on the taxable part if under age 59½Taxes in a single year; effect on income-based thresholds
Withdraw partPart is paid out; the rest renewsGain comes out first, so early withdrawals are mostly taxableRemaining balance may be below the contract’s minimum
1035 exchangeMoney moves to a new annuity contract directly between insurersNot taxed at the time of the exchange if the rules are metNew surrender period; new insurer; replacement paperwork
AnnuitizeContract is converted to an income streamEach payment is partly return of cost, partly taxableGenerally not reversible; compare with other income options

Option 1: Renewing the contract

Renewing is the path of least effort and, for some people, a reasonable one. It keeps your money in a contract you already understand, it does not trigger a tax event, and it avoids new paperwork. It also avoids a new surrender period if your contract says renewal does not restart one.

The trade is that you accept whatever rate was declared. Before renewing, compare that rate with other ways you could hold the same money, including a new MYGA, a certificate of deposit or Treasury securities. Our MYGA, CD and Treasury comparison sets out how those options differ beyond the stated rate, such as liquidity, tax treatment and who stands behind the guarantee. A rate that looks lower may still be worth keeping for reasons other than the number. A rate that looks acceptable should still be checked against the cost of the alternatives.

Option 2: Withdrawing the money

Taking the money out gives you control of it, and it also produces a tax bill if there is gain. For a non-qualified annuity, federal law taxes the earnings as ordinary income. Under Internal Revenue Code section 72(e), withdrawals before the annuity starting date come out gain first, which means the interest is generally taxed before your original premium is treated as returned. Premium you paid in is your cost basis and is not taxed again when it comes back to you.

If you are under age 59½, section 72(q) adds a 10 percent additional tax on the portion of the withdrawal that is includible in gross income. The IRS describes that additional tax as 10 percent of the taxable portion, and the statute lists exceptions, including distributions at or after age 59½, on or after death, attributable to disability, and certain substantially equal periodic payments. The additional tax applies to the taxable gain only, not to the return of basis.

Here is a labeled hypothetical, for illustration only and not a quote or current rate. Suppose a contract has a cash value of $100,000 at the end of its term, and $70,000 of that is the premium originally paid. Withdrawing all $100,000 would produce $30,000 of taxable gain. If the owner is under 59½ and no exception applies, the 10 percent additional tax would be calculated on that $30,000, or $3,000, in addition to ordinary income tax on the gain. A tax professional can work out the actual figures for any real situation.

A large withdrawal can also raise your income for the year. Reportable income affects how much of a Social Security benefit is taxed and can feed into Medicare premium surcharges. We cover the Medicare side of that in our annuities and Medicare guide. If your MYGA is large, taking it out over more than one tax year may be possible, and that is a question for a tax professional.

Option 3: Moving it with a 1035 exchange

Internal Revenue Code section 1035(a)(3) provides that no gain or loss is recognized when one annuity contract is exchanged for another annuity contract (or for a qualified long-term care insurance contract). In plain terms, you can move the contract’s value to a new annuity without paying tax at that moment, if the exchange follows the rules. Taxes on the gain are deferred rather than eliminated; they arise later when money comes out of the new contract.

The rules that matter in practice are these:

  1. Annuity for annuity. The exchange must be one of the types the statute lists. A MYGA to another MYGA, or to a fixed indexed annuity, qualifies as annuity for annuity. A MYGA to a bank account or a brokerage account does not.
  2. Same person on the new contract. Treasury Regulation 1.1035-1 limits an annuity-for-annuity exchange to cases where the same person or persons are the obligee or obligees under the new contract as under the original. In practice, the owner and annuitant on the new contract generally need to match the old one. Changing ownership during an exchange is a common way to create a taxable event by accident, so ask the receiving insurer to confirm.
  3. A direct transfer. The usual process has the new insurer request the funds from the old insurer using the new insurer’s exchange or transfer paperwork. If a check is made out to you and you deposit it, the transaction may be treated as a withdrawal rather than an exchange.
  4. Reporting. A reportable 1035 exchange is shown on Form 1099-R with code 6 in box 7a. The IRS instructions call for the total value of the contract in box 1 and zero in box 2a for the taxable amount, and total premiums in box 5. The instructions also say reporting is not required for some exchanges within the same company that meet specific conditions.
  5. Basis comes along. Your original cost basis moves into the new contract. Your tax situation is carried forward, not reset, which is why a later withdrawal is taxed on all accumulated gain, including the gain earned before the exchange.

