Buying an annuity does not change whether you can enroll in Medicare or which plans you can choose. What it can change is your reported income: the taxable part of annuity withdrawals and payments flows into the income figure Social Security uses to set income-related surcharges on Part B and Part D premiums, generally two years later. Annuity ownership can also matter for programs that test income and assets, including Medicare Savings Programs, Extra Help and Medicaid long-term care. This page explains those links at a high level; it is not tax, legal or Medicaid planning advice, and we are an independent agency, not affiliated with Medicare, Social Security or any government agency.
Owning an annuity does not change Medicare eligibility or plan options
Original Medicare eligibility turns on factors such as age, disability or kidney disease status, residency or citizenship, and work history for Part A without a monthly premium. Those are the criteria CMS and Social Security publish. Buying a fixed indexed or multi-year guaranteed annuity is not among them, and it does not change when you can enroll or which Part D, Medicare Advantage or Medigap plans are available where you live.
Where income enters is the premium side. Part B and Part D premiums can carry an income-related add-on, called the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount or IRMAA. For reference, the standard Part B premium is currently $202.90 per month and the Part B deductible is currently $283; an IRMAA add-on is an extra amount added to the premium. Plan premiums for Medicare Advantage, Part D and Medigap are set by the plans, and owning an annuity is not a Medicare eligibility factor. For a plain-English view of the whole cost picture, see our guide to how much Medicare costs.
So the useful question is not whether an annuity affects Medicare. It is how the income an annuity produces, and when it produces it, shows up on your tax return.
How IRMAA is set: income, filing status and a two-year lookback
Medicare describes IRMAA as an extra amount added to your monthly premium when your modified adjusted gross income, as reported on your IRS tax return from two years ago, is above a certain amount. Social Security’s operating manual (POMS) adds the details that matter for planning:
- The income measure is MAGI. For IRMAA, modified adjusted gross income is your adjusted gross income (AGI) from your Form 1040 plus your tax-exempt interest. The manual defines it as exactly those two pieces.
- The tax year is usually two years back. Social Security uses the most recent tax information the IRS can provide, which is generally from two years before the premium year, but never more than three years before. The manual’s own example is that premiums for 2026 are generally based on 2024 tax returns.
- Both Part B and Part D can carry an add-on. IRMAA applies to the Part B premium and to the Part D drug premium, including Part D coverage inside a Medicare Advantage plan or provided through an employer, according to Medicare’s fact sheet on how income affects drug coverage premiums.
- Filing status matters. The income levels differ for individual returns, joint returns and married-filing-separately returns, so the same dollar amount can land in different places for different households.
- The add-on is set by income bands. Social Security sorts income into levels, so a small difference in income near the edge of a band can change the amount for that year.
- The amounts change. The income levels and dollar add-ons are updated for each year, so we do not print them here. Medicare.gov and Social Security publish the current table, and our page on IRMAA explains how to read it. This page is part of our annuity education guide.
If you are subject to a Part D add-on, Medicare’s fact sheet says Social Security sends a letter, the extra amount is generally deducted from your Social Security, Railroad Retirement or Office of Personnel Management benefit, and, if you receive a bill instead, you pay Medicare rather than your drug plan. It also says you must pay both the extra amount and your plan premium to keep your Part D coverage.
What counts toward MAGI, and where annuity money fits
The point to keep in view is that IRMAA reads your return, not your contract. A deferred annuity grows on a tax-deferred basis, which the NAIC Buyer’s Guide describes as not paying income tax on earnings until you take them out, and it adds that deferral is not the same as having no tax. Deferral is why many people ask about annuities and IRMAA together: growth that has not yet been distributed is not generally part of the AGI on your return.
That is a timing effect, not an exemption. When money comes out, the taxable portion is ordinary income, and ordinary income that lands in a given tax year is part of the AGI that Social Security reads two years later. Tax-exempt interest from other sources is added back in MAGI, so owning municipal bonds, for example, does not keep that interest out of the IRMAA calculation.
