Last updated: November 16, 2026

MYGA vs. CD vs. Treasury: A Side-by-Side Comparison

A multi-year guaranteed annuity (MYGA), a bank or credit union certificate of deposit (CD) and a Treasury security can each lock in a fixed return for a set period, but they differ on who stands behind the promise, how you get your money out early, and when the interest is taxed. A MYGA is an insurance contract with tax deferral and a surrender schedule, a CD is a deposit with deposit insurance and an early withdrawal penalty, and a Treasury is a government obligation that can be sold before maturity at the market price. This page compares them across those points without quoting any current rates.

Three instruments that look alike and are built differently

On a rate sheet, a five-year MYGA, a five-year CD and a five-year Treasury note can look interchangeable: you hand over money, you are told a fixed rate, and you get the money back at the end. The differences sit underneath the rate, and they decide which instrument fits a particular job.

  • A MYGA is a fixed-rate deferred annuity issued by a life insurance company. The insurer declares a rate for a guarantee period, and the contract usually has a surrender schedule. FINRA’s investor education page describes a fixed annuity as one in which the insurer guarantees both the rate of return and the payout, and says growth is not taxed until you start making withdrawals. Our complete MYGA guide covers the product in depth.
  • A CD is a time deposit at a bank or a share certificate at a credit union. You agree to leave the money for a term, and the institution pays a stated rate.
  • A Treasury security is a debt obligation of the U.S. government. TreasuryDirect lists bills (4 to 52 weeks), notes (2, 3, 5, 7 or 10 years), bonds (20 or 30 years), inflation-protected securities and floating rate notes, and states that all of them are backed by the full faith and credit of the United States.

One structural difference shows up immediately: the terms on offer. MYGA guarantee periods are generally measured in multiple years, CDs run from short terms to several years, and Treasury bills mature within a year while notes start at two. If you need a particular maturity, one of the three may not offer it, and that alone can decide the question.

Side-by-side table

The table is a general framework. Individual contracts, banks and securities vary, so treat it as a list of questions rather than a description of any specific product.

FeatureMYGABank or credit union CDTreasury security
IssuerLife insurance companyBank or credit unionU.S. government
BackingInsurer’s claims-paying ability; limited state guaranty association protection; not FDIC-insuredFDIC (banks) or NCUA (credit unions) insurance up to limitsFull faith and credit of the U.S. government
Typical termsCommonly several years; varies by productMonths to several yearsBills up to one year; notes 2 to 10 years; bonds 20 to 30 years
RateDeclared by the insurer and guaranteed by it for the guarantee periodFixed for the term for most CDsFixed interest rate, or a discount for bills, set when the security is sold
Early accessSurrender charge on withdrawals above the free-withdrawal amount; market value adjustment on some contractsEarly withdrawal penalty set by the institutionCan be sold before maturity at the market price, which may be above or below what you paid
Federal tax on interestDeferred until withdrawn; ordinary income when taxedGenerally taxed in the year it becomes availableGenerally taxed; bills at maturity or sale, notes and bonds as interest is paid
State income tax on interestGenerally applies to taxable gain; varies by stateGenerally applies; varies by stateExempt from state and local income tax
Annual tax formNone for deferred interest in an individually owned non-qualified contract; Form 1099-R when money is distributedForm 1099-INTForm 1099-INT
10% additional tax before age 59 1/2Can apply to the taxable part of a withdrawal, with exceptionsNot applicable to the CD itselfNot applicable
Tax-deferred exchange to a similar productAn annuity can be exchanged for another annuity under IRC section 1035No equivalentNo equivalent
What happens at term endRenewal rate or options set by contractMany renew automatically unless you act within a grace period; check the account agreementMatures and pays face value

Several of these rows deserve a longer look, and the sections below take them in turn.

