Last updated: November 16, 2026

Fixed Indexed Annuity vs. MYGA: How to Choose

A fixed indexed annuity (FIA) and a multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA) are both deferred fixed annuities issued by an insurance company, and the main difference is how the growth is decided. A MYGA credits a fixed rate that is stated in the contract for a set number of years, so the value at the end of the term can be calculated when you buy, assuming no withdrawals and subject to the insurer’s ability to pay. An FIA credits interest linked to an index, within limits the insurer sets, so the result depends on how the index behaves and on terms the insurer may reset.

Neither one is the answer in the abstract. The question that tends to separate them is whether you would rather know the number now or accept a range of outcomes in exchange for the possibility of more, plus the option of an income rider. This page lays the two contracts next to each other, works through a hypothetical five-year illustration, and ends with a set of questions you can use to think it through. For the full treatment of each product, see our guides to fixed indexed annuities and multi-year guaranteed annuities, or start with the annuities overview.

What an FIA and a MYGA have in common

Before the differences, it helps to see how much the two products share, because a lot of the confusion comes from treating them as opposites. According to the NAIC Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities, most deferred annuities are alike in several ways, and both of these fit that description.

  • Both are contracts with an insurance company. Neither is a bank deposit, and neither is FDIC-insured. What the contract promises depends on the insurer’s ability to pay claims. The SEC’s investor bulletin on indexed annuities says plainly that all amounts payable are subject to the ability of the insurance company to pay. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails, and our page on insurer ratings and guaranty associations explains how that works.
  • Both have an accumulation period and, later, a payout period. Money goes in, interest is credited, and at some point you can take withdrawals, annuitize, or surrender the contract.
  • Both usually carry surrender charges. The NAIC guide says a charge generally applies if you take money out too early, that the percentage usually declines each year until the surrender period ends, and that many contracts allow a limited amount (it says usually up to 10%) to be withdrawn each year without the charge.
  • Both defer income tax on interest. The earnings are not taxed until they come out. The NAIC guide is careful to add that this is deferral, not exemption. Our page on how fixed annuities are taxed covers the rules, including the additional 10% federal tax that can apply to the taxable part of withdrawals before age 59½.
  • Both have a basic death benefit. The NAIC guide says it is usually the greater of the account value or the minimum guaranteed surrender value.
  • Both are sold by licensed insurance professionals, and in many states both come with a free look period after you receive the contract (the NAIC guide says usually 10 to 30 days, depending on the state).

Fixed indexed annuity vs. MYGA at a glance

The table below summarizes the differences. Details and cautions follow in the sections after it. Every contract has its own terms, so treat this as a map and not as a description of any particular product.

FeatureFixed indexed annuity (FIA)MYGA
How interest is determinedCredited at the end of each index term based on index changes, after a cap, participation rate, or spread is appliedA fixed rate stated in the contract for the guarantee period
Can the credit vary year to year?Yes. It can be zero in a down period and is limited in an up periodNo, during the guarantee period the rate is the rate
Floor on index-linked creditsZero in the contracts the NAIC guide describes: a down index does not reduce the value by itselfNot applicable; the fixed rate is the credit
Can the insurer change the formula?Often yes: the SEC bulletin says contracts commonly allow the insurer to change some features periodically, such as the rate cap; the NAIC guide says some companies guarantee a minimum or maximum for themNot during the guarantee period; a new rate is set at the end of it, subject to the contract’s guaranteed minimum rate
Lifetime income optionMany FIAs offer an optional rider (for example, a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit), usually for an extra charge, and annuitizationUsually annuitization if the contract allows it; riders of that kind are less typical
Surrender chargesCommon, schedule varies by contractCommon, schedule varies by contract
Market value adjustment (MVA)Some contractsSome contracts
ComplexityHigher: index, crediting method, limits, ridersLower: a rate, a term, a surrender schedule
Tax treatmentSame deferral rules as other non-qualified or qualified annuitiesSame
Main trade-offPossible upside above a fixed rate, with limits and variable outcomesKnown result, with no index-linked upside

How growth is determined

The MYGA: a declared rate for a stated period.