Which annuity events create reportable income
The table summarizes the general rules for common situations. It is a simplified overview, and individual contracts and tax situations vary.
| Annuity event | General income-tax treatment | How it can reach MAGI |
|---|---|---|
| Interest or index credits accumulating inside a deferred annuity | Tax-deferred; not taxed until withdrawn or received, per the NAIC Buyer’s Guide | Generally does not appear on your return while it stays in the contract |
| Partial withdrawal from a non-qualified annuity before payments start | IRS Publication 575: the amount withdrawn is allocated first to earnings (taxable) and then to your cost (not taxable), for contracts issued after August 13, 1982 | The taxable earnings portion adds to AGI |
| Full surrender of a non-qualified annuity | Taxable to the extent it exceeds your unrecovered cost | The gain adds to AGI in that tax year |
| Regular annuity payments (annuitization) | A part of each payment may be excluded as recovery of your cost; the rest is taxable | The taxable part of each payment adds to AGI each year |
| Withdrawals from an annuity held inside an IRA or other qualified plan | The NAIC guide notes that you pay ordinary income tax on all of the money received, not just the earnings | Generally the full distribution, apart from any after-tax basis, adds to AGI |
| Exchange of one annuity for another under IRC section 1035 | No gain or loss is recognized on the exchange of an annuity contract for another annuity contract | A properly structured exchange is not a taxable event, though the paperwork is reported |
| Death benefit paid to a beneficiary | The NAIC guide says survivors typically owe income tax on the death benefit | It affects the beneficiary’s return, not the owner’s |
| Funding the purchase with outside money | Depends on where the money comes from | Selling an appreciated investment or taking a taxable IRA withdrawal to fund a purchase can create income in that year |
Two practical notes. First, the earnings-first ordering means that when you take part of a non-qualified annuity before payments begin, the first dollars out are the taxable ones; deferral does not stretch to the first withdrawal. Second, insurers generally report distributions on Form 1099-R, and it is the taxable amount on your return, not the gross amount on the form, that matters for AGI. Our page on how fixed annuities are taxed covers the rules in more depth, including penalties for withdrawals before age 59½.
A hypothetical: three ways to handle the same $20,000 gain
The following example uses made-up numbers for illustration only. It is not a current rate, a quote or a prediction, and it ignores surrender charges, state tax, the 10 percent additional tax that can apply before age 59½, the effect on how much Social Security is taxable and any other tax effects.
Suppose a retiree has $60,000 of other AGI each year (pension, IRA withdrawals and the taxable part of Social Security), $2,000 of tax-exempt interest, and a non-qualified annuity with a $20,000 gain. Because earnings come out first, the first $20,000 withdrawn would be the gain.
| Approach | Annuity income in tax year 1 | Annuity income in tax year 2 | MAGI in year 1 | MAGI in year 2 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Surrender the contract in year 1 | $20,000 | $0 | $82,000 | $62,000 |
| B. Withdraw $10,000 of gain in each of two years | $10,000 | $10,000 | $72,000 | $72,000 |
| C. Exchange into another annuity under section 1035 | $0 | $0 | $62,000 | $62,000 |
The arithmetic: in approach A, $60,000 + $20,000 + $2,000 = $82,000. In B, $60,000 + $10,000 + $2,000 = $72,000 in each year. In C, $60,000 + $2,000 = $62,000.
What the table does and does not show: the dollar amounts of MAGI differ, and Social Security reads the year-1 and year-2 figures about two years later. Whether any of these figures crosses into a higher IRMAA band depends on the published bands for that premium year and on filing status, which we are deliberately not hard-coding. Approach C defers the gain rather than eliminating it, and it may bring a new surrender period or a different set of features. Approach B is only possible if the contract allows it without cost that outweighs any benefit. Nothing here says one approach is better; it shows that the timing of income can move MAGI in a particular year.
The two-year lag in practice
Because Social Security looks back, the year of the income and the year of the premium are different years. A few consequences:
- A large taxable withdrawal or surrender this year is generally reflected in Medicare premiums two years from now, not this year.
- Income at age 63 can matter, since a person who turns 65 may have a first-year Medicare premium set by a tax return from two years earlier.
- A one-time spike can raise premiums for a single year, and the following year’s figure then rests on a different tax year. A recurring withdrawal pattern has a recurring effect.
- If the IRS information for the usual year is not available, Social Security can use an older year, up to three years back.
For a retiree already on Medicare, the cleanest way to plan is to build a calendar of the tax year you are in, the tax year Social Security will read next and any year with an unusual event, such as selling a business or home, a large IRA distribution, a surrender or a partial exchange.
