Last updated: November 16, 2026

MYGA Surrender Charges, Free Withdrawals and Market Value Adjustments

A MYGA lets you leave early, but not without cost: withdrawals above the amount the contract allows each year are usually charged a surrender charge that declines over the surrender period, and some contracts also apply a market value adjustment (MVA) that can raise or lower what you receive depending on how interest rates have moved. Many contracts have a free withdrawal amount, waivers for certain events, and tax rules that treat interest as coming out first. The exact terms are in each contract, so this page explains the mechanics and shows how to find them. All dollar examples are hypothetical.

Why MYGAs have surrender charges at all

An insurer that declares a fixed rate for several years invests your premium in assets meant to be held for roughly that long. If many owners left early, the insurer might have to sell those assets at a loss. The surrender charge and, where used, the market value adjustment are the contract’s way of passing some of that cost to the owner who leaves. They are also the reason a MYGA is described as a product for money you do not expect to need during the term. NAIC’s 2022 Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities describes a surrender charge as a percentage of the amount taken out that usually goes down each year until the surrender charge period ends, and the newer NAIC Annuity Buyer’s Guide says most deferred annuities have a surrender charge period of often 5 to 10 years, sometimes longer.

This page stays on the exit side of the product. Our complete guide to MYGAs covers the whole product, and how MYGA rates work covers the rate you earn while you are inside it. The same concepts exist in indexed annuities, and our page on fixed indexed annuity surrender charges and withdrawals explains them from that angle, including what happens to index credits when you withdraw mid-period.

How surrender schedules are built

A surrender schedule is a table in the contract that lists a charge for each contract year. Common shapes, described in general terms:

  • Declining schedule. The charge starts at a higher percentage and falls each year until it reaches zero, which is the pattern the NAIC’s 2022 guide describes as usual.
  • Other shapes. Some contracts hold a charge flat for a stretch of years and then drop it. Look at the actual schedule instead of assuming a pattern.
  • Length versus guarantee period. In many MYGAs the surrender period matches the guarantee period, so the charge reaches zero when the rate guarantee ends. Some contracts have a longer surrender period than guarantee period, which means a renewal rate you could not have known at purchase may apply while a charge still does. Check both lengths side by side.

To show what a schedule looks like, here is a hypothetical seven-year declining schedule, invented for illustration and not a description of any product:

Contract yearHypothetical surrender charge
17%
26%
35%
44%
53%
62%
71%
8 and later0%

How the charge is applied also varies. In some contracts it applies to the amount withdrawn above the free-withdrawal amount; in others it applies to the full amount. The contract will say whether the charge is calculated on the account value or on premium, and whether it is deducted from the amount withdrawn or from the remaining balance. Ask for these details by name and look for them in the contract’s schedule page.

Free withdrawals: the part you can take out without a charge

Many contracts allow a limited amount to be withdrawn each year without a surrender charge. NAIC’s 2022 guide says most annuities with surrender charges let owners take out a certain amount, usually up to 10 percent, each year without a charge on that amount, and the newer NAIC guide describes the allowed amount as generally 5 to 10 percent annually. MYGAs vary, so confirm the figure in the contract. Points to look for:

  • How the amount is measured. It may be a percentage of the premium or of the account value, and the base can differ at the start of the contract year or at the time of withdrawal.
  • Whether unused amounts carry over. In many contracts they do not. A free-withdrawal amount not taken one year is often lost, not saved.
  • Interest-only withdrawals. Some contracts allow you to withdraw the interest earned, at set intervals, without a charge. If you are using a MYGA to produce income, this feature may matter more than the percentage.
  • Whether withdrawals reduce the base. A free withdrawal reduces the account value, and so reduces the interest earned on the balance going forward.
  • The first year. Some contracts do not allow a free withdrawal in the first contract year, and some set a minimum withdrawal size or a minimum remaining balance.
  • A systematic program. Some contracts only exempt withdrawals taken through the insurer’s scheduled withdrawal program.

A hypothetical partial withdrawal

Suppose a hypothetical contract has the schedule above and a free-withdrawal amount of 10 percent of the account value each year. In contract year 3 the account value is $100,000, and the owner withdraws $25,000.

  • Free-withdrawal amount: 10% of $100,000 = $10,000
  • Amount above the free-withdrawal amount: $25,000 minus $10,000 = $15,000
  • Surrender charge: year 3 is 5%, so 5% of $15,000 = $750
  • Amount received before taxes: $25,000 minus $750 = $24,250
  • Remaining account value: $75,000 (the charge is paid out of the withdrawal in this example)

This example leaves out any market value adjustment and any taxes, which are covered below. The arithmetic works only if the contract charges on the excess; if it charged 5 percent on the whole $25,000, the charge would be $1,250. That is the kind of detail worth confirming before you act.