In a MYGA, the insurer states a rate and promises it for the guarantee period in the contract. The NAIC guide notes that fixed deferred annuities in general have a guaranteed minimum interest rate that is stated in the contract and cannot change while you own it, and that the company sets rates above that minimum. In an ordinary fixed annuity the rate is fixed only for a period, often a year, after which the insurer declares a new one that could be higher or lower. A MYGA lengthens that period to several years. Because the rate is set when the contract is issued, you can calculate the value at the end of the term, assuming no withdrawals. Our guide on how MYGA rates work covers what drives the rate and how to read an offer.

The FIA: index-linked interest, filtered through limits.

An FIA credits interest based on the change in an index, such as the S&P 500, measured over an index term. The NAIC guide explains that you are not investing directly in the market or the index. The insurer applies a formula, and that formula often means the interest added reflects only part of the index change. The common tools are:

  • A participation rate, which determines how much of the index’s increase is used in the calculation. The SEC bulletin gives an example: a 75% participation rate with a 10% index return yields 7.5%.
  • A cap rate, the typical maximum credit for the term. In the SEC’s example, a 7% cap with a 12% index gain yields 7%.
  • A spread (also called a margin or asset fee), a percentage subtracted from the index gain. A 3% spread on a 9% gain yields 6%.

The SEC bulletin also says that index gains are generally computed without counting dividends paid by the stocks in the index, and that if you take money out before the end of a time period, not all of the return for that period may be applied. The NAIC guide adds that once interest is credited for a term, it is usually locked in, and later index declines do not reduce it. Our guide to how FIA crediting works goes through the crediting methods in detail.

A point that matters for comparison: according to the SEC bulletin, indexed annuity contracts commonly allow the insurer to change some features periodically, such as the rate cap, and the changes can affect your return. The NAIC guide says some companies guarantee that a cap or participation rate will never be lower (or higher) than a set minimum (or maximum). Where the contract states such a limit, that limit, not the first-year level, is what the contract commits the insurer to. This is a reason to read the contract’s guaranteed terms and not only the current ones.

A hypothetical five-year illustration

The numbers below are made up for illustration only. They are not current rates, caps or a quote, and they do not predict how any index will behave. They exist to show the shape of the difference.

Assume a single $100,000 purchase payment, no withdrawals for five years, and these invented terms:

  • MYGA: a 4.00% fixed annual rate for five years, compounding annually.
  • FIA: an annual point-to-point crediting method with a 6% cap and a 0% floor, and the same cap in every year. The index changes are invented price-return changes (dividends not counted).

The MYGA value after five years is $100,000 x 1.04^5, which is about $121,665 in every scenario. The FIA result depends on the path:

ScenarioInvented annual index changes, years 1 to 5Credits after 6% cap and 0% floorFIA value after year 5MYGA value after year 5
A: steady strong gains+15%, +12%, +9%, +18%, +11%6%, 6%, 6%, 6%, 6%about $133,823about $121,665
B: mixed+12%, -8%, +3%, +20%, -2%6%, 0%, 3%, 6%, 0%about $115,731about $121,665
C: weak-10%, +2%, -5%, +1%, 0%0%, 2%, 0%, 1%, 0%about $103,020about $121,665

The arithmetic: in scenario A, 1.06^5 = 1.33823, so $100,000 becomes about $133,823. In scenario B, 1.06 x 1.00 x 1.03 x 1.06 x 1.00 = 1.15731, so about $115,731. In scenario C, 1.00 x 1.02 x 1.00 x 1.01 x 1.00 = 1.0302, so $103,020.

What the table shows, and what it leaves out:

  • The FIA had no loss from the index in any scenario, because of the 0% floor. In scenario C it also credited very little.
  • To match the MYGA over five years, the FIA’s credits in this example would need to average about 4.00% a year, compounded. Scenario B, with two flat years, falls short.
  • The illustration ignores several things that matter in real contracts: rider charges, premium bonuses and their conditions, surrender charges if money is withdrawn, the chance that a cap is lowered after the first year, taxes, and the fact that actual indexes rarely behave like invented ones.
  • A bad outcome for one product is not a rule about the product. In a different invented scenario, with different terms, the order could reverse. The useful takeaway is that the MYGA result is knowable at purchase and the FIA result is not.

Floors and guarantees: what “guaranteed” covers

Both products rest on the same kind of promise: the insurer’s contractual obligations, backed by its own claims-paying ability. Within that, the guarantees differ in shape.