Who stands behind the promise

MYGA. Annuities are insurance contracts. The FDIC’s own description of deposit insurance lists annuities and life insurance policies as not covered, so a MYGA is not FDIC-insured. The guarantee is only as good as the insurer’s ability to meet its obligations. If an insurer fails, the state guaranty association system may cover some benefits within limits. NOLHGA, the national organization of these associations, describes most states’ annuity limit as $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits, notes that some states are higher, and explains that coverage generally comes from the association in the owner’s state of residence at the time the insurer is placed in liquidation. In Ohio, the statute (Ohio Revised Code section 3956.04) sets $250,000 in present value of annuity benefits per individual, subject to its other limits and exclusions. Amounts above the limit may become a claim against the failed insurer’s estate rather than being paid in full. This is background on how the protections work, not a reason to pick one instrument over another. Our page on insurer ratings and state guaranty associations covers this system and how to check an insurer.

CD. The FDIC insures deposits at insured banks up to $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category. The coverage depends on how the account is titled, so a single account, a joint account and an IRA at the same bank are in different categories, and all deposits you hold in the same category at one bank are added together. At federally insured credit unions, the NCUA’s standard maximum share insurance amount is also $250,000, and share certificates are included. If you hold more than the limit at one institution in one category, the excess is not covered.

Treasury. TreasuryDirect states that Treasury securities are backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. That backing covers timely interest and full principal at maturity. It does not cover the market price if you sell early: SEC investor education explains that the government does not guarantee the market price of a bond sold before maturity, and that rising rates push the prices of existing fixed-rate bonds down.

None of this tells you which is “stronger” in a general sense. It tells you that you are relying on three different kinds of promise, and that the protections have different limits and mechanics. The first question to ask about any of them is what would happen if the issuer could not pay.

Getting your money out early

All three limit early access, in different ways.

  • MYGA. A surrender schedule charges a percentage on withdrawals beyond a free-withdrawal amount, usually declining each year. Some contracts also apply a market value adjustment, which can increase or decrease the amount you receive depending on how interest rates have moved since you bought; NAIC’s 2022 Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities says an MVA could raise or lower the value and that every MVA calculation is different. Waivers for nursing home confinement or terminal illness exist in many contracts and vary by state and contract. The detail is in our page on MYGA surrender charges, free withdrawals and market value adjustments.
  • CD. Under the federal Truth in Savings rules (Regulation DD for banks), institutions must disclose that a penalty may be imposed for early withdrawal, how it is calculated and the conditions for charging it. The formula varies by institution, so read the account agreement before you commit.
  • Treasury. There is no penalty in the surrender sense. You can sell, and you receive the market price. If rates have risen since you bought, the price is likely to be lower than what you paid; if they have fallen, it is likely to be higher. Holding to maturity returns the face value.

For money you may need before the term ends, these differences matter more than the headline rate. A CD with a modest penalty, a Treasury that can be sold, and a MYGA with a multi-year surrender schedule are three different answers to the question of how much access you are giving up.

How the interest is taxed

This is the area where the three differ most, and it is also where it is easy to oversimplify. This section is general education, not tax advice; a CPA or tax attorney can apply it to your return.

Annual versus deferred. The IRS says most interest on bank accounts, including CDs, is taxable in the year it becomes available to you, and the payer should issue a Form 1099-INT for interest of $10 or more. A non-qualified annuity owned by an individual defers tax on growth until money is withdrawn. For Treasuries, TreasuryDirect explains that notes and bonds generate federal tax each year on interest paid, and bills generate interest at maturity or sale, so it is taxed in that year.

Interest comes out first from a non-qualified annuity. When you take a withdrawal from a non-qualified annuity before the annuity starting date, IRC section 72(e) and IRS Publication 575 treat the money as coming from earnings first, then from your cost (your after-tax premium). The earnings are taxed as ordinary income when they are withdrawn. A CD or Treasury has no such ordering, since interest is taxed as it arrives.

State tax. TreasuryDirect states that interest on Treasury securities is exempt from state and local income tax while being subject to federal tax. CD interest and annuity gains are generally taxable at the state level where a state has an income tax, but states differ, so check your own state’s treatment.

Net investment income tax. The IRS lists interest and non-qualified annuities among the types of net investment income that can be subject to the net investment income tax for taxpayers above the income thresholds in the statute. This is another place where timing matters: CD and Treasury interest is counted as it is received, and non-qualified annuity gain is counted when it is taxed.