If your income drops: asking Social Security for a new decision
Social Security can issue a new decision when income has fallen because of certain life-changing events. Medicare’s fact sheet and Social Security’s operating manual list them: marriage, divorce or annulment, the death of a spouse, work stoppage or reduced hours, loss of income-producing property because of a disaster or other event beyond your control, loss of employer pension income or a pension plan reorganization or termination, and certain settlements from an employer’s closure, bankruptcy or reorganization.
The manual also describes the process. You request a new determination, show evidence of both the event and more recent or accurate tax information, and, if you have not yet filed the tax return for the most recent year, provide an estimate of your MAGI. The event has to significantly reduce MAGI or move you to a filing status with a lower threshold table. If you do not provide the evidence within 30 days, the request can be dismissed, though the manual describes a possible 90-day extension if you ask.
A one-time annuity withdrawal or surrender is not itself on the manual’s list of life-changing events. If a year with a big taxable event is followed by a retirement, a spouse’s death or another listed event, a request may be worth making, and Social Security can explain how your facts fit. Do not assume a surcharge caused by a voluntary withdrawal can be reversed afterward. The letter you receive explains what to do if you disagree with a decision.
Social Security benefit taxation is a separate calculation with a similar logic
Separate from IRMAA, income also determines how much of your Social Security retirement benefit is taxed. IRS Publication 915 explains the test: add one-half of your benefits to your other income, including tax-exempt interest, and compare the total with a base amount for your filing status. Depending on the total, generally up to 50% or up to 85% of your benefits can be taxable.
Annuity income enters through the same door: the taxable part of withdrawals and payments counts as other income. Tax deferral keeps unwithdrawn growth out of that total. A year with a large surrender can therefore have two knock-on effects, more of your benefit becoming taxable that year and a possibly higher Medicare premium later. The two calculations use different measures and different tables, so do not assume that passing one threshold means you passed the other.
Using annuity income to plan Medicare costs
Predictable income can make the premium side of Medicare easier to budget, which is one reason retirement-income plans sometimes include a fixed annuity. Think in terms of fixed costs and variable costs:
- Fixed or known costs: the Part B premium (currently $202.90 before any IRMAA add-on), Part D plan premiums and Medigap or Medicare Advantage premiums.
- Variable costs: deductibles, copays and coinsurance, which change with use of care.
- Possible add-ons: Part B and Part D IRMAA, which depend on a return you have already filed or will file.
If you take a lifetime income stream from an annuity, compare the taxable portion of each payment with your other income when you estimate MAGI. If you plan systematic withdrawals from a multi-year guaranteed annuity, our page on using a MYGA in a retirement income plan shows how that timing interacts with Social Security and Medicare. Neither approach is a way to avoid Medicare costs; they are ways to see them coming.
Medicare Savings Programs, Extra Help and Medicaid
The programs below look at income and, in many cases, resources. Annuity ownership can matter to them, and the rules are specific to each program and state.
Medicare Savings Programs. These are run by states and help pay some Medicare costs, depending on the program. Medicare.gov says most have limits on income and resources, that the limits change each year, and that your state may not count certain income or resources. Apply through your state Medicaid office.
Extra Help with Part D costs. Social Security’s operating manual describes an income test and a resource test, and counts a spouse’s income and resources if you live together. How a particular annuity contract is counted depends on the program’s income and resource rules, so ask Social Security or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program. In Ohio, that is the Ohio Senior Health Insurance Information Program (OSHIIP), run by the Ohio Department of Insurance.
Medicaid long-term care. Federal Medicaid law, 42 U.S.C. section 1396p, addresses annuities specifically. It treats the purchase of an annuity as a transfer of assets for less than fair market value unless certain conditions are met, including that the state is named as a remainder beneficiary, and it sets conditions for annuities that are not part of a qualifying retirement account: irrevocable and nonassignable, actuarially sound, and payments in equal amounts with no deferral and no balloon payments. That description is a different design from a deferred accumulation annuity. Ohio’s rule on the treatment of annuity purchases (Ohio Administrative Code 5160:1-6-06.1) follows the same structure, applies to purchases made on or after February 8, 2006 (older annuities come under it only if a later transaction, such as adding principal or electing annuitization, occurs on or after that date), and requires disclosure of any annuity interest. For other transfers of assets, federal law uses a 60-month look-back period.