In a MYGA, the guarantee is the rate for the term and a minimum value at the end of it. In an FIA, the guarantee that a down index will not reduce credited interest below zero applies to the index-linked credit. The NAIC guide states that when the index declines over the period, zero interest is added, and the annuity value will not go down as long as you do not withdraw the money. The contract also has a minimum guaranteed value, which state nonforfeiture laws based on the NAIC model generally require. In the NAIC’s model law (Model 805), the minimum nonforfeiture amount is built from a percentage of premiums accumulated at a stated minimum interest rate, and states adopt the model individually, so the exact formula in your contract is the one to read. That minimum is not the same as the account value.

Two cautions apply to both products. First, the SEC bulletin says surrender charges reduce the value and the return of your investment, and FINRA says an investor may lose some of the principal by surrendering an indexed annuity too soon, so even a contract with a minimum value can take years to recover your premium if you leave early. Second, fees can reduce value: the NAIC guide says fees and charges reduce an annuity’s value. So “the index cannot reduce my value” and “I cannot lose money in the contract” are different statements. Our page on FIA risks and common myths addresses the second one.

The SEC bulletin also notes that some indexed annuities, particularly those that are securities, specify that you may lose money if the index goes down. Those are not the contracts we are describing here, and the 0% floor is a feature to confirm in the contract and disclosure, not to assume.

Income options: riders vs. a fixed term

If your goal includes income you cannot outlive, the two products differ most here.

Many FIAs offer a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit rider, usually for an extra cost. The NAIC guide says that such a rider can guarantee payments you cannot outlive (a promise that, like the rest of the contract, depends on the insurer’s financial strength and claims-paying ability), that the money still in the annuity continues to earn interest while you take payments, and that if the payments reduce the account value to zero, they continue for life. In most riders the income figures are calculated from a separate income base, which is a formula number and not cash you can withdraw; the contract defines it. We explain the mechanics in our guide to FIA income riders.

A MYGA is typically a growth-to-a-date contract. At the end of the guarantee period you decide what to do with the value: renew, take the money, move it through a 1035 exchange, or, if the contract allows, convert it to payments. The NAIC guide describes annuitization as choosing to receive guaranteed fixed payments for life or a set period, with the caveat that after payments begin you cannot take other money out of the annuity and usually cannot change the amount. Both product types may allow annuitization if the contract offers it, but a rider-based income stream is a feature more typical of FIAs.

If you want income to start right away or within a year, a different contract may fit, which we cover below under immediate annuities.

Surrender terms, liquidity and market value adjustments

On liquidity the two products look similar on paper and can behave differently in practice.

  • Surrender schedules. Both typically have a schedule of declining charges. The length varies by contract. In a MYGA, the surrender period may or may not match the guarantee period, so confirm both in the contract. In an FIA, the surrender period is a separate term, and the index term may differ from it.
  • Withdrawals without a charge. The NAIC guide says most annuities with surrender charges allow a certain amount, usually up to 10%, to be withdrawn each year without paying the charge on that amount. Check how the contract defines it.
  • Interest forfeited mid-term. The NAIC guide notes that if you take money from an indexed annuity before an index term ends, the annuity may not add all of the index-linked interest for that term. The SEC bulletin says the same of insurers that may not credit interest for a period if the contract is not held to the end of it. In many MYGAs the fixed rate is credited over time, so partial-period issues may be less pronounced, but confirm how your contract treats a mid-period withdrawal.
  • Market value adjustments. The NAIC guide explains that an MVA can increase or decrease account value, cash surrender value, or death benefit value on a withdrawal. In general, if interest rates are lower at withdrawal than when you bought the contract, the MVA could increase the amount you can take, and if rates are higher, it could reduce it. Every MVA calculation is different. Both product types may include one. Details are on our pages about FIA surrender charges and withdrawals and MYGA surrender charges and MVAs.

Costs and complexity

A MYGA has few moving parts: a rate, a term, a surrender schedule, and possibly an MVA. An FIA adds an index choice, a crediting method, one or more limits, and often a rider. That extra complexity is not automatically a drawback, but it does mean more terms to read, and more ways for two products that look alike to behave differently.

On cost, the NAIC guide says fees and charges help cover the insurer’s costs to sell and manage the annuity and pay benefits, that most annuities have some, and that the types and amounts differ among annuities. Riders are usually added at an extra cost. Reading the fee section of the contract and disclosure is the way to compare two specific products. The NAIC guide also says insurers usually pay the salesperson after the sale, that the payment does not reduce the amount you pay into the annuity, and that you can ask the salesperson how they earn money from the sale. We would encourage anyone to ask that question of any agent on any product. It is a reasonable thing to ask, and the answer should be given plainly.