A 1035 exchange does not remove the other tradeoffs. The new contract will have its own terms, its own surrender schedule, its own insurer, and its own financial strength to assess. The annuity tax guide describes exchanges in more detail.

Replacement paperwork

When a new annuity is purchased with money from an existing annuity, insurance regulators call that a replacement. The NAIC’s Life Insurance and Annuities Replacement Model Regulation (Model 613) provides that if an applicant reports existing coverage, the producer presents and reads a replacement notice no later than the time the application is taken, and both the applicant and the producer sign it. The notice identifies the contract being replaced by insurer, annuitant and contract number where available. Under the model, the replacing insurer must also tell any affected existing insurer about the replacement and must give you notice of a right to return the new contract within 30 days of delivery. States adopt their own versions, so details differ, but the idea is that you are shown, before you commit, that you may be giving up something in the old contract.

That is a good point to slow down. A replacement means the new contract’s free-look period (the short period after delivery to cancel, which varies by state) and surrender schedule begin anew, and some features of the old contract may not come across. In Ohio, the Department of Insurance’s consumer guide says the free-look period is 30 days when you buy an annuity to replace one you already own, and rule 3901-6-05 of the Ohio Administrative Code calls for the replacing insurer to give notice of a right to return the contract within 30 days of delivery. For a contract with a market value adjustment, the rule describes the refund as the cash surrender value plus the fees and charges deducted, rather than all premium paid. Read the free-look terms in the contract itself.

Option 4: Converting to an income stream

Annuitizing means exchanging the contract value for a stream of payments, either for life, for a set period, or for a combination. MYGAs are generally bought for the stated rate rather than for income, and annuitization terms vary by contract, so check what yours provides.

For taxes, payments under an annuity are generally split into a part that returns your cost basis and a part that is taxable. Section 72(b) of the tax code uses an exclusion ratio, the ratio of your investment in the contract to your expected return, to decide how much of each payment is excluded. The details are worked out by the insurer and the tax rules.

The main tradeoffs are loss of flexibility and the possibility that income is smaller or larger than other ways of generating it. Annuitization is often irreversible once payments start. If lifetime income is the actual goal, it is worth comparing quotes from separate income products, rather than assuming the MYGA’s annuitization option is the right fit. Our guide to MYGAs in a retirement income plan explains where a MYGA tends to fit and where it does not.

Splitting the money

Options are not all-or-nothing. A contract holder can often renew part, withdraw part and move part, subject to the contract’s rules and any minimum balance it requires. A partial 1035 exchange needs particular care. In Revenue Procedure 2011-38, the IRS provides that a direct transfer of part of an annuity’s cash value to a second annuity is treated as a 1035 exchange when no amounts are received from either contract during the 180 days after the transfer, other than amounts received as an annuity for 10 years or more or over one or more lives. Revenue Ruling 2003-76 holds that cost basis in a partial exchange is allocated according to the cash value immediately before the exchange.

A labeled hypothetical, for illustration only: a contract has a $100,000 cash value and $70,000 of basis, so $30,000 of gain. If 40 percent of the value, or $40,000, is exchanged into a new annuity, $28,000 of basis (40 percent of $70,000) goes with it, and $12,000 of gain moves into the new contract. The $60,000 that remains has $42,000 of basis and $18,000 of gain. Because of the 180-day rule, taking money out of either contract during that period could change how the exchange is treated, so planning the order of events matters. A tax professional can confirm how this would apply.

A timeline you can adapt

The dates below are planning suggestions, not legal deadlines. Your contract sets the real ones.

  1. From the first year onward. Put the end date of the guarantee period on a calendar and confirm that the insurer has your current contact details.
  2. Several months ahead. Reread the renewal and surrender provisions, find the minimum guaranteed interest rate, and note whether a new surrender period would begin on renewal.
  3. When the notice arrives. Write down the renewal rate, the window dates and the instructions for each option. If anything is unclear, ask the insurer to explain it in writing.
  4. Within the first couple of weeks of the window. Compare the renewal rate with alternatives, and, if you are considering an exchange, start the receiving insurer’s paperwork early, since processing takes time.
  5. Before the window closes. Confirm in writing what the insurer received and when. Keep copies.
  6. After the move. Check that the first statement shows the amounts and dates you expect, and that the tax reporting matches what you were told.