Market value adjustments

An MVA is a formula in some contracts that adjusts the value you receive when you withdraw or surrender before the end of the guarantee period. NAIC’s 2022 Buyer’s Guide for Deferred Annuities explains that an MVA could increase or decrease your annuity’s account value, cash surrender value, and/or death benefit value if you withdraw money from your account, and that every MVA calculation is different. The direction depends on interest rates:

  • If interest rates are higher when you withdraw than they were when you bought the annuity, the MVA could reduce the amount you can take from your annuity.
  • If interest rates are lower when you withdraw than when you bought, the MVA could increase the amount you can take.

The logic is similar to how bond prices behave. An insurer that holds assets to meet your guarantee would take a loss on those assets if it had to sell them after rates rose, and could take a gain if rates fell, and the MVA is a way of reflecting that. The SEC’s investor education page on annuities, in discussing registered MVA annuities, says these adjustments are in addition to any surrender charge that applies. The details vary from one contract to another, so treat the following as an illustration of the shape, not a formula you will find in your own contract.

A hypothetical MVA example

One common form of the calculation, which contracts vary, is to compare the interest rate when you bought (call it I) with a current rate for a similar period (call it J), and apply the difference over the number of years left in the guarantee period (n). This is a simplified teaching formula, not one taken from any particular contract:

Adjustment factor = ((1 + I) / (1 + J)) raised to the power n

Assume, for illustration only, that I = 4.00 percent, n = 3 years remain, and the account value is $100,000. The numbers below are hypothetical and not a rate, a quote or a forecast.

ScenarioComparison rate JAdjustment factorValue after MVA
Rates have risen5.00%(1.04 / 1.05)^3 = 0.9717$97,170
Rates have fallen3.00%(1.04 / 1.03)^3 = 1.0294$102,941

Now add a surrender charge. Assume 4 percent applies in that year and, in this contract, the charge is taken first and the MVA is applied to the remainder:

ScenarioAccount valueAfter 4% surrender chargeAfter MVA
Rates have risen$100,000$96,000about $93,283
Rates have fallen$100,000$96,000about $98,823

The order of operations differs by contract. In some, the MVA is applied to the account value first and the charge afterward. In others, the free withdrawal amount is excluded from the MVA. The results can differ by hundreds of dollars on a $100,000 contract, so the contract’s example calculation, which many contracts include, is the document to study.

Features of MVAs to ask about:

  • A floor. Many MVA contracts include a minimum guaranteed value so that the adjustment, together with other deductions, does not take the value below a contractual amount. Whether and how much depends on the contract and on state nonforfeiture requirements, which for deferred annuities build a minimum from a percentage of premiums accumulated at a minimum rate. The NAIC model standard nonforfeiture law uses 87.5 percent of premiums in its model text, and states adopt their own versions.
  • A reference rate. The rate J is taken from an index or from the insurer’s own current rates for a comparable period. Which one is used affects the result.
  • Windows with no adjustment. Some contracts do not apply the MVA during a period around the end of the guarantee period or for certain events such as death. Check the endorsement.
  • A distinction in product type. Annuities with an MVA that are registered with the SEC are securities products, described by the SEC as registered MVA annuities. This page discusses fixed insurance contracts; if a product is sold under a prospectus, different rules and disclosures apply.

Required minimum distributions from a qualified MYGA

When a MYGA is held inside an IRA or another qualified account, required minimum distributions (RMDs) apply to the account, and the age at which they begin depends on the owner’s birth year under current law. IRS Publication 590-B explains how RMDs are figured and says that special rules apply when part of an IRA balance is used to buy an annuity contract that pays out, including how the contract’s value and payments combine with the remaining balance. In practice the question for a MYGA is whether a withdrawal needed to satisfy an RMD triggers a surrender charge. Some contracts allow RMD withdrawals as an exception to the surrender charge, sometimes limited to withdrawals taken through the insurer’s systematic program; others do not. Check the contract language, and see our page on how fixed annuities are taxed for the broader rules. A tax professional can confirm how an RMD applies to your accounts.