A premium bonus is a feature that changes the comparison. The NAIC guide says bonuses are usually a percentage added to the annuity, that you may not be able to withdraw all or some of the bonus for a set period, and that you could lose the bonus by taking money out within a set time. A bonus is therefore one input among several and not a reason to choose a product on its own. Our page on what FIAs cost goes through this in more depth.

Taxes and death benefits

The federal tax rules for the interest are the same for both products. Interest grows tax-deferred, withdrawals from a non-qualified contract are generally treated as taxable gain first, and the additional 10% tax can apply to the taxable portion of withdrawals before age 59½ unless an exception applies. The 1035 exchange rules also apply to both: section 1035 of the Internal Revenue Code allows an annuity contract to be exchanged for another annuity contract without recognizing gain at the time of the exchange, and Rev. Proc. 2011-38 sets the conditions for partial exchanges. Because a MYGA’s term ends on a known date, many people encounter a 1035 exchange at the end of that term, which we cover in our guide on what happens when a MYGA guarantee period ends.

For death benefits, the NAIC guide says the basic benefit is usually the greater of the account value or the minimum guaranteed surrender value, and that if you die after beginning income payments, survivors may receive nothing unless the contract guarantees a minimum payout or you chose a payout option that continues after death. Survivors typically owe income taxes on any death benefit they receive. This applies to both product types. A tax professional or attorney can tell you how it applies to your own situation, and we do not provide tax or legal advice.

A question flow for deciding

The questions below are not a formula. They are a way to see which product is a candidate and which questions to ask next. Your answers do not decide anything for you.

  1. When might you need this money? If part of it could be needed before the surrender period ends, the amount, the free withdrawal provision, and any MVA matter more than the rate or the cap. If none of it will be needed for the full term, surrender terms matter less.
  2. How would you feel about a year with little or no credited interest? An FIA can credit zero in a down year. If that outcome would be hard to accept, a fixed rate may be more comfortable. If you can accept it for a chance at more, an FIA may be worth a closer look.
  3. Do you want a number to plan around? If you need a known value on a known date, a MYGA’s stated rate allows that, assuming the contract is held to the end of its term.
  4. Do you want lifetime income from this contract? If so, an FIA with an income rider, or a different income contract altogether, deserves attention. If the goal is growth to a date, a MYGA often answers it without a rider.
  5. How comfortable are you with terms that can be changed? FIA caps, participation rates and spreads can be changed by the insurer periodically, subject to the contract. The renewal and minimum terms in the contract are the ones to read.
  6. How much time will you spend reading and monitoring? An FIA calls for tracking an index choice and anniversary-date terms. A MYGA calls for noting the end-of-term date.
  7. Is the money qualified or non-qualified? Both products can be held in retirement accounts or with after-tax money. If it is an IRA, remember that the NAIC guide notes you can fund an IRA other ways and get the same tax advantages, and it lists “what features and benefits in the annuity, other than tax deferral” among the questions to ask, so an annuity in an IRA is worth judging on its other features.
  8. Does this fit with your other assets? How much of your total savings is going into one contract, one insurer, and one surrender schedule?

Answers to these questions are the starting point for a conversation, not an end to it. If you would like to talk it through, we can walk through them with you.

Why some people hold both

Using both is not a hedge in the investment sense, but it can reflect two different jobs. A MYGA may serve a defined purpose with a defined date, such as money that is intended to be there when a particular need arrives. An FIA may serve a longer-horizon purpose, where the owner is willing to accept variable credits and possibly wants a lifetime income rider. Each contract has its own surrender schedule, and the combined arrangement should still leave enough accessible money outside both for emergencies and near-term needs. Spreading among more than one insurer is also something people consider, because guaranty association protection is limited per person and per insurer. See our page on insurer ratings and guaranty associations for how those limits work.

How these compare with immediate annuities, variable annuities and RILAs

The word annuity covers more than FIAs and MYGAs. Here is how the others differ, for contrast only. We are describing them so you can tell them apart, not recommending any of them.