The takeaway is not that annuities and Medicaid cannot coexist. It is that Medicaid rules for annuities are technical, differ by state and change, and a purchase made close to a long-term care need can create a restricted coverage period. Speak with an elder-law attorney before buying an annuity, or exchanging one, if Medicaid eligibility is a realistic possibility. Our overview of annuities for Ohio retirees collects the Ohio-specific points we have been able to verify.
Where long-term care fits
Medicare generally does not cover long-term custodial care, as we explain on our page on Medicare and long-term care. People who want to plan for that gap choose among self-funding, long-term care insurance, Medicaid after eligibility rules are met, or a mix. Annuities appear in these discussions in two ways: as a source of income to pay for care, and as an asset that Medicaid rules examine. Neither role is a recommendation. If long-term care funding is the main goal, say so early in any planning conversation, because it changes which questions come first.
Reasons not to buy an annuity only to manage IRMAA
Because deferral is attractive for MAGI, it is worth stating the limits plainly.
- Deferral is not elimination. The deferred earnings are taxed when withdrawn, perhaps in a year with higher income, such as when required minimum distributions begin on other accounts.
- Surrender charges and liquidity. A contract’s surrender schedule can make it expensive to access the money when you need it, including for health costs.
- Guarantees depend on the insurer. Annuities are insurance contracts, they are not FDIC-insured, and state guaranty associations provide limited protection. Insurer ratings and guaranty association limits are worth checking before any purchase.
- Thresholds and rules change. Income bands, tax law and program rules are updated, so a plan built around today’s thresholds can age badly.
- Surcharge size relative to cost. Compare the size of a potential IRMAA add-on with the contract’s costs and your other needs before drawing any conclusion.
Questions to bring to a tax professional or advisor
If you are considering a surrender, partial withdrawal, exchange or new purchase and have Medicare or Medicaid in view, these questions make a conversation more productive.
- What will my AGI and MAGI be for this tax year with and without the transaction?
- Which year’s return will Social Security read for my next premium?
- Would spreading withdrawals over more than one tax year change the outcome, and does the contract allow it?
- How does the transaction affect the taxable portion of my Social Security benefit?
- If this is an exchange, does it meet the requirements of section 1035, and how will the paperwork be reported?
- If Medicaid or a Medicare Savings Program is realistic, how would this annuity be counted, and should an elder-law attorney review it first?
- Which of these effects are certain, and which depend on rules that change each year?
Our annuity buying checklist covers the questions to ask on the insurance side. If you want to talk through how a Medicare plan and an annuity fit together, contact our team.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does buying an annuity raise my Medicare premiums?
The purchase itself does not. Medicare premiums with an income-related add-on are based on the modified adjusted gross income from your tax return, generally from two years earlier. A purchase can matter indirectly if the money used to fund it, or later withdrawals from it, create taxable income in a given year.
Does annuity income count for IRMAA?
The taxable part of annuity withdrawals or payments is included in your adjusted gross income, and MAGI for IRMAA is your AGI plus tax-exempt interest. Growth that stays inside a deferred annuity is generally not on your return until it is distributed, and a properly structured section 1035 exchange is not a taxable event.
Can I appeal an IRMAA decision after a large withdrawal?
You can ask Social Security for a new decision if your income dropped because of a listed life-changing event, such as marriage, divorce, the death of a spouse, work stoppage or reduction, or loss of certain pension or property income. A one-time withdrawal is not itself on that list, so your options depend on the facts. The letter from Social Security explains how to disagree with a decision.
Do Medigap and Medicare Advantage plans depend on whether I own an annuity?
Owning an annuity is not an eligibility factor for Medicare, and plan premiums are set by the plans and plan rules. The income-related add-ons apply to Part B and Part D premiums. Ask a licensed agent about the specifics of any plan in your area.
Will an annuity affect my eligibility for Medicaid?
It can, particularly for Medicaid long-term care. Federal law and Ohio’s rules treat annuity purchases made by or for applicants in a specific way, and a purchase that does not meet the conditions can lead to a restricted coverage period. Rules vary by state, so consult an elder-law attorney before buying or exchanging an annuity if Medicaid is a possibility.
Where can I find the current IRMAA income levels?
Medicare.gov and Social Security publish them for each premium year, and they change over time. We do not print the figures here for that reason; our IRMAA explainer shows how to read the table and where to look.
Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.
Ready to talk through your options?
It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.