Waivers for nursing home confinement, terminal illness and death

Many contracts waive the surrender charge, and sometimes the MVA, if certain events occur. They typically include:

  • Nursing home or hospital confinement. Often requires a stay of a minimum number of consecutive days, sometimes starting after the contract date and sometimes with a limit on the owner’s age when the contract was issued.
  • Terminal illness. Usually requires a physician’s certification of a limited life expectancy, and the length of that life expectancy differs between contracts and states.
  • Death. Many contracts do not apply the surrender charge to a death benefit, but check, because the death benefit definition and any MVA treatment are specified in the contract.

These provisions are not uniform. Contracts and state-specific endorsements set different thresholds. One insurer contract filed with the SEC, for example, requires confinement of 30 consecutive days beginning after the contract date and a physician-certified life expectancy of 12 months or less for the terminal illness waiver, and other contracts and states use other periods. Some waivers can be used only once, some apply only to full surrenders and some do not apply to certain ages. Do not rely on a general description. The waiver language in your contract, and any state endorsement, controls, and Ohio contracts can be different from a contract issued in another state.

Two practical points. First, a waiver generally has to be claimed with documentation, so if the situation arises, contact the insurer early. Second, long-term care planning affects whether a waiver is useful. A waiver that requires a long confinement may not help with a shorter stay. Our existing page on long-term care insurance and the related guide on whether Medicare covers long-term care explain why that planning belongs alongside any annuity purchase.

Partial versus full surrender

A partial withdrawal reduces the account value and leaves the rest of the contract in place. Interest continues on the remaining balance at the declared rate, and the surrender schedule keeps running. Some contracts have a minimum remaining balance and, if a withdrawal would bring the contract below it, require a full surrender.

A full surrender ends the contract. You receive the surrender value after any charge and MVA, the contract’s guaranteed rate and death benefit end, and a taxable gain, if there is one, is reported. If you are thinking about surrendering to buy something else, consider a section 1035 exchange to another annuity instead, which can move the money without a taxable event but starts a new surrender period in the new contract. The page on what happens when a MYGA guarantee period ends covers the exchange mechanics, and our annuity buying checklist covers replacement cautions.

How withdrawals are taxed

This section is general education and not tax advice; a CPA or tax attorney can apply it to your situation.

Earnings come out first. For a non-qualified annuity (bought with after-tax money), IRC section 72(e) treats a withdrawal before the annuity starting date as taxable to the extent the cash value exceeds your investment in the contract, with the rest treated as a return of your cost. IRS Publication 575 describes it the same way: the amount withdrawn is allocated first to earnings (the taxable part) and then to your cost. Taxable earnings are ordinary income. Section 72(e)(3)(A) measures the gain using cash value determined without regard to any surrender charge, so a charge does not reduce the amount of the earnings treated as withdrawn for a partial withdrawal. A full surrender is treated differently: IRS Publication 575 says the amount received is tax free to the extent of the cost you have not previously recovered and the rest is taxable, so a tax professional should confirm how a surrender charge fits into the calculation for your contract.

Hypothetical. Assume $100,000 of premium (your cost) and an account value of $112,000, so $12,000 of earnings. You withdraw $20,000. The first $12,000 is allocated to earnings and is taxable as ordinary income; the remaining $8,000 is a return of cost and is not taxed. Your account value is then $92,000 and your remaining cost is $92,000 (the $100,000 premium less the $8,000 returned), so no earnings remain until more interest is credited; later interest would again come out first. Different contracts, an MVA or a surrender charge change the amount received, not the ordering rule.

The 10 percent additional tax. Under IRC section 72(q), the taxable part of an annuity distribution generally carries an additional 10 percent tax unless an exception applies. The exceptions include distributions made on or after age 59 1/2, after the holder’s death, because of disability, as part of substantially equal periodic payments, and under an immediate annuity. In the hypothetical above, if the owner were under 59 1/2 and no exception applied, the additional tax would be 10 percent of the $12,000 taxable part, or $1,200, on top of ordinary income tax. The additional tax applies only to the taxable part of a distribution, as IRS Publication 575 notes.

Withholding and reporting. The insurer reports distributions on Form 1099-R. IRS Publication 575 says the withholding rate for a nonperiodic distribution is 10 percent unless you elect no withholding or the payment is an eligible rollover distribution. That is a withholding default, not your final tax. A section 1035 exchange is shown on Form 1099-R with code 6 in box 7 and is not reported as income.

Qualified contracts. A MYGA inside an IRA follows IRA rules, not the non-qualified ordering above. Early distributions from an IRA are subject to their own penalty rules, and an RMD may be required. Our page on how fixed annuities are taxed covers the framework.

For the Medicare effect of a large withdrawal, see our page on annuities and Medicare: gain reported in one year can raise modified adjusted gross income, which the Social Security Administration uses, based on tax data from two years earlier, to decide Part B and Part D premium surcharges.