  • Immediate annuities. The NAIC guide says some annuities begin paying income soon after purchase. For federal tax purposes, section 72(u)(4) of the Internal Revenue Code describes an immediate annuity as one bought with a single premium, with an annuity starting date no more than one year after purchase, and with substantially equal periodic payments at least annually. The trade-off is that the money is converted to an income stream, rather than remaining a balance you can withdraw from.
  • Variable annuities. According to the NAIC guide, variable annuities earn returns based on the performance of investment portfolios called subaccounts that you choose, the return is not guaranteed, and you could lose money. They are sold with a prospectus, and the person selling one must also be registered with FINRA as a representative of a broker-dealer. They are securities products.
  • Registered index-linked annuities (RILAs). These are also securities. FINRA explains that they use a buffer or floor that limits both risk and reward, and that losses beyond a buffer fall on the owner. The SEC’s investor testing report gives an example: with a 20% buffer and a 25% index decline, the loss would be 5%. FINRA notes that RILAs lack the guaranteed minimum interest rate found in indexed annuities that are not securities, and the owner can lose money.

An FIA is a fixed annuity and a MYGA is a fixed annuity. Neither credits index losses to the contract value in the way a variable annuity or RILA can. They are not interchangeable with those products, and the regulation and the professionals who sell them are different.

Who each may fit, and who it may not

These are hypothetical profiles, not real clients, and not recommendations.

  • A person with a fixed date in mind may find a MYGA fits, for example someone who knows a sum will be needed in a certain number of years and wants to see the value at that date in the contract. A MYGA may not fit someone who wants a chance at above-fixed growth.
  • A person comfortable with variable credits and interested in a lifetime income rider may want to study an FIA. An FIA may not fit someone who needs to know the exact value in advance or who is likely to need most of the money within the surrender period.
  • A person who wants simplicity may lean toward a MYGA. A person who is willing to read more terms may find an FIA suitable.
  • A person who may need the money soon may find that neither fits, or that a smaller amount in either, with the rest in more accessible places, makes more sense.

Whatever the profile, the NAIC guide says a salesperson who suggests an annuity needs complete information about your life and financial situation, and that you should expect questions about your age, assets, debts, income, tax status, how you plan to pay for the annuity, risk tolerance, objectives, family circumstances, and how you plan to use the annuity. Our pages on who might consider an FIA and who might consider a MYGA go through that suitability framework in more detail.

Before you decide

Read the NAIC Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities, ask for the contract and disclosure documents, and ask what is guaranteed and what is not. Our annuity buying checklist turns those steps into a list of questions you can bring to any meeting. Our reading of these documents is no substitute for yours. If you would like to talk through a specific situation, you can contact us.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a fixed indexed annuity riskier than a MYGA?

They carry different kinds of uncertainty. A MYGA’s rate is known at purchase, so the uncertainty is mostly about the insurer’s ability to pay and about what you give up if you need the money early. An FIA adds uncertainty about how much interest will be credited and about whether the insurer will change caps or participation rates over time. Both are subject to the insurer’s claims-paying ability and to surrender charges. Neither is FDIC-insured.

Can an FIA lose money?

In the contracts the NAIC guide describes, a decline in the index does not reduce the account value by itself, because zero interest is added in a down period. But you can still receive less than you put in if you surrender during the surrender period, and fees such as rider charges can reduce the value. The SEC’s bulletin also notes that some indexed annuities, particularly those that are securities, can lose money when the index falls, so confirm the floor in the contract.

Which one earns more?

There is no general answer, and we do not promise returns for either product. A MYGA’s return is stated in the contract. An FIA’s return depends on the index, the crediting method, and limits that can change. The five-year illustration above uses invented numbers to show that the comparison can go either way depending on the path of the index.

Can I hold a MYGA and an FIA at the same time?

Yes, there is no rule against owning both, and some people do for different purposes. The points to weigh are the combined surrender schedules, how much of your savings is tied up, whether you are relying on one insurer, and whether you still have enough accessible money for emergencies.

How is the interest taxed in each?

The federal rules are the same for both. The interest is tax-deferred until it is withdrawn or paid out, and for a non-qualified contract the taxable gain generally comes out first. A 10% additional federal tax can apply to the taxable part of withdrawals before age 59½, subject to exceptions. See our annuity taxes page, and ask a tax professional about your situation.

Do these annuities affect Medicare?

Buying one does not change Medicare eligibility. Taxable annuity income and gains can raise your adjusted gross income in the year they are reported, and income-related Medicare premiums are generally based on your tax return from two years earlier. We cover the connection on our IRMAA explainer and on our annuities and Medicare page.

Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.

Ready to talk through your options?

It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.