The auto-renewal trap

One way people end up in a result they did not choose is by missing the window. Depending on the contract, a missed window can mean the contract renews for a new term at a declared rate, or the money earns the contract’s minimum guaranteed rate, or a surrender charge could apply to a later withdrawal. The consequence depends on the wording, which is why reading it matters. There is nothing inherently wrong with a renewal. The problem is renewing by default, at a rate that was never compared to anything else.

A related point: if the new rate is lower than you expected, that does not by itself justify moving. A move can bring a new surrender period, a different insurer whose financial strength you would have to evaluate, replacement paperwork, and a different set of contract terms. The page on insurer ratings and state guaranty associations covers how to look at the insurer on the other side of a transfer, including the limited protection state guaranty associations provide. Annuities are insurance contracts, they are not FDIC-insured, and their guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the insurer.

Qualified money works a little differently

When a MYGA is held inside an IRA or other retirement account, the tax mechanics change. A 1035 exchange is not the usual route; instead, qualified money is typically moved by a direct transfer between custodians (a trustee-to-trustee transfer) or by rollover rules, depending on the account. The IRS Form 1099-R instructions say that a transfer between trustees or issuers that involves no payment to the participant is generally not reported, with certain listed exceptions. Required minimum distributions also apply to qualified contracts, with the starting age set by federal law and depending on the year you were born. If you hold a MYGA in an IRA, ask both the insurer and the custodian how the contract’s value is counted for required distributions as the term ends. Whether you ought to move or renew should not be driven by tax mechanics alone, and a tax professional can help you sort it out.

Questions to ask at purchase, before the term ends

You can shape the end-of-term experience by asking about it when you buy. Useful questions include:

  • How and when will the insurer notify me before the guarantee period ends, and what happens if the notice is lost?
  • How long is the window after the end date, and can I withdraw or transfer during it without surrender charges?
  • What is the contract’s minimum guaranteed interest rate, and how is the renewal rate determined?
  • Does a new surrender period begin if the contract renews?
  • Can I choose a new guarantee length, or does the contract renew for a set length?
  • What does the contract do if I take no action?
  • Is annuitization available, and on what terms?
  • Does the insurer accept 1035 exchange requests in the window, and does the transfer need to be completed or only started before the window ends?

Our annuity buying checklist puts these questions in a longer list that covers the purchase itself. If a conversation about an annuity you hold or are considering would help, you are welcome to contact us.

Frequently Asked Questions

What if I miss the renewal window?

It depends on the contract. Some contracts renew automatically for a new term at the declared renewal rate, some credit the minimum guaranteed rate, and some apply surrender charges to later withdrawals. Contact the insurer as soon as you notice, ask what options remain, and get the answer in writing. A missed window does not necessarily mean a bad outcome, but it can limit your choices.

Is the renewal rate usually lower than a new MYGA rate?

Not necessarily, and we do not predict rates. Insurers set renewal rates and new-contract rates separately, so they can differ in either direction. The only way to know is to compare the renewal offer with what is available elsewhere at the time, along with each contract’s surrender terms and each insurer’s financial strength.

Do I owe tax when my MYGA term ends?

Not simply because the term ends. For non-qualified money, tax on the gain generally arises when money is withdrawn, surrendered or paid out as income, not when the guarantee period ends. A properly handled 1035 exchange is not taxed at the time of the exchange. A tax professional can look at your specific facts.

Can I do a 1035 exchange for only part of the contract?

Often yes, if the contract and the receiving insurer allow it. The IRS has issued guidance on partial exchanges, including a 180-day rule under Revenue Procedure 2011-38, so taking withdrawals from either contract soon afterward can affect the result. Confirm the details with the insurers and a tax professional before you start.

Does a 1035 exchange restart the surrender period?

The new contract has its own surrender schedule, which generally starts from the new contract’s issue date. Contracts differ, so ask the receiving insurer whether any time already served on the old contract counts toward the new one. Compare the new schedule against your liquidity needs before you move.

Should I renew, withdraw or exchange?

That depends on your goals, the renewal rate, the new contract’s terms, your tax situation and how much liquidity you need. This page explains the mechanics so you can ask better questions, and we do not recommend any one path. The page on who might consider a MYGA covers the planning questions that apply on the way in and at renewal.

Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.

Ready to talk through your options?

It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.