Where to find these terms in your contract

If you are reading a contract or a quote and want to locate the exit terms, look for these headings and pages:

  1. Contract data or schedule page. The surrender charge schedule, the free withdrawal percentage and any minimum remaining balance.
  2. Surrender charge or withdrawal provisions. How the charge is calculated and on what base.
  3. Market value adjustment endorsement. The formula, the reference rate, the floor and any exempt windows.
  4. Waiver endorsements. Nursing home, terminal illness and death provisions, with any state-specific substitution.
  5. Nonforfeiture or guaranteed minimum value page. The minimum values the contract must provide under state law, often shown in a table by year.
  6. Death benefit provision. Whether the surrender charge or MVA applies at death.
  7. Disclosure document and buyer’s guide. The NAIC buyer’s guide and the company disclosure should explain surrender charges and MVAs in summary form.
  8. Free look provision. The number of days after delivery you can cancel, and what is refunded. NAIC’s 2022 guide says the period is usually 10 to 30 days depending on the state, and the newer NAIC guide says usually 10 days, stated on the first page of the contract. Ohio rule 3901-6-14 requires at least fifteen days when the buyer’s guide and disclosure were not given at or before application.

Planning around the exit terms

A surrender schedule is a time horizon in table form. A few questions help match it to your situation:

  • How long is the money available? Compare the surrender period with when you expect to need the funds. Our page on who might consider a MYGA treats time horizon and liquidity in more depth.
  • What other money covers emergencies? A MYGA is generally not an emergency fund, and an emergency may arrive in year one when the charge is highest.
  • Could laddering help? Spreading money across several guarantee periods can create access at intervals without exiting a contract. See MYGA laddering.
  • What about taxes if you leave? The ordering rule and any 10 percent additional tax change the real cost of an early withdrawal, beyond the surrender charge.
  • Is the insurer sound? Exit terms assume the insurer can pay. See insurer ratings and state guaranty associations. Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank deposits, and are not FDIC-insured.

If you would like to go through a contract’s exit terms with someone, you can reach us through our contact page. This page is educational and is not tax, legal or investment advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a typical MYGA surrender charge?

It varies by contract. NAIC’s 2022 guide says the charge is a percentage of the amount taken out that usually goes down each year until the surrender charge period ends, and the newer NAIC guide says the period is often 5 to 10 years, sometimes longer. The actual percentages are in your contract’s schedule, and we do not state current product terms here.

Can I take money out of a MYGA without paying a surrender charge?

Many contracts allow a limited free withdrawal each year, which NAIC’s 2022 guide says is usually up to 10 percent (the newer guide says generally 5 to 10 percent). Some contracts also allow interest-only withdrawals, and waivers may apply for events such as nursing home confinement or terminal illness. A free withdrawal can still be taxable, because earnings come out first for non-qualified money.

Will a market value adjustment always reduce my money?

No. An MVA can raise or lower the amount you receive depending on how interest rates have moved since you bought. If rates are higher when you withdraw, it could reduce the amount; if they are lower, it could increase it. Many contracts set a floor, and every MVA formula is different, so read the one in your contract.

Do surrender charges apply to a required minimum distribution?

It depends on the contract. Some contracts treat RMD withdrawals as an exception to the surrender charge, sometimes only through a systematic withdrawal program. Check the contract and ask the insurer before you take the distribution.

Does the surrender charge reduce my taxable gain?

For a partial withdrawal, IRC section 72(e)(3)(A) measures the gain using cash value determined without regard to any surrender charge, so the charge does not reduce the earnings treated as withdrawn. For a full surrender, IRS Publication 575 says the amount received is tax free to the extent of your unrecovered cost and the rest is taxable. A tax professional can confirm how this applies to your return.

What happens to a MYGA if the owner dies during the surrender period?

Many contracts pay the death benefit to the named beneficiary without a surrender charge, but the provision is contract-specific. Taxes can apply to the beneficiary on the earnings, and a named beneficiary can allow the contract to pass outside probate. Read the death benefit provision and ask the insurer how it treats any MVA.

Annuities are insurance contracts, not bank products. They are not FDIC-insured and are not a deposit, and guarantees depend on the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. State guaranty associations provide limited protection if an insurer fails. This page is general education, not tax, legal or investment advice; talk with a tax professional or attorney about your situation. Product features, availability and rules vary by insurer and by state, and we’re an independent agency, not affiliated with any government agency.

Ready to talk through your options?

It’s free, unbiased, and there’s no obligation.