Non-natural owners. Under IRC section 72(u), an annuity contract held by an owner who is not a natural person is generally not treated as an annuity for tax purposes, and the income is taxed currently as ordinary income. Exceptions include a holder acting as an agent for a natural person, a contract acquired by an estate at the owner’s death, contracts held under qualified plans and IRAs, and immediate annuities. If a trust or business would own the contract, this needs professional review.

A hypothetical to show the timing effect

To isolate the tax timing, here is a deliberately simple example. These are made-up numbers for illustration only, not a current rate, a quote or a prediction. Assume $100,000 earns a fixed 4.00 percent annual effective rate for five years in both a CD and a MYGA, the owner has a 24 percent marginal federal rate throughout, state tax is ignored, and in the CD case each year’s tax is paid from that year’s interest.

CD (interest taxed each year)MYGA (taxed at the end)
Pre-tax rate4.00%4.00%
After-tax rate earned each year3.04% (4.00% less 24% tax)4.00% (no tax until withdrawal)
Value after 5 years, before any tax due at the end$116,153$121,665
Tax due at the endnone furtherabout $5,200 (24% of $21,665 gain)
Value after all tax$116,153$116,466

In this example, deferral produces about $313 more after tax over five years on $100,000. That is a small difference, and it depends on assumptions that may not hold: that the rates are identical, that the tax rate is the same when the gain is finally taxed, and that the MYGA is held to the end without surrender charges or a market value adjustment. In practice the rates, surrender terms and tax brackets differ, and deferral matters more the longer the period and the higher the rate. Differences in rate between products can swamp the tax effect in either direction, which is why comparing after-tax results, not headlines, is worth the effort.

Effects on Social Security taxation and Medicare premiums

Interest reported each year raises adjusted gross income. SSA describes the combined income used to decide whether Social Security benefits are taxable as adjusted gross income plus nontaxable interest plus half of Social Security benefits, so reportable CD and Treasury interest counts in that formula. For Medicare, SSA describes modified adjusted gross income as adjusted gross income plus tax-exempt interest, and the income-related monthly adjustment amount (IRMAA) for Part B and Part D is generally based on tax data from two years earlier. Deferral inside a MYGA can keep reportable income lower while the contract accumulates, but a large withdrawal or surrender can put much of the gain into a single year. Our pages on annuities and Medicare and IRMAA explain the mechanics. We do not state bracket figures here because they change.

The 10 percent additional tax and 1035 exchanges

Before age 59 1/2. IRC section 72(q) imposes a 10 percent additional tax on the taxable part of an annuity distribution, with exceptions that include age 59 1/2 or older, death, disability, substantially equal periodic payments and payments under an immediate annuity. IRS Publication 575 notes that the tax applies only to the part of a distribution that is includible in income. CDs are not subject to this tax; a CD’s early withdrawal penalty is the institution’s, not the IRS’s. If you are under 59 1/2 and may need to withdraw from a MYGA, factor the additional tax into the surrender schedule and the ordinary income tax.

Exchanges. IRC section 1035(a)(3) provides that no gain or loss is recognized on the exchange of an annuity contract for another annuity contract, and IRS Publication 575 says an exchange for a contract issued by a different company is reported on Form 1099-R with code 6 in box 7. That is relevant at the end of a MYGA guarantee period, when you might want to move to a different contract without a taxable event. A CD or Treasury has no equivalent mechanism. The rules for how an exchange must be set up (a direct transfer, same owner and annuitant) are covered in our page on what happens when a MYGA guarantee period ends. A new contract usually starts a new surrender period, so an exchange is not without cost.

Laddering and reinvestment risk

All three instruments face reinvestment risk: when the term ends, new money may earn less or more than the old. Spreading maturities over time is a common response, and it works with CDs, Treasuries and MYGAs alike. With a ladder, one rung matures regularly and can be reinvested at then-current rates or used for spending. With MYGAs, the rungs can be issued by different insurers, which also spreads your reliance across more than one company. Our page on MYGA laddering shows a worked hypothetical ladder in a table and discusses the drawbacks: multiple contracts, minimum premiums and dependence on the rate environment.

Income needs and cash flow

How you will use the interest can steer the choice.

  • If you want interest paid out regularly, Treasury notes and bonds pay interest every six months, and many CDs can be set up to pay interest out. A MYGA typically accumulates interest inside the contract, though some contracts permit interest-only withdrawals, and those withdrawals are limited by the free withdrawal provisions.
  • If you plan to let the money grow to a known date and then use it, the guarantee period and deferral are the features at work.
  • If a required minimum distribution is involved because the contract is inside an IRA, tax deferral is already provided by the IRA, and the comparison is about guarantees, access and rate, not about annuity tax deferral. Our page on using a MYGA in a retirement income plan looks at this.

Considerations that may point toward each

The goal of this section is to describe considerations, not to tell you what to buy. Which instrument fits depends on your whole situation.

  • A MYGA may be worth considering when you have money you are confident you will not need for the guarantee period, you value the tax deferral on non-qualified money, you are comfortable relying on the issuing insurer’s claims-paying ability, you want a defined maturity that is longer than Treasury bills or short CDs offer, and the surrender schedule fits your time horizon.
  • A CD may be worth considering when you want deposit insurance, an institution you can walk into, and a simple early withdrawal penalty, and the term you need is available.
  • A Treasury may be worth considering when you want U.S. government backing, state and local income tax exemption on interest, and the ability to sell before maturity, and you accept that the sale price can be lower than what you paid.

Each also has tradeoffs that cut the other way: a MYGA can cost more to leave early and relies on the insurer; a CD’s rate can be lower and its interest is taxed each year; a Treasury’s price can fall if you sell early. Many households use more than one, because each answers a different part of the question. Our guide on who might consider a MYGA, and who might not sets out a suitability framework.

Questions to bring to a comparison

  1. How long will this money stay untouched, and what is my plan if I need it sooner?
  2. What is the early-access cost of each option, in dollars, at year one, two and three?
  3. Which option fits the account type: after-tax money, an IRA or a trust?
  4. What happens at term end, and what is the process and deadline for each?
  5. How would reportable interest each year affect my tax return, my Social Security taxation and my Medicare premiums, compared with deferral?
  6. Am I within deposit insurance and guaranty association limits at each issuer?
  7. What is the insurer’s financial strength, and where can I check it?
  8. If I am replacing something, what do I give up by doing so?

Our annuity buying checklist turns these into a step-by-step process, and you can reach us through our contact page if you want help working through them. We do not quote rates on this site, and this page is educational, not tax, legal or investment advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a MYGA the same as a CD?

No. A CD is a deposit at a bank or credit union, insured by the FDIC or NCUA up to limits. A MYGA is an annuity contract issued by a life insurance company, not insured by the FDIC, with protection from a state guaranty association within limits. The tax treatment, early-access rules and issuer risk all differ, even though both lock a rate for a term.

Is MYGA interest taxed differently from CD interest?

For a non-qualified annuity owned by an individual, growth is generally tax-deferred until withdrawal, and withdrawals are treated as earnings first. CD interest is generally taxable in the year it becomes available. Both are ordinary income when taxed, and state treatment varies. A tax professional can explain how this applies to your situation.

Is Treasury interest exempt from state tax?

Treasury interest is subject to federal income tax and exempt from state and local income taxes, according to TreasuryDirect. Whether the state exemption makes a difference depends on whether your state has an income tax and what rate applies.

Does the 10 percent additional tax apply to CDs?

No, the section 72(q) additional tax applies to annuity distributions, not to CDs. It applies to the taxable portion of a withdrawal from an annuity before age 59 1/2 unless an exception applies. A CD’s early withdrawal penalty is set by the institution and is a separate matter.

Can I move a CD into a MYGA without tax?

A CD is not an annuity, so section 1035 does not apply to it. You can cash out a CD, subject to any penalty and to tax on the interest, and use the proceeds to buy a MYGA. A 1035 exchange is available for moving from one annuity contract to another.

Does buying a MYGA change my Medicare coverage?

Buying a MYGA does not affect eligibility for Medicare. Income reported on your tax return, including annuity gains when taxed, can affect Social Security benefit taxation and Medicare premium surcharges through the income-related monthly adjustment amount, which is generally based on tax data from two years earlier. Our page on annuities and Medicare explains the timing.

Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.

Ready to talk through your options?

It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.